Oh ok thanks Lord
I still think your scum
Just kidding
I still think your scum
Just kidding
Finished Mafia XLVIII: Motfia
- Thread starter PMJ
- Start date
- Status
Regarding Gekki:
Gekki says that TE is not new, reasoning with the 2 past mafia games, which isn't particularly weird. The tipping point was using Discord mafia to further justify this, which is weird, because Gekki would know that forum mafia and Discord mafia are very different.
Another weird thing is that he claims TE is the only semi-valid lynch option, as justification. That firstly shouldn't prevent Gekki from looking elsewhere! Besides, I've pointed out how both Jade and quaking have also been weird, which Gekki could have focused on instead, which is why I say TE is an easy choice.
The final weird thing which I noticed recently is that Gekki was the first responder to TE's claim thing, yet only now decides to vote him for it.
I also am feeling deja vu.
@Lord o da rings Do you think Gekki is actually mafia? Or just playing weird/scummy?
Gekki says that TE is not new, reasoning with the 2 past mafia games, which isn't particularly weird. The tipping point was using Discord mafia to further justify this, which is weird, because Gekki would know that forum mafia and Discord mafia are very different.
Another weird thing is that he claims TE is the only semi-valid lynch option, as justification. That firstly shouldn't prevent Gekki from looking elsewhere! Besides, I've pointed out how both Jade and quaking have also been weird, which Gekki could have focused on instead, which is why I say TE is an easy choice.
The final weird thing which I noticed recently is that Gekki was the first responder to TE's claim thing, yet only now decides to vote him for it.
I also am feeling deja vu.
@Lord o da rings Do you think Gekki is actually mafia? Or just playing weird/scummy?
Ooh bb is asking only a specific person a question.
I'm feeling deja Vu.
I bet quaking remembers this.
I'm feeling deja Vu.
I bet quaking remembers this.
Well now it's possible it wasn't a joke, and he drew his massclaim inspiration from this. So yeah, this isn't a scumtell either way.
Of course not actually mafia yet. Still a bit early to mark him down as my definitive scum read, but I think this is the best place to put my vote for the time being.
##UNVOTE
I still don't understand why I'm being scumread for trying to move past RVS, though. :L
I guess you're right.
I still don't understand why I'm being scumread for trying to move past RVS, though. :L
A. They aren't random
B. I didn't blow up
C. He isn't new as in this is his first game
Yes, but as bb stated above (or was it Jade?) that the other kinds of mafia are waaaay different than the widely known pokebeach mafia.
Forum Mafia here is the same as everywhere else...
And PB Mafia is not widely known.
Did I say I wasn't looking elsewhere? The claim thing isn't the main reason I voted for him, and Discord Mafia is still mafia experience, even if it is way different. I don't see instances of Jade or Quaking being weird but I may be missing something.
You and I of all people right now know this is incredibly false.
The basics of the games are the same.
Everything else is not. Activity levels, people playing (with very different styles of playing), metas, etc. Every single site out there has different ways of playing the game. I hadn't really understood that until playing on those sites. Mafia is a very different experience on all of them, it shocks me that you don't think the same.
Now before we lead this conversation into useless banter about the differences of Mafia on different sites, I'm turning in for the night. Will take a look at all of this in the morning.
I mean, I play very similarly on all of them. Each site has their own little differences.
Also, same here. I need rest.
I don't remember this, so could you explain please? ^.^
I am just seeing this all to be very similar to last game: Gekki was scummy/was townier then got too aggressive/was somewhat logically inconsistent, yet he flipped town.
Fixed version:
Yup, you said something like "the only semi-viable vote" was TE, which implies you weren't looking that hard.
What was the main reason then? The bolded is weird, because you respond with "TE is not new" whenever I'm saying that TE is acting like a new player (and so those 'scumtells' are not tells), yet you acknowledge that Discord mafia is way different to forum mafia. So, TE is effectively "new".
The first sentence of your post suggests that you've been looking elsewhere, whereas this part shows that you haven't. Which is it?
Nope, each site has their own HUGE differences. Especially the other site that I play on. Eitherway, it is also weird that in your experience, people play similarly across sites, because by that logic, TE is playing similarly to the other sites he played, and so it doesn't make sense for you to think that the claiming could be scummy.
From general experience with new players, especially those getting pressured a lot. There are three probable scenarios: TE would have responded immediately (if he was online around that time), he will respond within the next 8ish hours, or will not respond and disappear from the game entirely. Hopefully not the last one.
So who do we kill today? Bb? Te? Not a single one has a case like gekki.
Huh the ladt mafia is very similar to this one.
Huh the ladt mafia is very similar to this one.
Holy crap y'all talk a lot.
- Status