(Financial Analysis of Boxes/Tins)
I feel that tins are different from collections, in a sense. With tins, they're typically reprints of EX's that are already in a set with alternate art and they're Black Star Promos specifically made for these tins. Also typically, they tend to be pretty decent EX reprints. (Take Volcanion EX for instance. That's a pretty good card to get on top of 4 packs.) So there
can be some value in tins. These collections, on the other hand, are a mixed bag. More often than not, the Promos have been of cards that aren't exactly playable, so there's not much value to the Promo competitively. So since players might not want to buy the product just for the Promo, who does that leave? Kids, those who might like the Pokemon on the Promo, and collectors.
As a collector, personally, it's become an annoyance seeing
so many Promos come out in "collections" that are $20 or more, especially when my luck with pulling anything decent from the packs has been abysmal. $20 here and there is fine, but if you're collecting the Promos and these "collections" come out frequently, that becomes hard to keep up with, and buying the singles online becomes a better solution. (And those Mega EX Promos? I really wanted Diancie EX & M Diancie EX and Absol EX & M Absol EX, but wow--$40? And they're not too playable? I don't care how many packs were included; I'm not paying that.)
The thing is, it's irksome seeing the plethora of "collections" for $20+, especially if you see how those same Promos are handled in Japan. In Japan, it definitely
seems more like they have their customers and fans in mind when they give you a Promo for buying a certain amount of products or for just showing up somewhere, or even just buying inexpensive products. Whereas with TPCi, it comes off as throwing a random Promo into box with 4 packs, calling it a "collection" and charging $20 or more
because they can.
I'm certainly not trying to argue or anything.
This has just been bugging me for the past year or so, especially after seeing those Charizard, Dragonite, etc. "collections" and now Snorlax GX (which I think giving it as a preorder bonus for Sun and Moon is a great idea) being tossed into yet another $20 "collection".
Your post is too long to do a quote reply too
.
Oops. I guess I ranted a bit too much. Ha ha.
(As I did again in this entire post...)
Personally, I think having a card as a preorder bonus is a great idea. I definitely see your point, though. My thoughts are that it
could open some people up to the TCG. Maybe someone who hasn't seen the cards since Gen 1 gets this and is like, "What
is this craziness? This is awesome!" And they look into the TCG. Or maybe a kid gets this card and is
introduced to the TCG. But of course, like you said, there will be those who will be like, "What
is this craziness? MEH." There could be tons of people like that, and they just sell it on eBay or something; it might become fairly common with the amount of games that are undoubtedly going to sell. (Or maybe not, with your example. Ha ha.) I don't think this should be done with every Pokemon game, but Sun and Moon seemed (to me) like a really good opportunity to promote the TCG.
Yeah, that's why I had to assume there could be licensing issues outside of Japan (possibly other issues). Not a great solution, but I had to mention that little things like that in Japan are neat. And I didn't mean Promos given at league are THE solution. (I hope it didn't sound like that.) I just can't help but notice there aren't ANY Black Star Promos given at leagues. And really, aside from that Magikarp, there aren't any Promos being given out in order to
promote the TCG. And that's what I was trying to get at. It would be nice to see the TCG continue to grow, and
maybe some free promos here and there could help.
And I agree. None of the solutions are perfect. But $20 box after $20 box has become tiring and expensive, including those $30 to $50+ boxes too. Buying singles has become the best way to keep up with them, and that's kind of a shame. One thing I didn't mention, though, is cheaper products with Promos included. We have those single and three pack blisters; I buy those. Why can't we get more like those? Is it because some Promos are EX's and we need a comically over-sized box to show off how much more special-er it is than other Promos and thus justifying the $20 price tag?