Finished Werewolf XXIX: Melee - Finished!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jabberwock though, was very hesitant to vote IE yesterday and the evidence was there. I don't know if it's just cos he's new? But he's reading scum to me.

##vote: Jabberwock
Jabber is town.

My leads for the moment:
TFP - Hasn't been too active since we lost Camo. Late on both the IE and Drac wagons and didn't vote Yeowie at all.
SilverSilent - Was verbal during the IE wagon, but always on the fence. Didn't vbote IE or Drac, voted Yeowie after slip.
double o squirtle - Short posts, not overly helpful. Didn't vote Drac and voted Yeowie after slip.

For now:
##VOTE double o squirtle
 
Mewtwo claimed to be the journalist... His latest article seemed scummy...

TFP reads strong town after having no clue what was scummy about Drac's slip... Very noob town!

SS2 always reads scummy, his natural playstyle is super hesitant so could be that but yeah hesitancy doesn't really get us anywhere.

And yeah I thought Camo was sold on double squirtle being noob town as well.

So not including my scum read of Reinforce then SS2 seems like a strong bet. Considering scum are night killing active people reinforce may be a better bet considering he's less active than ss2
 
Also Vom is probably mewtwo. He's probably scum haha...
Vom outed Yeowie, doubtful he's scum.
Mewtwo claimed to be the journalist... His latest article seemed scummy...

TFP reads strong town after having no clue what was scummy about Drac's slip... Very newbie town!

SS2 always reads scummy, his natural playstyle is super hesitant so could be that but yeah hesitancy doesn't really get us anywhere.

And yeah I thought Camo was sold on double squirtle being newbie town as well.
I think Mewtwo might be indie, actually. He did confirm Vom's ability for us (so Vom could be Mewtwo, but that still doesn't make him scum).
You're right on all other counts, but just because Camo thought something doesn't make it fact.

So not including my scum read of Reinforce then SS2 seems like a strong bet. Considering scum are night killing active people reinforce may be a better bet considering he's less active than ss2
RF voted Yeowie before his slip. That's what keeps me hesitant on him.
 
I haven't been too active over the past week because I've been really busy. I've had strong scum reads on reinforce since day 1 and I've just received information that has led me to believe he is scum. I haven't read up on what's happening yet so I'm just going to vote him for now

##VOTE REINFORCE
 
I haven't been too active over the past week because I've been really busy. I've had strong scum reads on reinforce since day 1 and I've just received information that has led me to believe he is scum. I haven't read up on what's happening yet so I'm just going to vote him for now

##VOTE REINFORCE
Do share then, because unless you actually have evidence this only adds to my suspicion on you.
 
I've seen one of his abilities. And I think it could be scum

Here it is.

Active Ability: Oil Spill
[LOCKED]
This ability will unlock when you are targeted by 3 energy-based abilities.

It's obvious that he is game and watch. It isn't directly scum but it's very likely that a scum player could have a kill ability, and it think once he's absorbed them he can peform a kill.
 
Alright... So in smash, oil spill is an Instakill ability after 3 energy attacks! I really thought that ness would be the reason for the specification between energy and non energy attacks, but clearly it's game and watch.

Assuming Oil Spill is some sort of kill power, and bbninjas as Roy flipped vigilante, then that'd make RF scum (unless for whatever reason there are two killing town players...)

##unvote: Jabberwock
##vote: Reinforce


@Reinforce what's your thoughts on th game so far, especially in relation to the ability TFP has claimed you have. Who are your biggest reads right now?
 
I second Keeper, that Ability does look suspicious.

I'm mixed about the Mewtwo stuff, since his other messages weren't that... hostile, I guess? And I don't think Vom is Mewtwo, confirming himself isn't that good of an idea.
 
TheFancyPineapple's claim is correct.

You are Mr. Game & Watch, and you are aligned with The Game. You are an odd character, with strong attacks, but the inability to L-Cancel your aerials and the fact that your shield doesn't cover your feet is an issue.

Active Ability: Fire!
Once a night, you may PM me the name of 2 players. You will summon your flat friends carrying their trampoline, and they will propel your first target in the air, and they will spy on the other one and report back to you. When the next day starts, both of you will learn who that player targeted.

Active Ability: Oil Spill
[LOCKED]
This ability will unlock when you are targeted by 3 energy-based abilities.

Win Condition: All members of Master Hand’s Minions are eliminated.

I'm the Tracker, basically. It has a resemblance to scattered mind's ability in that another person will be shared what I learn. Due to some bad luck, I haven't gotten good results from it so far. It's almost always that one of my two required targets ends up night killed lol. But after I got strong town vibes from Vom after Yeowie had the scumslip of the decade, I've targeted Vom since then, for the past two nights. He's probably winded from all the flinging and spying I've made him do :p

My first ability hasn't gotten me any concrete information (the ability fails when one of the two targets died), but if you want the full details, I'll give it if someone asks for it nicely.

And before you guys ask, the Oil Spill ability is still locked. Considering the condition requires me to be targeted and yet I'm not the type of WW player to attract people's attention or target with abilities, I'm not surprised that it hasn't unlocked yet. And since I'm not familiar with Mr. Game & Watch or Melee in general, I have no definite idea on what the Oil Spill ability will do once it does unlock. If it does sound scummy, it's out of my hands, and I'll just shrug to any of you who thinks it does.

Now, to other posts:
You two are my biggest scum reads right now. Reinforce cos you haven't been very active and your posts have been very few in number.

If you consider me scummy due to having a low number of posts, then I'll have to disagree. I prefer quality over quantity when it comes to my posts, and it has been that way since I started Pokebeach WW. My timezone is also a factor on why it happens, but I'm not going to say that's a major reason. And frankly, I think that's illogical accusation. If having a low number of posts is a scumminess indicator, then we shouldn't even bother reading and analyzing each other's posts and instead just look at each player's post count in the thread and vote for the one with the fewest posts (which is what you're insinuating and your basis for saying I'm scummy) --- Does this sound logical at all? No, and that's why I won't accept an accusation with this reasoning.

But if you're going to change that accusation of yours to say that my scumminess is about my posts themselves instead, whether it's the content or the timing of when I posted them, then feel free to quote and point them out to me, and explain clearly why I'm scummy based on them.

As for your second question about my player reads so far...

My scum reads:

Squirtle Squad - I suspected you due to bringing up accusation near the end of yesterday, which had 'going after you if you're wrong' tone on PMJ, who I read as town. And today he ended up dead. Did you go ahead with that "threat", hmm? I'm also suspicious with your reason for pointing me as scummy... but you did hop early on Yeowie before his slip (along with Camoclone and me) and that's why I'm currently on the fence about you and am not voting or directly going after you yet.

Luispipe8 - because the original Team Magma scum from last game are scum in this game too LOL In the first few days, he basically popped up, left a vote and said he'll post more thoughts later, which didn't really solidify for me. He was more active yesterday, but he's still in the upper half of my suspect list.

Town reads: Vom, TheFancyPineapple, Camoclone, Keeper of Night

Uncertain reads but leaning Town: SilverSilent

Uncertain reads: double o squirtle, Jabberwock
 
Active Ability: Fire!
Once a night, you may PM me the name of 2 players. You will summon your flat friends carrying their trampoline, and they will propel your first target in the air, and they will spy on the other one and report back to you. When the next day starts, both of you will learn who that player targeted.
I don't like how this is worded.

My first ability hasn't gotten me any concrete information (the ability fails when one of the two targets died), but if you want the full details, I'll give it if someone asks for it nicely.
I highly recommend you just give it to us anyway.

##VOTE: Reinforce
 
And before you guys ask, the Oil Spill ability is still locked. Considering the condition requires me to be targeted and yet I'm not the type of WW player to attract people's attention or target with abilities, I'm not surprised that it hasn't unlocked yet. And since I'm not familiar with Mr. Game & Watch or Melee in general, I have no definite idea on what the Oil Spill ability will do once it does unlock. If it does sound scummy, it's out of my hands, and I'll just shrug to any of you who thinks it does.
I don't like this. I haven't played Melee either, but it's not hard to look up 'Oil Spill' – or rather, Oil Panic, which is what I found it as. That's not hard to find either, though, after looking up Oil Spill. It appears to be capable of up to 200% damage in Melee with variable knockback, which sounds like a pretty scummy ability.

##VOTE: Reinforce
 
I don't like how this is worded.

That's something you'll have to take up with the game hosts, then.

And sure I might be more thorough in researching what Oil Spill would do in another situation, but like I said, due to the unlocking conditions, I had low hopes of it unlocking, so it wasn't going to be entirely useful speculating about it. I instead decided that I'll just wait for if by some miracle it will unlock and I'll find out what it does then.

I highly recommend you just give it to us anyway.

##VOTE: Reinforce

Okay, you did ask nicely.

Night 1 update:
TheFancyPineapple informed you that bbninjas did not target anybody last night.

Night 2 update:
You tried to make your flat friends fling scattered mind up into the air, but he was nowhere to be found!

Night 3 update:
Vom informed you that Athena was nowhere to be found last night.

Night 4 update:
Vom informed you that Squirtle Squad did not target anybody last night.

Some notes: The Night 1 choices were not made by me, but Empoleon_master whom I replaced. Night 2 and Night 3 failed because they were nightkilled. I tried to track Squirtle Squad Night 4 because I suspected him as I said in my previous post.

I don't like this. I haven't played Melee either, but it's not hard to look up 'Oil Spill' – or rather, Oil Panic, which is what I found it as. That's not hard to find either, though, after looking up Oil Spill. It appears to be capable of up to 200% damage in Melee with variable knockback, which sounds like a pretty scummy ability.

##VOTE: Reinforce

Even if it does that in Melee, we don't know how exactly it will translate as an Ability into a Werewolf Game.
 
I'll have to be going now, but here's something that I've just received.

Your ability name should definitely be "Oil Panic" as opposed to "Oil Spill". It's a minor detail, but you can quote this post if you want.

Interpret that however you wish.

I've laid out all of my cards for this game.

Now, I've counted 4 votes on me, which means I'm close to being lynched, or perhaps I already am if there are modified vote weights out there. Regardless, I have to go now and sleep because I have to go to work in 4 hours. But I'll be back here after work as long as the Day is not over. But if you guys are already decided and don't want to hear from me anymore and so turbolynch me before I can get back from work, there's nothing I can do about that, and I'm aware that it can happen (see previous WW game). But if you have questions for me that you want me to answer and you're willing to wait, I'll be back home from work 15 hours from the time of this post. Just a heads up.

See ya.
 
I've targeted Vom since then, for the past two nights.
I confirm this.
He's probably winded from all the flinging and spying I've made him do :p
I also confirm this :U

I'm not too sure on RF tbh. Of course, it would be weird that there are two vigilantes, but it would be equally weird if there was a scum vigilante (I've never seen one so far.) Also, even though his Ability (the Fire! one) is actually true, it /could/ always be a provable safe claim, but I doubt it.

I'd really rather not lynch someone on what an ability could do, especially if we don't know what it actually does; or on the way it's worded unless it's utter nonsense and messy.
 
##unvote: Reinforce

We are close to a lynch so I don't want anyone potentially hammering (especially one with a double vote!)

Why is his first ability called fire? Doesn't quite make sense for what it does... Also it doesn't say anywhere in your ability that it fails if one of your targets is killed...

Apart from that his claim is believable enough, and I can confirm that I didn't target anyone in Night 4 like he has claimed...
 
Why is his first ability called fire? Doesn't quite make sense for what it does... Also it doesn't say anywhere in your ability that it fails if one of your targets is killed...

Fire is Mr Game & Watch's up special and is basically the description of the ability minus the spying on the other person part. Also when he says it fails if one of them dies, I think it just means that you can't spy on anyone because they're "dead".

Oh and I can confirm him spying on scattered mind on night 2 is true (well if my logic is correct).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top