Final Games Poll

Pick your 2 favorites.

  • The Challenge

    Votes: 46 54.1%

  • Mushroom Mayhem

    Votes: 40 47.1%

  • Trivia of DNA

    Votes: 55 64.7%
  • Total voters
    85
  • Poll closed .
Shining Raikou

Shining Raikou

Your friendly neighborhood Raikou fan!
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
These 3 games are the frontrunners, please pick your 2 favorites.

I'll count the votes on Sunday at midnight EST.
 
Three games, that's it. Werewolf, and the top two from this poll.
 
SPM3 said:
You can't reopen all three of them and make everyone happy? :/
Click to expand...

Tyraniking said:
^Yeah, really. It's just one more game.
Click to expand...

If more than the 3 games we have made concessions for are opened, then everyone will have a "valid" case to get whatever game they like reopened. At that point, we might as well just reopen the whole Game Corner which is exactly the opposite of what we're trying to accomplish.
 
One more game =/= the entire game corner. That'd be like saying "Well I don't want to spend more than 10 dollars on this _____, and if I spend $10.01 then I may as well just spend all of my savings." I mean the members are the ones who wanted the game corner revamp in the first place. Now your making it even worse than BEFORE it was revamped. IMO the least you can do is just allow one more game. I'm sure I'm not alone in saying I'd be more active here if my favorite game was staying.
 
My favorite game was the Ban Game, but I'll still be plenty active without it.
 
The reason why we asked for one more is that, due to unforeseen circumstances, those three games ended up in pretty much a 3-way tie for first, with only marginal differences (2 votes or less difference).
In something like that I don't see how it's harmful to just declare those three the winner for this month around. And one more game, as was said before, is not that big of a deal, especially if you know all of them are going to be high-quality games.
 
It was guaranteed to remain; this was announced a few months prior.
 
ESP said:
If more than the 3 games we have made concessions for are opened, then everyone will have a "valid" case to get whatever game they like reopened. At that point, we might as well just reopen the whole Game Corner which is exactly the opposite of what we're trying to accomplish.
Click to expand...
Looking at the last poll, the three games featured each received about 22% of the votes. That's proof that these are the three games people want, and no game outside of these three has the same popularity.

I don't see why the addition of one game makes a huge difference. Its just one more game. If it was something like the addition of four more, I could understand. But I don't see the point in being irrational about just one more.
 
Because as soon as I allow one more game it's "one more this and one more that". I'm sticking to the plan. End of story.
 
ESP said:
If more than the 3 games we have made concessions for are opened, then everyone will have a "valid" case to get whatever game they like reopened. At that point, we might as well just reopen the whole Game Corner which is exactly the opposite of what we're trying to accomplish.
Click to expand...

Why three? Why not four? Why not two? Why not five? There's no reason behind it... If there's four popular games, there should be four games. I don't see what the big deal is.
 
I really want all of them to stay. The Challenge and MM are both competitions I guess you would say where you sign up and play. Trivia of DNA is different than that and does not require as much work as the others do. I honestly think we should keep all three, what are the reasons we can't have one more when they were practically tied last vote?
EDIT: Really SR? I don't actually think that is a reason. If there are four popular games, let there be four popular games.
 
Werewolf probably would've got more votes than any other game anyway. I would've voted for it, as would many others. It was one of the first games PB had on it that actually required a lot of thought to be put into posts.
 
Yeah, although I think that one more game isn't a big deal, Shining Raikou is right. If we added one more, everyone else would ask for their games to be added too because "it's just one more." Besides, everyone should be happy that we are getting any games instead of what easily could have been none.
 
Blah237 said:
Yeah, although I think that one more game isn't a big deal, Shining Raikou is right. If we added one more, everyone else would ask for their games to be added too because "it's just one more." Besides, everyone should be happy that we are getting any games instead of what easily could have been none.
Click to expand...

But it's not just one more. We voted and they all got a pretty even vote. They are all great games that I would like to see. It was obvious which RPG's wouldn't be staying, and some people who wanted their game to stay didn't get to keep it going and they had to just deal with it. Now we are down to the best and it's not just one person asking for a game to stay.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top