Finished Murder V: The Fifth Generation

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

In case you get Ninja'd, when you want to comment on a previous post, either quote that post or state the post number.

118 - To clarify, this has been the rule since Murder I: Murder in the Mansion. And I have had the privilege of enforcing it on Bulbagarden. Also, it should be a written rule that posting during the night is not permitted, as I ended up with 4 pages of nighttime conversation in my Bulbagarden version of this game before I could log in again.

With that said, let's get back to the game. No change in my Hatman theory.
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

Let me be clear on something.

At no time did I say screw the rules, I have mods. I am not attempting to put myself or anyone else above the rules. I am asking for the rules to be amended because I think it should be okay to double post.

So are you saying, Guy89, that if we get ninja'd, we still have to wait for someone else to post just because we got ninja'd?

What evidence is there pointing to Hatman (Froslass)? Someone want to summarize for me?
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

Rule rescinded, double posting is aloud if you are ninja'd.

If any more rule questions/ suggestions appear, PM them to me.
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

PMJ said:
Let me be clear on something.

At no time did I say screw the rules, I have mods. I am not attempting to put myself or anyone else above the rules. I am asking for the rules to be amended because I think it should be okay to double post.

So are you saying, Guy89, that if we get ninja'd, we still have to wait for someone else to post just because we got ninja'd?

What evidence is there pointing to Hatman (Froslass)? Someone want to summarize for me?
Click to expand...

According to Snorchu, Hatman has bad grammar. Also the one F and S thing.

I have to say that MSE and 7L7M7 have the worst grammar here, and are most likely to have written the note. I'll stick with my MSE vote.
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

Guy89 said:
Rule rescinded, double posting is aloud if you are ninja'd.

If any more rule questions/ suggestions appear, PM them to me.
Click to expand...

HOLD IT!

PokeBeach rules disallow double-posting, and last I checked, those rules have apply here as well. In other words, PMJ is saying "Screw the rules I have mods".

sillykyle! said:
What does the vote count look like?
Click to expand...

Here's the total of correctly-entered votes (Remember, use the boldface tags to vote!)

Bastiodon: 1
Shaymin: 1
Lucario: 1
Froslass: 1
Reshiram: 1

I personally doubt that MSE would be the murderer. He may seem suspicious, but that's what threw people off in Werewolf VI, when I replaced him and they lynched me based on MSE's reputation.
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

It's kinda hard to tell when people aren't bolding their votes.

I'm still not sure who to vote for, as the whole See Flare theory might just be a coincidence or the murderer trying to trick us.

Joeypals!! said:
Yeah, I always mess up on that word for a wierd reason.
Click to expand...

Also, I'm fairly sure its spelled weird.
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

Snorchu said:
I personally doubt that MSE would be the murderer. He may seem suspicious, but that's what threw people off in Werewolf VI, when I replaced him and they lynched me based on MSE's reputation.
Click to expand...

His reputation is not what makes him suspicious. It's the clues and his grammar.

Also, I believe if it's not him, it's either Hatman or 7Lucario7Master7
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

lol, the killer is being based off of grammer now?
I dont feel like thats the best way to think but w/e, im new to this game.
Also how do i have bad grammer? or are you just saying that to add more random ideas that make me the killer?
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

7Lucario7Master7 said:
lol, the killer is being based off of grammer now?
I don't feel like thats the best way to think but w/e, im new to this game.
There was bad grammer in the note.
Also how do i have bad grammer? or are you just saying that to add more random ideas that make me the killer?
You sometimes don't capitalize "I". That is exactly what was in note.
Click to expand...

I've changed my mind.

Unvote: Shaymin
Vote: Lucario
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

Once again, my bad. The two words I can never spell for my life. Besides, iTouches do not do spellchecker. :( Also, the note had bad grammer, so the person posting as murderer should as well.
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

They are saying that because the killer's note has relaxed grammar (not capitalizing I, ignoring apostrophes, etc), and you seem to be the only one with that style.

But guys, his grammar is not _that_ bad. I wouldn't hold it against him.
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

Anyone even pay attention to my Bastiodon theory? And I know, grammar, not grammer. Hard to keep things straight with a pulsating headache coming in waves...
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

GOD I WAS NINJA'D AGAIN.

My post is referring to Lucario.
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

Said the guy who started the idea of me being the killer
And yes my i isn't capitalized but the killer did that just to make the words that wasn't capitalized stand out more, i dont think it was just his style, it also would be easy for him to read your posts on how you think its grammer related and he just starts using great grammer and none of you will think that person did it.
[/size]
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

You know, the outbursts are not necessary. By the way, you forgot to put size=whatever before the text, which would have made it worse. Honestly though, the Seed Flare theory may be incorrect. The text said "See my rage Flare", true? Well, what if it was instead a warning on who will die night one without catching this guy? Honestly, it could be something to throw us off. Take it from the murderer from last game. Like stated earlier, Nod has some of the worst grammar (finally got it!) around. Why is that not suspect? This is because everyone looks at the present. Also, remember back to when Roark fought his dad in the anime. Was there or was there not loads of anger against the opposing side, more than usual even? Wrath is also a synonym of rage. Why bring this out? If I remember correctly:
Nod3 said:
Bastiodon. NOA! FEEL MY WRATH!
Click to expand...
Anyone find this a coincidence?
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

Im just defending myself as any normal person should when they are accused of such crimes.
and the size was because i was gonna vote but then took it back,
But im going to vote now
VOTE Bastiodon
It makes sence
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

Make it bolded like instructed please!
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

Here's the total of correctly-entered votes (Remember, use the boldface tags to vote!)

Bastiodon: 1 (Nod3)
Lucario: 2 (7Lucario7Master7)
Froslass: 1 (Hatman)
Reshiram: 1 (MS Eeveelution)

42 chocolate said:
His reputation is not what makes him suspicious. It's the clues and his grammar.
Click to expand...

Keep in mind that MSE is from Malaysia. In countries that adopted the English language in the last 50 years, the grammar may not be perfect and in fact may turn out slightly different than either American or British English, even in the written form. Besides, MSE's writing style is not at all like the style used to write the note. Though I do believe grammar is valuable evidence, it cannot be used to convict MSE.

Also, note that the murderer did not capitalize the first word of every sentence but instead capitalized words like See and Flare, which we all seem to have picked up on. If you refer to post 68, you will see a definite difference between the two writing styles. Thus MSE cannot be the murderer.

Zyflair said:
"The Reshiram (MS Eeveelution) makes such a rash key point to the Froslass with the 'S' and 'F' without even considering the 'H'. It is likely he is the murderer and attempting to frame the Froslass, even adding "ghost" to throw us off. Can't accuse anyone yet, as it's not even remotely concrete..."
Click to expand...

Um, Zyflair... "H" for "Hatman"? And the "ghost" thing wasn't MSE's suspicion, it was mine. And he did raise the probability that Froslass is not the murderer but rather the next target. If you don't understand what I'm doing, I'm trying to clear MSE's name.

Hatman said:
D: But I'm too much of a n00b to be a murderer!
:p i dunno, but I don't like being framed. Also, How was Empoleon killed? was there any evidence of what weapon was used, or if it was just the bare hands/feet/whateverthepokemonhas?
Click to expand...

Last edited by Hatman: Monday, June 14, 6:08 PM

There is a lot of truth to this statement; he is too much of a n00b. Too much to play the game correctly. Not too much to be a murderer. And being a n00b does not discount the possibility that Hatman is the murderer. And if you look at the capitalization pattern, you'll see it matches the pattern in the note! Thus I have every reason to believe that Hatman is the murderer. My vote remains as such.
 
RE: Murder V: The Fifth Generation: Day 1 Ends 6/17/10 7AM PDT (An RPG)

Joeypals!! said:
Also, the note had bad grammer, so the person posting as murderer should as well.[/color]
Click to expand...

Oh god now we're going off of grammar? This whole theory is countered by the simple fact that the murderer could make his spelling/grammar bad ON PURPOSE on the note and then type normally here -.-
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top