Ruling Charizard (Base) > Charizard (SF) ?

[Soul]

Hey,

Can I still play the Charizard from the Base Set ?

 

[TofU]

Yes, you can.

Although, you will simply need a Card-Dex Translation.

Hope I helped! ;]

 

[Soul]

Allright, thanks it helped me a lot =)

 

[charizard87]

actually if I recall correctly from talking to other professors a reference is not needed.

 

[TofU]

^^Why would it not be needed? The Base Set Charizard has a Poke-Body not a Poke-Power.

 

[Soul]

No, the Base Set one has a Poke-Power the SF one has a Poke-Body

 

[greenbeetless]

Just need to tell the other person about the errata.

 

[red blastoise]

oh, and base set specifies fire energy CARDS, SF specifies fire energy

 

[xxashxx]

The 2 Charizard cards are pretty much the same except for the Pokebody/Pokepower. I hope we can use all past cards because there was some pretty good cards made and it would be pointless not to use the past cards from Wizards of the Coast.

 

[Lou Cypher]

As far as I know, you will need a REFERENCE. greenbeetless, if you play a Base Set Charizard against me and you do not present me either a card-dex or a SF Charizard as reference, I will have you disqualified for playing illegal cards. Those are the rules, you can tell me all you want.

 

[Chairman Kaga]

The DQ rhetoric is a bit much.

The penalty for not having a reference is a Warning. However, you will be asked to replace the card with a basic Energy, since it is illegal unless you have the reference.

 

[Chairman Kaga]

FYI, POP updated the reprint list today.

Charizard requires a reference. Charmander and Charmeleon do not.