But what about "Pokémon Red, Blue, and Yellow Special Pikachu Edition Gotta Catch 'em All"? The full name for the Yellow version,
Pokémon Yellow: Special Pikachu Edition is already pretty darn long for a name.
Pimpwalkin' Mateo Johnson said:
They stopped using the "Gotta Catch 'em All!" slogan at the start of the third generation because you could no longer "catch 'em all" using just Ruby & Sapphire. We couldn't "catch 'em all" until FRLG was released, like what, 3 years later?
You're right! It would take Ruby, Sapphire, Colosseum, FireRed, and LeafGreen to get all of the normally obtainable ones. I guess the novelty of getting surprise Pokémon like Mew and Celebi would fade away by then too, as their numbers began to increase.
Seeing the case of that guy I met, I think the "Gotta catch 'em all!" mindset is less productive than the battling part of it though, since once someone DOES get them all, they have no incentive to keep playing. That's probably why so many people I knew who used to play Pokémon have hung up their Poké Ball belts for good: Because they've already caught them all for their time and moved on to another game series. (In the case of my high school friends, they just played
Diablo 2 online up until graduation.)