BW/BW2 White or Soul Silver?

Which one should I get?

  • Total voters
    19
P

pokemeister899

VM if you want to play ACNL with me!
Member
I got good grades this school year and I can get a new video game.

So I decided on either White or Soul Silver. My question is, which one?

I have Black, Platinum, Heart Gold, and Ruby. Which one would be the best choice in terms of starter and legendary Pokemon? I want White so I can get more Unova legendaries, and I want Soul Silver because I want more Johto and Kanto starter Pokemon, and another Pokewalker(I lost the one that came with HG). Also. please dont say both, or suggest another game.

Also, I'm not worrying about the price, so dont suggest based on that.

And I dont have wifi for my ds, so dont suggest based on "getting pokemon over the GTS", either.
 
Well, i guess ss. It has good gameplay and others. You already have black which is better than white in my opinion
 
We cant really decide for you but Il say what I think. I would have to say white because its newer, has many differences from black and you get Zekrom which you cant in black. soul silver on the other hand only really gives you latias/latios and some more starters. And with a propable R/S/E remake on the way, its really just the starters which you can get on GTS anyway. I vote for white. (this also does not really belong here, propably general discussion would be better for future refference)
 
Well I'm not worrying about the Hoenn starters or Latios/Latias, I already have them all. Its just that I'm wanting more Kanto and Johto starters.
(btw I put this in 5th gen because im talking about a 5th gen game)
 
Well, GTS is good for that, I feel that if the starters are the only benefit from SS, then white is the much better option.
(Yeah, but your also talking about a 4th gen game so this is kind of general)
 
I do want White for Zekrom and the old Opelucid city and White forest, but I also want SS for another Pokewalker, and more starter Pokemon.
 
If you want to complete the National Pokedex, go for White, since it has more Pokemon you can encounter, plus the migration system. If you want the Pokewalker and more starters, as you said, go for SS. Though I think you'd rather go for White, since you can catch most of the same Pokemon in HG and SS(in Soul Silver I caught a Caterpie in the Bug Catching Contest even though it says Area Unknown in SS).
 
I would go for White, since you get Zekrom and Thundurus, because that means that you can trade and get Landurous. Plus, HG and SS are almost exact copies, but Black and White aren't.
 
I say you should get white, you can get pokemon from other generations if your thinking about getting about finally getting Soul Silver.
 
Well most people are saying White, so I might go for that, but I really want a Spiritomb through the Pokewalker...
 
OK everyone, I decided on...

White, plus Vol. 1 of the official strategy guide. That is, if White doesnt sell out.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top