Attention: *** Trading Forum Discussion & Announcements ***:

[omahanime]

The Trade Council wants to improve the quality of feedback left. If you have ever dealt with a member but wished the previous feedback could have prepared you better for the negotiations. Was communication an issue? Were the cards not as described? Did their style of shipping did not match yours?

For these reasons we are urging members to adopt the following recommendation.

BLANK:

[b]Rating:[/b]
[b]Buyer/Seller/Trade:[/b]
[b]Communication:[/b]
[b]Description of Cards:[/b]
[b]Shipping:[/b]
[b]Overall:[/b]

Rating: Positive (+1), Neutral (0), Negative (-1)

Buyer/Seller/Trade (Choose 1, what you were or did in the transaction)

Communication: How were they at responding to your PM's? Did they tell you when they were shipping? Were they honest/dishonest about anything?

Description of Cards: Were cards described accurately?

Shipping: How fast did you receive your item? How was it packaged? (Poorly, Very Good, etc)

Overall/Additional Comments: Any other thoughts about the trade not provided above?


EXAMPLE REPUTATION:

Rating: Positive (+1)
Buyer/Seller/Trade: Trade
Communication: Great communication! PM me when cards were shipping and kept in contact the whole trade!
Descriptions of Cards: Cards were said to be near-mint and arrived that way!
Shipping: Quick, and very well packaged!
Overall/Additional Comments: N/A.



Rating: Neutral (0)
Buyer/Seller/Trade: Buyer
Communication: OK communication. Did not keep me too updated about the status of my items after payment was sent
Descriptions of Cards: Cards were said to be in mint condition and were.
Shipping: Very Slow Shipping, but packaged very well.
Overall/Additional Comments: Took over 2 weeks to receive my package with little to minimal communication. I would like more communication especially when dealing with money.


Just copy the blank form and paste into the feedback thread and fill in.

 

[omahanime]

RE: Changes to Feedback

Attention

Since no complaints were posted, everyone must be in agreement so:

Effective December 1, 2011 this is mandatory.

Any feedback left in any other format will receive a warning.

 

[Butterfly719]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

Wow, if I could "like" this post, I would! Awesome update to the ref system! The new feedback format is going to be extremely helpful in determining the type of trader you'll be dealing with.

 

[Zorua]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

Very, very good idea. I'm really liking the changes that are going on around the forum.

This new system will definitely improve how trades are done and reported back on

 

[Afro-G]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

I definitely like this change because I'm kind of tired of the "great trader +1" refs that are usually given out. I always try to say a little bit about the trade when I leave a ref and this will help others do the same.

 

[konter5683]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

So pretty much instead of Great trader +1 ref I now have to put

Rating:A++
Buyer/Seller/Trade:Trade
Communication:A+++
Description of Cards:A++
Shipping:A+++
Overall:A+++

 

[safariblade]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

No, you have to actually write out and explain how the trade went. With sentences.

 

[ESP]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

So pretty much instead of Great trader +1 ref I now have to put

Rating:A++
Buyer/Seller/Trade:Trade
Communication:A+++
Description of Cards:A++
Shipping:A+++
Overall:A+++

No, you have to actually write out and explain how the trade went. With sentences.

Exactly what safari said. There are even examples giving you a great idea of how to fill out the new form.

 

[konter5683]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

so

Rating: Posative
Buyer/Seller/Trade: Trade
Communication: Great
Description of Cards: Exact
Shipping: Fast
Overall: 5/5

 

[safariblade]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

Don't be difficult. You know exactly what we mean. There are examples.
"Fast." is not a sentence.

 

[ESP]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

No, you have to actually write out and explain how the trade went. With sentences.

so

Rating: Posative
Buyer/Seller/Trade: Trade
Communication: Great
Description of Cards: Exact
Shipping: Fast
Overall: 5/5

With sentences.

I'd suggest you cut it out with the whole "playing dumb" act.

 

[omahanime]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

so

Rating: Posative
Buyer/Seller/Trade: Trade
Communication: Great
Description of Cards: Exact
Shipping: Fast
Overall: 5/5

You can try that if you want, but do not be surprised when I warn you.

Don't be difficult. You know exactly what we mean. There are examples.
"Fast." is not a sentence.

Well said.

I'd suggest you cut it out with the whole "playing dumb" act.

No comment

 

[konter5683]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

You can try that if you want, but do not be surprised when I warn you.

Because as you can see I have been quite an active trader recently. I don't plan on leaving much feedback anyways. Warnings are only bad when they get about 70%

 

[AnthonyG]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

Oh hey your close to that goal now.

If you have nothing productive to say, no need to post.

 

[omahanime]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

Remember this becomes MANDATORY in 1 1/2 weeks.

 

[omahanime]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

Remember this becomes MANDATORY in 6 days.

 

[omahanime]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

Remember this becomes MANDATORY in 5 days.

Warnings will be issued for non-compliance.

 

[omahanime]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

Remember this becomes MANDATORY in 4 days.

Warnings will be issued for non-compliance.


So you might as well start doing it today.

 

[omahanime]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

Remember this becomes MANDATORY in 3 days.

Warnings will be issued for non-compliance.


So you might as well start doing it today.

 

[omahanime]

RE: Attention: Changes to Feedback

Remember this becomes MANDATORY in 2 days.

Warnings will be issued for non-compliance.


So you might as well start doing it today.