Finished Mushroom Mayhem ~ Congratulations Hatman

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

Six people left.

We have a doctor, Rosalina(SL), Reflector?(t-king), 1-2 something else, and 1-2 Koopa Troops. yay.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

6 Players left.

Blue Thunder (Possible Koopa Trooper)
HypnoticLuxray (Was seen as innocent by Rosalina)
sillykyle! (Possible Koopa Trooper)
Hatman (Part of a night update said he felt strong enough to kill Bowser himself, but could still be a Koopa Trooper)
Tyraniking (Was seen as innocent by Toadette)
ShadowLugia (Most likely Rosalina)

So that pretty much leaves me, Blue Thunder and Hatman.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th

Wow, that was...wow.

I know who Bowser Jr. is. Let me just lead up to the moment :D

Who would've thought...that one post...could lead us to the last trooper? Everybody overlooked it, and while I was casually browsing the thread, I found the post. (Epic, huh?)

catutie said:
BT and Hipoke are our best bets right now if we want to go for people laying low...but other than that I've got nothing. It seems that the Kong's are good but they just just suck at finding the Koopa Troop :/

Catutie wanted to lynch BT. If BT was a trooper, why would Catutie want to lynch his own teammate? Suggesting the death of his own teammate is not helping them win. Which means, there's only ONE person who could be the last victim: Kyle the silly.

Gogogogo open voting.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

Tyraniking said:
Wow, that was...wow.

I know who Bowser Jr. is. Let me just lead up to the moment :D

Who would've thought...that one post...could lead us to the last trooper? Everybody overlooked it, and while I was casually browsing the thread, I found the post. (Epic, huh?)


Catutie wanted to lynch BT. If BT was a trooper, why would Catutie want to lynch his own teammate? Suggesting the death of his own teammate is not helping them win. Which means, there's only ONE person who could be the last victim: Kyle the silly.

Gogogogo open voting.

Y u no smart.

It's called reverse-pshycology. If he DIDN'T suspect his own teamate, then it would be obvious they're buddy buddy. Which makes me think silly IS NOT a wolf.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 4 ends October 5th

Tyraniking said:
Wow, that was...wow.

I know who Bowser Jr. is. Let me just lead up to the moment :D

Who would've thought...that one post...could lead us to the last trooper? Everybody overlooked it, and while I was casually browsing the thread, I found the post. (Epic, huh?)


Catutie wanted to lynch BT. If BT was a trooper, why would Catutie want to lynch his own teammate? Suggesting the death of his own teammate is not helping them win. Which means, there's only ONE person who could be the last victim: Kyle the silly.

Gogogogo open voting.

What about Hatman...?
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

Not only that, but silly lies too low. That alone is not enough to make me feel that kyle is innocent.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

Of the alive people, silly has 3rd in post count. (tied for third with this post) Yeah, that's real low.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

Hatman is still not a better lynch. He has less against him.

Post count doesn't matter. It's what he posts. His posts sound like P99 and SA's posts. What are we supposed to do, lynch BT? Why is HE a good lynch? I explained why we should lynch Kyle, so explain why we should lynch someone else.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

Because I'm innocent. Because the only evidence you have against me is what catutie said in one of his posts, and that (weak) evidence works just as well against Hatman. I haven't said too much because I haven't had much to say. Also, take a look at this.

Total Posts: 488
User # Posts
Tyraniking 49
Hatman 32
sillykyle! 24

HypnoticLuxray 24
Blue Thunder 11
ShadowLugia 2

You can't use activity level as a reason, because I'm neither the most active nor the least active of the suspects.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

If that evidence works just as well against Hatman, I'd find evidence similar to mine.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

Choosing someone isn't my thing. I prefer to argue because I can. ;D

And you can't say we have more evidence against one person than another, since the evidence you presented is completely circuimstancial. It could mean one thing or another. Although I do understand what you mean by, "The way he posts."

I think we should wait for everyone to post, rather than making rash decisions. Alot of these guys (BT) only post when they are being voted for. And when he did post, it was a gigantic post on why standing near someone means nothing. Kind of an over-the-top defense. Now he's probably gonna post, just because I'm questioning him. :O
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

Nope Hypnolux, just silly old Shadow. ;) Just want to let you guys know that I haven't posted here since... let's say a while. :/ I'm still in the finals. While that might not be fair, I'm going to contribute and help where I can. And never use activity as a reason to lynch (unless it gets to the point where a modkill is necessary). I'm not sure who to be suspicious of.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

ShadowLugia said:
Nope Hypnolux, just silly old Shadow. ;) Just want to let you guys know that I haven't posted here since... let's say a while. :/ I'm still in the finals. While that might not be fair, I'm going to contribute and help where I can. And never use activity as a reason to lynch (unless it gets to the point where a modkill is necessary). I'm not sure who to be suspicious of.

The main suspects right now are me, Blue Thunder and Hatman. Tyraniking currently thinks it's me, I'm defending myself, and HypnoticLuxray is arguing against Tyraniking because he can. There. I just told you everything that's happened so far this game day. ;D
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

To anyone that thought I was making a decision based on activity, I'd read this post:

Tyraniking said:
Post count doesn't matter. It's what he posts. His posts sound like P99 and SA's posts. What are we supposed to do, lynch BT? Why is HE a good lynch? I explained why we should lynch Kyle, so explain why we should lynch someone else.

I'm not saying I won't wait for anyone to post. If you have some evidence that can make me change my mind, (which HL won't because he has nobody else to blame) then I'll listen openly. All I'm saying is that I'll probably vote for Kyle. To me, he has the most going against him.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

Oh yeah, I totally believe you know, even though that's an easily made up excuse to not post much instead of lying low. I stand unconvinced.

Also, I don't think Hatman is bad, because he said that he could throw Bowser into the lava himself. I mean, the whole point of statements like that is to give you hints. It's just like P99, with the oiling joints. I thought it was a figure of speech, but it is again, probably another hidden hint. It's not there just for fun, people.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

idk why you'd put a hidden hint into your posts, he's not some cryptic Indiana Jones character. XD And thanks for filling me in kyle. Off of that sole piece of evidence, bt would probably be the best bet, since kyle doesn't have much evidence, and hat is apparently a helpful character.
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

HL, you would be correct...

HL, I really don't know why catutie would even bother with reverse psychology. It seems that there is probably only one Koopa member left, and if I was that Koopa Member...why would catutie want his one remaining ally gone?! He would have put himself in a terrible position, where one mistake on his part or an intelligent Townie would have resulted in the loss of the Koopa Troopa. If I really was an ally of his, he would have likely stayed low or at least point out someone who is equally as suspicious as I am. He even still tried to get me lynched after I posted my defense, when at least a few others changed their minds about how "guilty" I was. I mean....why would he be so adamant about getting rid of me despite being an ally? Trying to hide under the guise of "reverse psychology" would have been stupid so late in the game, and it wouldn't have even worked...

At this point, I'm thinking that sillykyle seems the most suspicious to me right now, mainly based on the fact that everyone else has at least one piece of evidence that says they are innocent. (Though how reliable that evidence is obviously skeptical in the case of myself, sillykyle and Hatman)


p.s my defense was "so over the top" because it had to be. It wouldn't have stopped my nigh-inevitable lynching if it wasn't.[/color]
 
RE: Mushroom Mayhem ~ Day 6 ends October 11th

lol I only posted that to get you to post. ;D

why would catutie want his one remaining ally gone?!

How can you be so sure there was only one left? We were never told how many Koopa Troops there were. How do you know this?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top