Finished Murder VIII - Rescue Mission

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

Spinarak started laughing.
"He has been the most helpful person in the game! What is your definition of helpful, mlouden?"
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

^This. Now please unvote me so that we can make a logical decision.
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

As whoever else pointed out, you randomly strung together 3-4 clues in a semi-plausable theory, then the murderer RANDOMLY DECIDED TO OUT HIMSELF FOR NO REASON. He was pretty much trolling by admitting, and could have easily just brought suspicion to someone else or just said SK was wrong.
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

"I wouldn't call it random. It all fit perfectly. We probably would have lynched TDL because it fit so perfectly. And besides, SK was right... So he has done more than you or anyone else in this game. If you want to lynch him, I would try a different argument"
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

Mlouden, by saying I'm the murderer, you're basically saying I was the accomplice and I turned TDL in, correct? Allow me to show you this handy quote from the first post.

The murderer is at any time in the game able to choose an accomplice (This has only occurred in Murder I, and Murder VI) (They will do this by PM) who is then also able to kill people and bring the total killings up to double! But the accomplice also has the choice to turn in the murderer at any time and get them killed, thus having everybody alive win the game.
Click to expand...

Your logic does not fit at all. If you're going to accuse an innocent Pokemon, at least have a good reason.
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

The fact that Sillykyle! just like that found the murderer and TDL agreed to it after one accusation is too fishy. I mean, please use your head guys, that most likely wasn't just a coincidence. I mean, it's amazing he's still here, in my opinion. Hipoke dying was unfortunate, because I think he was using his head. Sillykyle!, you were wrong about Hipoke and you said you'd vote for yourself. I think you probably wanted an extra day so that you can get an accomplice in the game. Here we go:

Vote: Sillykyle!
Vote: Hipoke

Nothing personal broske :).
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

Uh yeah, there actually is another accomplice now.
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

Oh... Wow... I was wondering why two people got killed... >.< It still doesn't make sense to kill me though. As I have stated before, the evidence for me is stronger than the evidence against me.

Shall we recap?

Evidence for sillykyle!:

- If I was the original accomplice, I would have resigned and won when TDL died.
- Try linking a single CoG clue to me.
- Before he died, even hipoke didn't think I was the murderer.

Evidence against sillykyle!:

- TDL said I was the accomplice. (But no one has answered my simple question yet. Why would you ever trust the murderer?)
- I made the mistake of getting hipoke killed. (Then again, a lot of innocent Pokemon have been lynched. Guessing is part of the game, and you're not always going to guess right.)
- I figured out who the murderer was out of nowhere. (But if you look a few pages back, you'll see that I explained my entire thought process.)

Not very strong evidence if you ask me. Also, I have another question that I bet nobody can answer. If I really was the original accomplice, why on earth would I get TDL killed and then get an accomplice of my own? It makes no sense. Please, think about what I have said, and then make a logical decision.

P.S. It's sillykyle!. There's no capital. ;D
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

sillykyle! said:
I never said that. I know that nobody is going to listen to me, so I'm giving up.
Click to expand...

OoC: So much for that. I'm not really going to get too deep into an evidence struggle right now. Your overall attitude towards being suspected is reason enough for me to vote you out of this game. Nothing personal, but if you're going to play, expect stuff like this to happen. Don't just give up and then halfheartedly defend yourself. It's rather depressing.
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

ShadowLugia said:
OoC: So much for that. I'm not really going to get too deep into an evidence struggle right now. Your overall attitude towards being suspected is reason enough for me to vote you out of this game. Nothing personal, but if you're going to play, expect stuff like this to happen. Don't just give up and then halfheartedly defend yourself. It's rather depressing.
Click to expand...

It was supposed to get you guys to feel sympathetic, then you would be more willing to listen to me when I defended myself. Unfortunately, now everyone knows my strategy. :/ But what I still don't understand is why that makes you want to get rid of me. As you can see, I obviously didn't give up. You guys are making a grave mistake here. If you kill me, not only do you lose another innocent Pokemon, but you lose an active poster who comes up with good theories.
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

OoC: ^Now that's what I like to see. Put a little effort into it. ;)
If anyone has any suggestions on who to vote out, I'm certainly listening. Otherwise...
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

^I say we choose one of these Pokemon, because it's the best shot we have.

Dark Void said:
OOC: Sorry for being inactive, school and stuff.

IC: "Maybe the clue is referencing certain Pokemon? 'First you must have something to sniff out the trail.' Growlithe are known for having a great sense of smell and Dark Sonic J is a Growlithe. 'But be warned, there is a high percentage of fail.' Not sure if this is referencing anything...'Next you must make a calm call.' Maybe a Pokemon that can learn Calm Mind? There are a couple though. 'Your eyes, however will cause your fall.' So maybe a Pokemon that doesn't use eyes? Umbreon/Espeon is a Ralts, which means his eyes are always closed. In addition, Ralts can learn Calm Mind. 'After, set fire to every single crook.' Maybe a fire type? We started with 3 Fire types, Dark Sonic J (Growlithe), Guilty Spark (Charmander), and legendhunter32 (Chimchar). Of those, Dark Sonic J is already mentioned and legendhunter23 is dead, so maybe the clue is referencing Guilty Spark? 'You never know who will come back to look.' I'm kind of stumped on this, anyone have any insight on this line? 'Lastly, you must throw tons of rotten fruit' I'm kind of tricked by this, you would think a grass type like Tropius but the only alive grass-type we have is Ice Espeon (Rotom-Cut). 'At every last man who deserves the boot.' I can't figure out this either.

So, in summary, the clue seems to reference Dark Sonic J, Umbreon/Espeon, Guilty spark, and maybe Ice Espeon. Anyone see any things that are similar about these people, flaws with my logic, or have any insight on any other parts of the clue?"
Click to expand...
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

Come on guys, don't let this game die from inactivity. We have to at least try to find the murderer.

Vote: Umbreon/Espeon
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

Bump

Seriously guys, we gotta keep active.
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

Kill SILLYKYLE


OOC:
sorry pory but I just had to modkill a member of mafia lol
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

Mlouden, I have repeated my argument over and over, but you just ignore it and refuse to counter my logic. This leads me to believe you don't have solid reasons for voting me. I know I said I would vote for myself if I was wrong about hipoke, but I was just desperate. Come on, at least come up with some sort of argument...
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

Well... I dunno, mlouden has been kind of insistent on killing sillykyle. Jussayin
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

The fact that you made such a statement and then retracted it means you lied. You said you would vote for yourself, you have not done so. As of right now you're our only actual lead. Also per the rules you could just have pointed fingers at tdl but told/asked porygon for you not to side with us given what happened. Also if that's the case, you're now trying to shift suspicion off yourself by saying let's lynch someone totally random for NO REASON..that makes 0 sense
 
RE: Murder VIII - Rescue Mission (Day 5 Ends Sept. 17th, 8PM EST!)

...Would Porygon have gone against the rules to do that? I highly doubt it...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top