Dang it, the poll is loading from the website system's cache. I changed it right before I put it up and it's loading the old one, like with the news stories that never want to show up (because the cache did not have the story).
I reset the poll since the old options before I fixed it were showing up. Everyone vote again!
EDIT: The site is still not showing the fixed poll. Guess I'll have to reset it later when it decides to. The options are: Steelix, Lucario, Poliwrath, Magcargo, Surskit, Ludicolo, and Girafarig.