PMJ
Silhouette Gloom of the Sundown Lands
Forum Head
Articles Head
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
Also, may I add that this tactic which is so risky is also very fitting for PMJ- he did a similar risky move in another game where he blocked his own kill using his scumbuddy which was a scum doctor.
There is a pretty big difference here; I have never suggested that I was confirmed or even probable town using the bb lynch as validation. In that game, my plan was to have the doctor protect the night kill and then come forward as the source of the protection, but Celever blocked the doctor and there went that plan.
Also, him targeting me still after I claimed to be in the basement- a host confirmed townie role- is a glaring and alarming point. PMJ should know that there was no need for me to out my partner- but he still insisted and pushed me to do that - "the only thing that will save you" - yet, when I said "ok here you go, it is unnecessary but whatever- it's Mariano" - he still pushed for my lynch. This is absurd and just confirms that all he wanted was to know who else was in the basement.
Yeah, because your play up to that point was abysmal and worthy of a lynch. It makes perfect sense if you're scum and to not come right out and say "you're wrong, I'm confirmed town, here's how I can prove this" is mind-boggling. If you would have quoted that bit from the basement QT straight away I would have backed off right away. I'm trying to think of how that could possibly be faked but I'm not seeing it. That would have gone a lot farther than just claiming you were town and offering up no proof when it was possible you were scum making a gambit and instead claiming your mason was the person I had pegged as scum alongside you.
You just don't leave a confirmed town alive-never.
How new are you? Scum can absolutely leave a confirmed townie alive if they think the doctor is going to protect them, knowing that the scum will likely go for the confirmed townie. It's classic wifom.
For Scattered Mind to claim the basement role without the knowledge that it could possibly be counter-claimed would be a dumb dumb mafia move.
My guess was that the real masons were barred from sharing that information. That's why they couldn't be cc'd. Also I didn't want to believe that the hosts would put three host-confirmable townies in this setup when analyzing reads and posts was supposed to be the name of the game.