Elbow certainly refuted those bigger claims, (especially those on Focus Sash and Korrina), so I don't really need to go there. To say that just because not all decks utilize these cards don't make them less important. #FightingTypesMatter too ya know?
Seems like you and
@Elbow are debating a different otaku. S'what I get for having such a generic screen name.
Since what I wrote was pretty badly misunderstood, perhaps I shouldn't have opened with that joke. The
short version is my central point was
I think you sell the Fighting Type a bit short though.
There are definitely some spots where I wasn't very clear but a lot of the positions being attributed to me aren't mine. I thought the idea of your article was to discuss how things
might change post rotation. That means taking apart the game as it is now, breaking it down into different decks and Pokémon Types and such, then reassembling it after you've worked out the differences into something resembling the post rotation format.
@Elbow "refuted" me using points that don't actually stand up to scrutiny. I disagreed with your assessment a little, not a lot: I wasn't saying that
Korrina and
Focus Sash didn't matter to any deck, I was pointing out that they weren't a four-per-deck staple for all Fighting decks.
Focus Sash sounds like it would have been awesome post rotation... except as you two pointed out it was mostly to counter Night March (no longer Standard legal) and
Vespiquen (now much slower). Any deck has the option of including
Ariados post rotation would neuter
Focus Sash anyway.
Focus Sash rotating out is a huge deal, but at the same time are Fighting decks going to need it like they once did?
I did have a poorly worded sentence where I mentioned the two times (one quite unlikely, the other not uncommon) where
Skyla could be better than
Korrina; that was because most of the time it will be worse. Still that preserves the element of Item search (and expands it to include Stadiums). Pokémon search has to be handled by the same Items most decks use; that means less room for other stuff, but it doesn't mean the deck is non-functional. Things change, but they don't always change the same way. If various Fighting decks remain Tier 4 (as Elbow labeled them) I'm not going to blame that on lack of
Focus Sash and/or
Korrina. It will be the same reason as now; too many other decks just work
better. We haven't even considered how new cards like
Ninja Boy might change things. Now if you still believe me wrong... okay. You can choose to explain why I am wrong or you can leave it at that. Either is open to you. I
know I am not always right; still I'd at least like to be accurately identified as wrong for what I said, not how it was misconstrued.