RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
Or it's someone who was role blocked. Whoever was role blocked on Night 2 could be Bowser...
Or it's someone who was role blocked. Whoever was role blocked on Night 2 could be Bowser...
Finished Mushroom Mayhem ~ Congratulations Hatman
- Thread starter Professor Palutena
- Start date
- Status
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
Here's a list of roles I think we can assume of people still alive:
Metal Mario(Role-Blocked, was pokemon99)
Bowser(Only attacked night 1)
Kong clan, one is a killer(Speeding barrels, Funky Kong's description)
Rosalina(Seer, was relieved when she saw who HypnoticLuxray was)
Note-Writer(Only wrote a note night 2, saw Tyraniking as "good")
Here's a list of roles I think we can assume of people still alive:
Metal Mario(Role-Blocked, was pokemon99)
Bowser(Only attacked night 1)
Kong clan, one is a killer(Speeding barrels, Funky Kong's description)
Rosalina(Seer, was relieved when she saw who HypnoticLuxray was)
Note-Writer(Only wrote a note night 2, saw Tyraniking as "good")
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
Do you really?
Posting so you can post again.
Lemme' hear your wondorous theory.
Yoshidude10 said:
Do you really?
Posting so you can post again.
Lemme' hear your wondorous theory.
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
First, let me say this.
This makes me think Hatman is clean.
In Super Mario Sunshine, Bowser Jr. uses a magic paintbrush. In Super Mario Sluggers, he uses a paintbrush for a bat. I think Bowser Jr. could be the last Koopa Troopa (besides Bowser, I think).
And one more thing ; where did it say HL was clean? I looked over everything, and it never said anywhere HL was clean.
First, let me say this.
Bippa201 said:
This makes me think Hatman is clean.
Bippa201 said:
In Super Mario Sunshine, Bowser Jr. uses a magic paintbrush. In Super Mario Sluggers, he uses a paintbrush for a bat. I think Bowser Jr. could be the last Koopa Troopa (besides Bowser, I think).
And one more thing ; where did it say HL was clean? I looked over everything, and it never said anywhere HL was clean.
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
aww, I thought you were gonna say something productive.
That means I'm clean, duh.
Pokenerd already said the thing about Bowser JR, and It says on the OP Bowser jr's a character/
Hatman means nothing to me.
aww, I thought you were gonna say something productive.
That means I'm clean, duh.
Pokenerd already said the thing about Bowser JR, and It says on the OP Bowser jr's a character/
Hatman means nothing to me.
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
Lol Yoshi...that told us nothing. I say BT. We don't need role blockers...or deleters...or what ever he does. As I said I believe the Kong's are allied with the town to try and kill the Koopa Troop. They just aren't good at getting them :/ no offense...I'm clueless as to who the Koopa Troop right now too
. That is interesting about Bowser. I didn't notice that he only killed on night one...I think inactive. Why would a role blocker block the same person 2 times? Hmmm I guess if they knew what role they had...I'm confusing myself lol
Lol Yoshi...that told us nothing. I say BT. We don't need role blockers...or deleters...or what ever he does. As I said I believe the Kong's are allied with the town to try and kill the Koopa Troop. They just aren't good at getting them :/ no offense...I'm clueless as to who the Koopa Troop right now too
. That is interesting about Bowser. I didn't notice that he only killed on night one...I think inactive. Why would a role blocker block the same person 2 times? Hmmm I guess if they knew what role they had...I'm confusing myself lol
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
Why did it say Blue Thunder was near P99? Honestly, Blue Thunder is the best bet if we go on some evidence.
Why did it say Blue Thunder was near P99? Honestly, Blue Thunder is the best bet if we go on some evidence.
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
I hadn't even revealed my theory, but whatever.
My theory was that the roleblocker(s) has(have) continued to roleblock somebody. Maybe they've figured this out by now, and that's why they've continued to roleblock Bowser.
Anyway, Hatman, HL, Tyraniking, and most likely SL are clean. That eliminates 4 of the 14 players left, and then p99 is the Metal Man, so there's 9 other people to think about. If you look at the list of people left, there's a few people there that could obviously be Boswer (hint hint ; look at the people with 5 posts or less that aren't dead. This should lower it to the prime suspects, since maybe Bowser just hasn't attacked because of activity).
There you go, everyone. Sorry about not posting, I was in school, so yeah.
I hadn't even revealed my theory, but whatever.
My theory was that the roleblocker(s) has(have) continued to roleblock somebody. Maybe they've figured this out by now, and that's why they've continued to roleblock Bowser.
Anyway, Hatman, HL, Tyraniking, and most likely SL are clean. That eliminates 4 of the 14 players left, and then p99 is the Metal Man, so there's 9 other people to think about. If you look at the list of people left, there's a few people there that could obviously be Boswer (hint hint ; look at the people with 5 posts or less that aren't dead. This should lower it to the prime suspects, since maybe Bowser just hasn't attacked because of activity).
There you go, everyone. Sorry about not posting, I was in school, so yeah.
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
Pretty much everybody has evidence leading up to lynching Blue Thunder. But if he were really just lurking, he would've showed up by now to defend himself. I think he's really inactive, but probably not Bowser. If he is Bowser, he's not doing anything anyway. I think we should go for someone who isn't role blocked, and isn't HL, Hatman, or I.
Pretty much everybody has evidence leading up to lynching Blue Thunder. But if he were really just lurking, he would've showed up by now to defend himself. I think he's really inactive, but probably not Bowser. If he is Bowser, he's not doing anything anyway. I think we should go for someone who isn't role blocked, and isn't HL, Hatman, or I.
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
whoa whoa hold the phone guys.
If you carefully read the post, it says I only "witnessed" this event, and that "I am eager to share the results with the town." (Hint hint) It doesn't say that I had caused it, or in anyway had anything to do with the loss of Pokemon99's abilities.
Now, let's say for a second that I actually do have this supposed "role-blocking" ability. Based on how it was used to stop a harmful member from further hurting us, wouldn't that most likely mean I would be allied with the town? Do you seriously think if I were Bowser/other mafia member, I would have targeted my own ally the "Metal Man"? Are you kidding me?
Now, I definitely agree with those who say that Bowser is an inactive member, based on the fact he didn't kill last round or the round before iirc. However, there are still a few others who are just as inactive as I have been, if not even more so. (Hint hint it's not a magical coincidence I was mentioned in the last update HINT HINT)
I also see the argument of "oh even though he might be with the town, his "ability" will only do us harm." That speaks for itself...clearly the role didn't do us any harm this round, did it? If anything, it essentially eliminated a Mafia Member. Granted, it could cause harm in future rounds, but compare the risks versus the rewards. This ability could be a potentially game-winning ability. Would you really want to throw that opportunity away?
...and all of this is of course assuming I even have that role in the first place, which I as I pointed at the very beginning of the post, the wording of the update does not support the argument that I caused the loss of Pokemon99's roles. I only saw the event take place, and "am I eager to tell everyone about what had happened." (And if I actually did cause this event....why would I want to blab to the town about it? To show "hey guyz i got a mafia member hur durr!?" Wouldn't that just make me look suspicious (like it's already doing now) as well? It just logically wouldn't make any sense.)
In conclusion, I do not have this role-blocking ability based on the wording of the nightly update, (i.e the only official source of information) and even if on the off-chance Bippa meant something completely different by that update, it's highly unlikely I would be with a Koopa Troop member. There's better targets, guys. :/
whoa whoa hold the phone guys.
If you carefully read the post, it says I only "witnessed" this event, and that "I am eager to share the results with the town." (Hint hint) It doesn't say that I had caused it, or in anyway had anything to do with the loss of Pokemon99's abilities.
Now, let's say for a second that I actually do have this supposed "role-blocking" ability. Based on how it was used to stop a harmful member from further hurting us, wouldn't that most likely mean I would be allied with the town? Do you seriously think if I were Bowser/other mafia member, I would have targeted my own ally the "Metal Man"? Are you kidding me?
Now, I definitely agree with those who say that Bowser is an inactive member, based on the fact he didn't kill last round or the round before iirc. However, there are still a few others who are just as inactive as I have been, if not even more so. (Hint hint it's not a magical coincidence I was mentioned in the last update HINT HINT)
I also see the argument of "oh even though he might be with the town, his "ability" will only do us harm." That speaks for itself...clearly the role didn't do us any harm this round, did it? If anything, it essentially eliminated a Mafia Member. Granted, it could cause harm in future rounds, but compare the risks versus the rewards. This ability could be a potentially game-winning ability. Would you really want to throw that opportunity away?
...and all of this is of course assuming I even have that role in the first place, which I as I pointed at the very beginning of the post, the wording of the update does not support the argument that I caused the loss of Pokemon99's roles. I only saw the event take place, and "am I eager to tell everyone about what had happened." (And if I actually did cause this event....why would I want to blab to the town about it? To show "hey guyz i got a mafia member hur durr!?" Wouldn't that just make me look suspicious (like it's already doing now) as well? It just logically wouldn't make any sense.)
In conclusion, I do not have this role-blocking ability based on the wording of the nightly update, (i.e the only official source of information) and even if on the off-chance Bippa meant something completely different by that update, it's highly unlikely I would be with a Koopa Troop member. There's better targets, guys. :/
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
Your arguement about targeting your own ally the metal man is invalid due to the fact that the metal man role was an indie role, meaning you wouldn't have known it was him if you did it, so that arguement says nothing.
Your arguement about targeting your own ally the metal man is invalid due to the fact that the metal man role was an indie role, meaning you wouldn't have known it was him if you did it, so that arguement says nothing.
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
It was never confirmed that he was an Indie. I don't even think Pokemon99 has outright claimed it, either. (He says he now wants to help the town, but that doesn't mean he was an indie from the get go)
And even if he was, assuming that I would be a mafia member, why would I choose anyone that wasn't confirmed to be clean? Why would I want to a risk on someone when I could have a nigh-guaranteed shot at the town with a role-block by targeting someone like HL or Tyraniking?
Irregardless, the point still stands: it is highly unlikely that I even have the role to begin with, let alone am a mafia member.
It was never confirmed that he was an Indie. I don't even think Pokemon99 has outright claimed it, either. (He says he now wants to help the town, but that doesn't mean he was an indie from the get go)
And even if he was, assuming that I would be a mafia member, why would I choose anyone that wasn't confirmed to be clean? Why would I want to a risk on someone when I could have a nigh-guaranteed shot at the town with a role-block by targeting someone like HL or Tyraniking?
Irregardless, the point still stands: it is highly unlikely that I even have the role to begin with, let alone am a mafia member.
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
Blue Thunder brings up good points. At this point I don't really care whether or not BT is the role killer because either
A) It only works once per game because it's such a powerful role, or
B) They're smart and don't kill a role every night, analyzing who the killers could be.
The role killer has only helped us and I think option A is more likely, meaning they won't ever be a problem.
As for Bowser, I do not think killing inactives is the way to go. If they hadn't sent a PM since night one, don't you think Bippa would have done something? They could be getting role blocked or something.
Blue Thunder brings up good points. At this point I don't really care whether or not BT is the role killer because either
A) It only works once per game because it's such a powerful role, or
B) They're smart and don't kill a role every night, analyzing who the killers could be.
The role killer has only helped us and I think option A is more likely, meaning they won't ever be a problem.
As for Bowser, I do not think killing inactives is the way to go. If they hadn't sent a PM since night one, don't you think Bippa would have done something? They could be getting role blocked or something.
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
I agree with BT, BUT isn't it just a little strange how he wasn't posting much at all until now? Right when every bit of evidence was leading towards him? Which means he definitely could be lurking, lying low, and looking for people to slip up. And now he's shoving all that evidence back where it came. That's exactly what a town-allied killer would do, and if he is a trouble maker, I think that's probably what he is. But then again, I'd think that the Kong would be active, in order to find what out who the town want to kill. Isn't that why Glaceon was killed? TL;DR: I think BT is clean. I don't think he's a good lynch.
Lets get on another topic: Pokemon99. Obviously this guy is Metal Mario, and we know he won't kill anyone now. But in order for the town to win, he needs to die eventually. We could lynch him, but we need the Kong gone ASAP before he starts killing all the townies. May as well save him for last?
One last possible vote is an inactive. That's Hipoke and ShadowLugia, but again, that's basically wasting a vote.
I agree with BT, BUT isn't it just a little strange how he wasn't posting much at all until now? Right when every bit of evidence was leading towards him? Which means he definitely could be lurking, lying low, and looking for people to slip up. And now he's shoving all that evidence back where it came. That's exactly what a town-allied killer would do, and if he is a trouble maker, I think that's probably what he is. But then again, I'd think that the Kong would be active, in order to find what out who the town want to kill. Isn't that why Glaceon was killed? TL;DR: I think BT is clean. I don't think he's a good lynch.
Lets get on another topic: Pokemon99. Obviously this guy is Metal Mario, and we know he won't kill anyone now. But in order for the town to win, he needs to die eventually. We could lynch him, but we need the Kong gone ASAP before he starts killing all the townies. May as well save him for last?
One last possible vote is an inactive. That's Hipoke and ShadowLugia, but again, that's basically wasting a vote.
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
You guys have until 4pm MST to reach a majority, or I'm killing one of you myself. ;D
So that leaves you with about 18 hours.
You guys have until 4pm MST to reach a majority, or I'm killing one of you myself. ;D
So that leaves you with about 18 hours.
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th
NO! We can't waste our vote. The townies can potentially lose if we waste our vote.
DV57
Yoshidude
Chillarmy
sillykyle!
Catutie
Xdogking
AllInAPackage
Blue Thunder
Lynching anyone of these people could change the game. We know there's a lot of killers out there, and we know that HL, probably Hatman, and I are innocent, and SL and Hipoke are too inactive.
NO! We can't waste our vote. The townies can potentially lose if we waste our vote.
DV57
Yoshidude
Chillarmy
sillykyle!
Catutie
Xdogking
AllInAPackage
Blue Thunder
Lynching anyone of these people could change the game. We know there's a lot of killers out there, and we know that HL, probably Hatman, and I are innocent, and SL and Hipoke are too inactive.
- Status