Project696 said:LuxChomp and SP's all started out as theorymon, TorterraTank a few years back, theorymon. To say theorymon almost never works is a horrible statement. The best statement is "Theorymon, the deadly disease in which you either crush the meta or fail miserably."
And I've been playtesting it against any and every deck, So far I've only found one that crushes it to oblivion, but thats a complete and other rogue deck. The ZPS match up is pretty much 50/50 so far. I'll just wait to show off my deck.
Then in that case, everything started as theorymon. I'm talking legit theorymons, that ARE theories and not backed by solid experimental data. If you're willing to bet that your strat is NOT theorymon, then you need to show your deck off to other people and have it tested by more than one person. As long as an idea stays with one person, it's theorymon, no matter how good it is.
And really, a rogue deck crushes your deck into oblivion but not any other meta deck? (Not counting the 50/50 ZPS). Please state that rogue deck if you can and that sounds awfully suspicious...and weird. Usually the reason meta decks are better than rogue decks is that they can do the same thing and more, so the fact that a rogue deck can beat your deck but not meta decks is very strange.