Finished Mafia XLVIII: Motfia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Who even voted for gekki in the first place anyway?

If it was BB, then he could have been mafia becouse whenever anyone votes for gekki, he just blows up and pretty much kills himself because people vote for him.
 
The Last Shaymin said:
Who even voted for gekki in the first place anyway?

If it was BB, then he could have been mafia becouse whenever anyone votes for gekki, he just blows up and pretty much kills himself because people vote for him.
Click to expand...
Lorde, Firo, Nick, TE, you, and myself (though mine was for securing a lynch, not because I wanted to).

BB is looking bad for wagon distancing by not actually having his vote on Gekki despite making a case on him and saying he dropped his point on me.
 
This happened in the last mafia too. bb aggrivates gekki somehow, and then he blows up, we all vote for him, and then he dies and the mafia wins.

We should stop this.
 
The Last Shaymin said:
I think bb may be a mafian because he sparked the arguement between gekki and whoever else, and he pretty much started the incorrect bandwagon.
Click to expand...

The Last Shaymin said:
Who even voted for gekki in the first place anyway?
Click to expand...

Yeah, I voted for Gekki because he read to me as scum (which sounds really mean out of context). The entire bit with Lorde dragged on for so long that I got tired and frustrated of seeing it. I voted for him in RVS, I think, then changed to T_E, then back to Gekki.

Also, to any player, what's MYLO mean? I know what it stands for (Mislynch You Lose), but like, does it mean that if the wrong person is lynched, that the game is done?
 
GrandPanacea said:
Yeah, I voted for Gekki because he read to me as scum (which sounds really mean out of context). The entire bit with Lorde dragged on for so long that I got tired and frustrated of seeing it. I voted for him in RVS, I think, then changed to T_E, then back to Gekki.

Also, to any player, what's MYLO mean? I know what it stands for (Mislynch You Lose), but like, does it mean that if the wrong person is lynched, that the game is done?
Click to expand...
I think so. There has to be 4 mafians in this game, or maybe 3 with an ability that allows them to steal a vote.
 
GrandPanacea said:
Also, to any player, what's MYLO mean? I know what it stands for (Mislynch You Lose), but like, does it mean that if the wrong person is lynched, that the game is done?
Click to expand...
The issue with MYLO as a term is that it varies. Some times, it's mislynch and you will lose. Others, it's mislynch and you lose unless doctor protects. And in others, it's mislynch and possibly lose if all night actions go badly.
 
The Last Shaymin said:
I think so. There has to be 4 mafians in this game, or maybe 3 with an ability that allows them to steal a vote.
Click to expand...
That sounds like a devious ability. o: I like it.

NinjaPenguin said:
The issue with MYLO as a term is that it varies. Some times, it's mislynch and you will lose. Others, it's mislynch and you lose unless doctor protects. And in others, it's mislynch and possibly lose if all night actions go badly.
Click to expand...
Ahh, gotcha, thanks.
 
MYLO at the beggining of Day 2? That means there are 4 mafians? We need to be careful.
Gekki flipped town, so there is a decent chance that people who wanted him dead is scum, I would go after those ones.
 
Oh wait, just realized that quaking wasn't nightkilled, only his role was revealed. And we are at MYLO? I really don't understand. Are there 5 mafians?
 
NinjaPenguin said:
Lorde, Firo, Nick, TE, you, and myself (though mine was for securing a lynch, not because I wanted to).
Click to expand...
You know, you didn't need to hammer, the rule that we largely agree on (where a simple majority is required) is not in this game.
BB is looking bad for wagon distancing by not actually having his vote on Gekki despite making a case on him and saying he dropped his point on me.
Click to expand...
I actually agree with this. He also said he'd lay down his vote on Gekki and made some massive wall posts, when he never actually committed a vote.

However, the same can be said about yourself, though to a lesser extent.
The Last Shaymin said:
I think so. There has to be 4 mafians in this game, or maybe 3 with an ability that allows them to steal a vote.
Click to expand...
A steal a vote wouldn't put us in MYLO, especially since they need the actual numbers (not just votes, people actually aligned with them) to push that so soon. There have to be 4 mafians, which is ridiculous in a 12 player set-up.
Mariano11887 said:
Oh wait, just realized that quaking wasn't nightkilled, only his role was revealed. And we are at MYLO? I really don't understand. Are there 5 mafians?
Click to expand...
No, PMJ said there're 10 players alive. Quaking's dead, though the flavor makes it look like otherwise.
 
Lord o da rings said:
You know, you didn't need to hammer, the rule that we largely agree on (where a simple majority is required) is not in this game.

I actually agree with this. He also said he'd lay down his vote on Gekki and made some massive wall posts, when he never actually committed a vote.

However, the same can be said about yourself, though to a lesser extent.

A steal a vote wouldn't put us in MYLO, especially since they need the actual numbers (not just votes, people actually aligned with them) to push that so soon. There have to be 4 mafians, which is ridiculous in a 12 player set-up.

No, PMJ said there're 10 players alive. Quaking's dead, though the flavor makes it look like otherwise.
Click to expand...
Hammer was to prevent last second vote shenanigans; that rule doesn't exist.

And this false equivalency is what makes you look so scummy. BB said Gekki was the best lynch and I was bad and didn't actually vote the way he said was best nor gave reason not to. I said Lorde was the best lynch and voted Gekki to prevent shenanigans despite not wanting to.
 
NinjaPenguin said:
Hammer was to prevent last second vote shenanigans; that rule doesn't exist.

And this false equivalency is what makes you look so scummy. BB said Gekki was the best lynch and I was bad and didn't actually vote the way he said was best nor gave reason not to. I said Lorde was the best lynch and voted Gekki to prevent shenanigans despite not wanting to.
Click to expand...
I think you already established that anyone who tried to pull anything was dead, there was no necessity for it, and anyone stupid enough to do anything was good as dead since you were watching the thread like a hawk. And the rule has been in some of the recent games, and I think the idea was proposed by scattered in the main FG discussion thread. Should be in every game, tbh.

I can't seem to find anywhere where you specified leaning either way.
 
Lord o da rings said:
I think you already established that anyone who tried to pull anything was dead, there was no necessity for it, and anyone stupid enough to do anything was good as dead since you were watching the thread like a hawk.
Click to expand...
You say that but Nick called me a blockhead for my idea so wtv.
Lord o da rings said:
I can't seem to find anywhere where you specified leaning either way.
Click to expand...
After I gave Gekki that last chance, I was pretty assured he wasn't the best lynch. Post where you can tell my leaning is here:
NinjaPenguin said:
One minutes until Gekki hammer. Don't want it, but a lynch is better than none and I don't want any shady business.
Click to expand...

Also, BB explicitly said what was best and still didn't vote it. That's really different.
 
On mobile; bbn didn’t vote because he was asleep and by the time he had woken back up, the votes had piled up on Gekki and NP had hammered him, so... I didn’t vote him before I went to sleep because my vote would have put him dangerously close to the hammer mark.
 
bbninjas said:
On mobile; bbn didn’t vote because he was asleep and by the time he had woken back up, the votes had piled up on Gekki and NP had hammered him, so... I didn’t vote him before I went to sleep because my vote would have put him dangerously close to the hammer mark.
Click to expand...
Gekki was at L-3 and you had a VW of 1 yesterday. Putting someone at L-2 isn't dangerously close.
 
Confirming quaking is dead via the mafia's factional kill. Long story short the flavor doesn't allow for everyone to go to bed so this was my workaround.

I didn't update the OP because I had an appointment I was running late for and didn't want to make you guys wait for me. The OP is updated.

If town doesn't lynch scum today, it's over, no questions asked.
 
so what do we do? if there are 4 mafias like everyone is saying then there is a 40% chance we can pull through off of a random guess but that would make no sense as we would be putting it up to dumb luck i saw NP suggest a massclaim and i feel like in this situation that might be our best option
 
TOTAL_EPICNESS said:
so what do we do? if there are 4 mafias like everyone is saying then there is a 40% chance we can pull through off of a random guess but that would make no sense as we would be putting it up to dumb luck i saw NP suggest a massclaim and i feel like in this situation that might be our best option
Click to expand...
Man, random guessing is a dumb idea. This isn't RVS. 40% chance of hitting scum. That's a 60% chance of hitting town and instantly losing. I'm not gonna hinge my bets on random chance. I wanna actually play this game, since it's my first time. I'd really rather not have it cut short due to someone thinking a 40% chance is a good idea.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top