From what I've used for Sleeves in Magic, Naruto, Duel Masters and Pokemon:
1. Umbreon/Espeon Offical POP sleeves I won From Jwitzz's Contest:
These sleeves were really well built, but only after a couple months they started peeling up, and the artwork faded on them so I can't use them in tournaments anymore.
2. Ultrapro:
Whenever I get a new pack of sleeves, I'll probably pick up 2 Packs of 50 of this, they're really good, having the texture on the back is easy to tell when they're shuffled and because the texture dulls them they don't glare for matches
3. Max Pro: I liked these for my Charizard Deck but my big gripe with them is that the back is transparent, so if a card has a big creece on the back, or a gash its super noticable, after a couple months they start tearing so I would only suggest these is if you need a cheap set of sleeves for replacement for a tournament and/or all of your cards are in near mint condition
4. Player's Choice: These are very well built, but I don't recommend any light colors, they attract dust like flies
5. Dragonshield: Same as Player's Choice