Hey, I was looking through some old messages and found this gem from when I was discussing the challenge with P; I thought you may want it:
-I think celever and james will start a catfight, keeper will be off chasing a butterfly and reversor will do the challenge, but then the catfight catches up to him and keeper, in the act of catching the butterfly, stumbles onto victory.
-Keeper is, as I said, chasing butterflies, and that's why he's going to win. Even if he loses.
Butterflies are forever.
Some time later, you got your butterfly.