I always end up liking the airy pikachus more (sparky, oldest bro of the pichu bros), so my vote goes to sparky, also because ash's pikachu is too powerful then it should be
Ashes pikachu because sparky (richies pikachu) has not been trained that much according to chronicles and that is how I see it anyway. But I still like both pokemon.
I voted for they are both ugly because I like the surfer one (those blue eyes....so..pretty....) and I don't like richie's because of it's voice (drives me crazy watching Chronicles..) and Ash's Pikachu is just a regular pikachu.