• Please read THIS THREAD if you are a new trader/seller.

    Thank you!

Has: old and new, including TORNADUS EX FA! Wants: a lot (now accepting bulk!)

RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

Add on the 1st edition holo Fossil Haunter, and it's a deal. :)
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

When we were negotiating before, you said you wanted to add the played Rocket's Zapdos - at that point I think I was up by around $2 on my side, but I value the Zapdos at $5 (that's how much I paid for it, and it's in usable condition) so then it was up by around $3 on your side, which is why I suggested to add the Pidgeot, which I value at $2 or so (one didn't sell for $1 two days ago on eBay) so I think what I posted above is the best I can do.

Let me know :)
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

My issue is the value of the Arcanine, and yours is the Zapdos. When we cut both, the remaining trade becomes surprisingly balanced...

My:

NM-M 1st Ed. Sabrina's Gengar $3
NM-M 1st Ed. Pidgeot $?
NM-M CG Blaziken ex $6 (slightly higher than the average auction; lower than the average auction + BiN)
Crap-tastic HL Kyogre ex $X

for

Exc-M 1st Ed Snorlax $?
Exc-M 1st Ed Giovanni's Machamp $2
Exc-M 1st Ed Giovanni's Persian $4
Exc-M 1st Ed Misty's Golduck $3
Slightly above crap-tastic Aerodactyl ex $X

I feel like Snorlax and Pidgeot are comparable exchanges for one-another (inconsistent cards that could both go all sorts of directions in value). Sabrina's Gengar is approximately equal to any one of the other three first editions, and then Blaziken ex CG is equal to the other two.

The difference in values is about as even as we can possibly get. Either way, LMK. :D
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

HI there,
I have the following from your wants:

Mysterious Treasures
Lumineon #11

Legends Awakened
Heatran LV.X

I am interested in any of your MINT, English EXs/Lv. Xs. Could you please check my list and see if there is anything else you need? thanks!
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

^ Not if you're valuing them at $1-$2 each, lol.
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

JEKyl said:
My issue is the value of the Arcanine, and yours is the Zapdos. When we cut both, the remaining trade becomes surprisingly balanced...

My:

NM-M 1st Ed. Sabrina's Gengar $3
NM-M 1st Ed. Pidgeot $?
NM-M CG Blaziken ex $6 (slightly higher than the average auction; lower than the average auction + BiN)
Crap-tastic HL Kyogre ex $X

for

Exc-M 1st Ed Snorlax $?
Exc-M 1st Ed Giovanni's Machamp $2
Exc-M 1st Ed Giovanni's Persian $4
Exc-M 1st Ed Misty's Golduck $3
Slightly above crap-tastic Aerodactyl ex $X

I feel like Snorlax and Pidgeot are comparable exchanges for one-another (inconsistent cards that could both go all sorts of directions in value). Sabrina's Gengar is approximately equal to any one of the other three first editions, and then Blaziken ex CG is equal to the other two.

The difference in values is about as even as we can possibly get. Either way, LMK. :D
Click to expand...

I'll get back to you soon :)
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

Do you have any first edition commons/uncommons/trainers/energy not listed/
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

Yessir, I do; in fact, I have a box of first edition base sitting just feet away from me.

Are your C/U wants listed in your thread?
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

How about your

1st Ed. Sabrina's Gengar
1st Ed. Pidgeot
LM Arcanine ex
CG Blaziken ex
HL Kyogre ex
EM Medicham ex

for

1st Ed Brock's Rhydon
1st Ed Erika's Clefable
1st Ed Haunter
1st Ed Snorlax
1st Ed Giovanni's Machamp
1st Ed Giovanni's Persian
1st Ed Misty's Golduck
Aerodactyl ex
Rocket's Zapdos ex
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

The Misty's Golduck and Haunter are being obtained in another trade - care to make a different offer?
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

Your

1st Ed. Sabrina's Gengar
1st Ed. Pidgeot
LM Arcanine ex
CG Blaziken ex
Metagross *

for

1st Ed Brock's Rhydon
1st Ed Erika's Clefable
1st Ed Snorlax
1st Ed Giovanni's Machamp
1st Ed Giovanni's Persian
1st Ed Shining Magikarp
1st Ed Dark Feraligatr
Aerodactyl ex
Rocket's Zapdos ex
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

Hmmm, 'Gross just went yesterday, and Mew * delta is up on an ebay fixed price. In addition to that, I can't find my extra Cham ex. How about:

My:

1st Ed. Sabrina's Gengar
1st Ed. Pidgeot
CG Blaziken ex
HL Kyogre ex


for

1st Ed Brock's Rhydon
1st Ed Erika's Clefable
1st Ed Snorlax
1st Ed Giovanni's Machamp
1st Ed Giovanni's Persian
Aerodactyl ex
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

I can do

1st Ed. Sabrina's Gengar
1st Ed. Pidgeot
LM Arcanine ex
CG Blaziken ex

for

1st Ed Brock's Rhydon
1st Ed Erika's Clefable
1st Ed Snorlax
1st Ed Giovanni's Machamp
1st Ed Giovanni's Persian
Aerodactyl ex
 
RE: Wants Old Cards; Has Old and New! (UPDATE: more collectibles!!!)

I think the offer I have listed is pretty reasonable. If you feel like there's some slight value discrepancy, then I can toss in a "trade-up" Snorlax holo unlimited; however, I'm not keen on trading the Arcanine ex for less than $9-$10 worth of cards. If you can throw in two more 1st ed holos off of my list, then I might consider going with it.

So for review, my counter-offers:

A)

1st Ed. Sabrina's Gengar
1st Ed. Pidgeot
CG Blaziken ex
HL Kyogre ex
Snorlax Jungle holo unlimited


for

1st Ed Brock's Rhydon
1st Ed Erika's Clefable
1st Ed Snorlax holo
1st Ed Giovanni's Machamp
1st Ed Giovanni's Persian
Aerodactyl ex

B)

1st Ed. Sabrina's Gengar
1st Ed. Pidgeot
LM Arcanine ex
CG Blaziken ex

for

1st Ed Brock's Rhydon
1st Ed Erika's Clefable
1st Ed Snorlax
1st Ed Giovanni's Machamp
1st Ed Giovanni's Persian
x2 more 1st ed holos I need (tentative)
Aerodactyl ex

EDIT: noticed you had a Torchic star on your 'Gym thread. Care to make some offer that would include that instead? It ought to do a lot of the "heavy lifting" in our current trade.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top