Finished cop5 - A Mafia Variant

[Machamp The Champion]

My result is that camoclone is innocent. Let's wait for the other 2 to report before we start voting.

 

[Keeper of Night]

It might even be better to not vote and wait another night.
Is NL a voting option PMJ?

 

[Camoclone]

Astra is scum... I got a guilty off him.
VOTE: ASTRA

 

[Camoclone]

Also... If for some weird reason Astra isn't lynched then everyone seer him tonight.

 

[PMJ]

no lynch is not an option. not like you guys need it anyway.

 

[Keeper of Night]

[soiler=sanity]Sane - Always correct
Insane - Always incorrect
Paranoid - Always guilty
Naive - Always innocent[/spoiler]

Camoclone, just because you got Astra as guilty (and so did I) doesn't mean he's bad.
We should wait for DNA to report his inspect before we vote anyone off.

 

[Camoclone]

[soiler=sanity]Sane - Always correct
Insane - Always incorrect
Paranoid - Always guilty
Naive - Always innocent[/spoiler]

Camoclone, just because you got Astra as guilty (and so did I) doesn't mean he's bad.
We should wait for DNA to report his inspect before we vote anyone off.

2 Astra Guilty's (sane and paranoid or insane and paranoid)
1 Camoclone town (sane or naive)
1 Fourarms town (anything)

What are the chances? I must say that I think four arms is naive...

 

[Machamp The Champion]

[soiler=sanity]Sane - Always correct
Insane - Always incorrect
Paranoid - Always guilty
Naive - Always innocent[/spoiler]

Camoclone, just because you got Astra as guilty (and so did I) doesn't mean he's bad.
We should wait for DNA to report his inspect before we vote anyone off.

2 Astra Guilty's (sane and paranoid or insane and paranoid)
1 Camoclone town (sane or naive)
1 Fourarms town (anything)

What are the chances? I must say that I think four arms is naive...

You or Keeper of Night could be lying though, so that doesn't really mean anything.

 

[Keeper of Night]

You make a good point. However, I'm holding my vote until we get all the results.

 

[Camoclone]

2 Astra Guilty's (sane and paranoid or insane and paranoid)
1 Camoclone town (sane or naive)
1 Fourarms town (anything)

What are the chances? I must say that I think four arms is naive...

You or Keeper of Night could be lying though, so that doesn't really mean anything.

We could... It's up to you to decide. We can honestly just lynch me today and then have everyone seer Astra tomorrow. Let me do the math real quick!

 

[DNA]

I blink, and there are about 30 new posts in this thread. This is what happens when I'm gone for one weekend. You all go crazy.

Still waiting for PMJ to get back to me about my results.

 

[DNA]

All right, back home again, finally. Now I can actually post well.

Not sure if it means anything, but I investigated Four Arms and he turned up innocent. I hear we're scrutinizing Astra right now? Fill me in; I've been gone basically the whole weekend.

 

[Keeper of Night]

Ok well... We have to vote. By lynching Astra me and camo can know which inspectors we are if wrong.
[v]Astra[/v]

 

[Machamp The Champion]

Okay, I analyzed it, and there are 2 possibilities. Let's take a look at the scenario's:

Astra is Mafia
Me: Sane or Naive
DNA: Sane or Naive
Keeper of Night: Sane or Paranoid
camoclone: Sane or Paranoid
There's no Insane Cop, so this is impossible.

Keeper or Night is Mafia
Me: Sane or Naive
DNA: Sane or Naive
Astra: Sane or Naive
camoclone: Insane or Paranoid
We can't share Sane and Naive between DNA, Astra and I, so this is also impossible.

I'm the Mafia
DNA: Insane or Naive
Astra: Insane or Naive
Keeper of Night: Insane or Paranoid
camoclone: Insane or Paranoid
This proves you have to be insane to think I'm the Mafia.

DNA is Mafia
Me: Sane or Naive
Astra: Sane or Naive
Keeper of Night: Insane or Paranoid
camoclone: Insane or Paranoid
This one is possible. Pretty self-explanatory.

camoclone is Mafia
Me: Insane or Naive
DNA: Sane of Naive
Astra: Sane or Naive.
Keeper of Night: Insane or Paranoid
This one's a little more complicated than the last one, but basically I'm Insane, KoN is Paranoid, and DNA and Astra are either Sane or Naive.

So basically we just lynch one than the other and then we win. camoclone is more suspicious in my eyes, since he tried to turbo-lynch Astra
VOTE: camoclone

 

[Keeper of Night]

Idc who is lynched D1, if it's wrong, then there is a good chance that we will find the mafia tomorrow if we're careful with our inspects.

 

[Keeper of Night]

So I meant to...
[v]Camoclone[/v]

 

[Professor Palutena]

camo is either paranoid or insane. Keeper of Night is the other.

DNA is either sane or naive. I'm the other.

Don't know anything from Four Arms yet.

Vote: camoclone

Pushing dat wagon on a game based on pure chance on day 1 is imho huge scumtell.

 

[DNA]

That, or camo is a terrible player, but he was told at the outset of the game that there is only 1 cop that gets correct reads, so...

VOTE: camoclone

I don't think ineptitude is even a proper response. I think Four Arms has the right idea. It's like one giant prisoner's dilemma.

 

[Camoclone]

What are the chances though that 2 people would seer Astra and get guilty?

 

[Camoclone]

That, or camo is a terrible player, but he was told at the outset of the game that there is only 1 cop that gets correct reads, so...

Ahhh... But the chances! Use your numbers DNA.