Finished Mafia LIV: My Bastard Village-Game Over!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actualy Zone, you are last variable.

So let me ask it...
Are you town who turns scum when attacked?
Or some other role like that?
 
They are not outright classic town, but they are not scum with Math either.

What are they then in your opinion?
Another indie?
 
Seriously, either I'm blind or just unaware, what word censor am I breaking?

Dammit, this event actually looked fun.

I'm not able to read a lot of the thread right now so I'll probably give some thoughts soon, but wouldn't me claiming I'm Michael remove Zone's (albeit subtle) suspicion of me being scum?
 
For those who think I'm scum, I won the activity Day 3 that allowed me to pick a building. I chose the Constable's Office and Math as the target, and directly caused his lynch. I chose Math because he was flying under the radar, making him an ideal nightkiller choice if he's scum.

I really like Roz's theory. I was thinking the same thing regarding the haikus considering that we never saw any particular repercussions for breaking the haiku, but I was yet to think about other possible fake lines -- but the guilty child scenario makes sense. Problem: Why would the scum start the game trying to frame Drac?

-> I see...
-> What was your ability again?
I am able to stop people from participating in activities by posting a certain phrase in-thread.

-> Because of my pent up emotions. bbninjas said that it was irrational if I am town, and a potential ATE if I am scum. Mainly because someone stole the Easter Egg.
Not withstanding that the Easter Egg ordeal wasn't your fault, you can absolutely 'redeem' yourself by putting in the effort to lynch scum, and otherwise stopping trying to get yourself lynched. Aside, I find Zone's username (townidiot) absolutely hilarious and I am even less inclined to lynch him.
 
For those who think I'm scum, I won the activity Day 3 that allowed me to pick a building. I chose the Constable's Office and Math as the target, and directly caused his lynch. I chose Math because he was flying under the radar, making him an ideal nightkiller choice if he's scum.

I really like Roz's theory. I was thinking the same thing regarding the haikus considering that we never saw any particular repercussions for breaking the haiku, but I was yet to think about other possible fake lines -- but the guilty child scenario makes sense. Problem: Why would the scum start the game trying to frame Drac?


I am able to stop people from participating in activities by posting a certain phrase in-thread.


Not withstanding that the Easter Egg ordeal wasn't your fault, you can absolutely 'redeem' yourself by putting in the effort to lynch scum, and otherwise stopping trying to get yourself lynched. Aside, I find Zone's username (townidiot) absolutely hilarious and I am even less inclined to lynch him.
Myquilty cild reveal should not be related to scum action as it is my own ability.
 
Problem: Why would the scum start the game trying to frame Drac?

They didn't.
Imo it would be used more to show "look, I have an ability" if it was truth for Drac's case.

Cause let's be realistic, beside that one ability wich could end up as any message, Math didn't really have anything to claim.

Haikus on the other hand were "revealed". By whom? By host? It is formulated more like someone revealed it and yet noone claimed it.
 
So once again - bb saying that scum decided to use haiku for vig requierment is clearing him, cause scum wanted us to be distracted by it.

And actually succesfuly - like it took me 2 days to [forbiden word] why messanger can't be town. (But yeah, haikus + rhymes afterwards were TERRIBLE combination).

Firekitten claims they need to win events and theirs flavor username is "PartyAnimal" so I'm gonna accept it.
I don't really see them as possible NK since there was only one kill every night and I don't really see different wincons for indie with this name.

Zone is not scum. Or at least not now/main faction. However I heavily suspect them of role wich switches alignments when attacked.
Basicly a traitor.
However, if that is truth - I doubt he switched aligment yet, cause there was always a night kill and most likely cause scum was being scared to do it. (It's wine but I doubt scum would risk attacking someone who wants to be attacked)

That leaves Aqua, Violet and Draclord.
 
Can you explain your choice to scan Roz instead of Zone again?
I did change to Zone from my original target then reconsider back once more when I read Luis' point. I dare not reveal who I would target as I don't want some weird ability (if any) to trigger when they know my intended target.
 
Oh, I don't even have tu submit. Nice.
Same here. I don't want to participate the first game.
Actualy Zone, you are last variable.

So let me ask it...
Are you town who turns scum when attacked?
Or some other role like that?
They are not outright classic town, but they are not scum with Math either.

What are they then in your opinion?
Another indie?
If they are neutral they are doing a great job at being neutral, they are trying to use their role.
I'm not a neutral, nor a lone wolf scum.
Y'all simply forget where I come from. I get that you two might be confused, but bbninjas should know what I'm talking about. If not, then y'all should remember what I said about my homeforum.
I'm not able to read a lot of the thread right now so I'll probably give some thoughts soon, but wouldn't me claiming I'm Michael remove Zone's (albeit subtle) suspicion of me being scum?
Oh. Huh. That's actually a good point.
Which means that one person among NICK and bbninjas is confirmed town...
...too much thinking. Rather, how did you and bbninjas even get acquainted? If NICK's through your ability, firekitten through the event, then how did you start communicating with bbninjas?
I am able to stop people from participating in activities by posting a certain phrase in-thread.
Oh. Right. Go to school thing.
...yeah, fair point. That is indeed weak compared to firekitten's and my ability.
Not withstanding that the Easter Egg ordeal wasn't your fault, you can absolutely 'redeem' yourself by putting in the effort to lynch scum, and otherwise stopping trying to get yourself lynched. Aside, I find Zone's username (townidiot) absolutely hilarious and I am even less inclined to lynch him.
...I still wish you are scum. (Is this even possible? I already forget why you are leaning town though. ...roz, a quick reminder please.)
Myquilty cild reveal should not be related to scum action as it is my own ability.
...hm? Say, am I the only one who think this is weird? If the Guilty Child is actually part of Drac's ability, then how did MathBlade know about it?
However I heavily suspect them of role wich switches alignments when attacked.
Basicly a traitor.
Sorry to disappoint you. You're still wrong.
...unless NP can make that happen out of nowhere, in which case I have no problems with it. (Though I will still kill the one who took the Easter Egg...)
 
...hm? Say, am I the only one who think this is weird? If the Guilty Child is actually part of Drac's ability, then how did MathBlade know about it?

I reveal that part of my role after the host add the missing information from first update
 
Sorry to disappoint you. You're still wrong.
...unless NP can make that happen out of nowhere, in which case I have no problems with it. (Though I will still kill the one who took the Easter Egg...)

Don't have to be a traitor as a traitor.
It's more like... I don't think that only reason to ask to be killed is being mad.
You seemed like you had some plan behind it. Could be other role-based thing.
Paranoid Gun Owner to kill scum?
Bulletproof to waste theirs kill?

The thing is - I do believe that you was asking to be killed for real, it wasn't fake, but I can't really pinpoint the full reason why you was doing it in the first place.

I'm guessing your ability would answer this question, but not sharing it might be smarter.
 
Let's go further to the 3 in question: Drac, Violet, Aqua.

We can be sure that scum decided to give vote immunity to Aqua.
Everyone should have been voting Math. Aqua, however, got 2 votes - Math and someone else.

No one claiming it means that it was most likely a scum vote.
But... since we can't vote them anyway, we will have to leave it for another day (which may not come if we misslynch today, welp).

It should be 4 vs 2 vs 1 rn.
Misslynch makes it 2 vs 2 vs 1, so MyLo. Possibly even worse if my traitor Zone theory is right (Since it would lose a townie and GAIN a scum), but... welp again.
Scum would have to wifom it, so it's still somehow good. Plus I don't really think FK will betray me anytime soon (love ya ~<3).

The 3 revealed votes had 2 people of wich aligment we already know anyway. I'm still wondering if Violet was revealed as this "3rd" scum, who voted Math for towncred, when other 2 voted for Aqua. And it would make sense with haiku as well, so I'm kinda most inclined to them being scum rn.
 
That's actually my whole PoV rn, and the theory which I believe is close to gamesolving, but still misses a few puzzles.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top