RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
There's no such thing as a scum tell.
Keeper of Night said:
There's no such thing as a scum tell.
Finished The Challenge: Season 4 - Keeper of Night takes it all!
- Thread starter Professor Palutena
- Start date
- Status
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
Except even though it says "all roles are public knowledge", I don't see a single wolf OR alignment changer.
Exactly. Which is my argument for why Palutena cannot be scum.WanderingWolf said:
Celever said:
Except even though it says "all roles are public knowledge", I don't see a single wolf OR alignment changer.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
*facepalm*
You said that there were 5 village roles, implying they all must be used once, with one wolf.
He said that roles may not be used, and some may be used between 1-5 times (since there must be at least 1 wolf... maybe). This impys that there may be 4 wolves, 2 coroners. 1 cop, 3 roleblocks, and a VT, and a wolf. Any kind of combination. He never explicitly said, nor implied that there must be two wolves, or more.
Celever said:
*facepalm*
You said that there were 5 village roles, implying they all must be used once, with one wolf.
He said that roles may not be used, and some may be used between 1-5 times (since there must be at least 1 wolf... maybe). This impys that there may be 4 wolves, 2 coroners. 1 cop, 3 roleblocks, and a VT, and a wolf. Any kind of combination. He never explicitly said, nor implied that there must be two wolves, or more.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
Ok. I know there's a large chance WW and cleverer are going to vote for each other the second this starts, but I honestly think that going for a no lynch is the best option for day 1. Chances are there are two wolfs, meaning we lose if we mislynch today. Voting for no lynch allows us to have another day and for the seer, if we have one, to search again on night one. The wolf kill being unsuccessful is even an option considering the Coroner, if there is one, is deathproof and we also potentially have the Doctor protecting someone.
Ok. I know there's a large chance WW and cleverer are going to vote for each other the second this starts, but I honestly think that going for a no lynch is the best option for day 1. Chances are there are two wolfs, meaning we lose if we mislynch today. Voting for no lynch allows us to have another day and for the seer, if we have one, to search again on night one. The wolf kill being unsuccessful is even an option considering the Coroner, if there is one, is deathproof and we also potentially have the Doctor protecting someone.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
...Is anybody up for just a headstrong, reckless, (almost) completely luck based way of going about this challenge?
Because I have an idea that fits said description.
...Is anybody up for just a headstrong, reckless, (almost) completely luck based way of going about this challenge?
Because I have an idea that fits said description.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
lol, James is in a really unfortunate position because there are two ways the scum are going to take their kill tonight:
Kill James
This frames me as a werewolf because I want to murder him with a pickaxe and a chainsaw.
Not kill James
This makes James look completely like a wolf, because rev and I would kill him unless he we scum. Of course the scumteam could also be KoN/RG etc. etc. but still.
lol, James is in a really unfortunate position because there are two ways the scum are going to take their kill tonight:
Kill James
This frames me as a werewolf because I want to murder him with a pickaxe and a chainsaw.
Not kill James
This makes James look completely like a wolf, because rev and I would kill him unless he we scum. Of course the scumteam could also be KoN/RG etc. etc. but still.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
Reckless is not a way to go about a werewolf game with this many people.
Reckless is not a way to go about a werewolf game with this many people.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
Celever said:
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
I'd like the doctor to not protect me, I'm not worth protecting.
I'd like the doctor to not protect me, I'm not worth protecting.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
Actually, the odds are against us. I think I'll keep said plan to myself, execute it myself, hope not to die in the process, and maybe live to tell the tale.
...Unless I'm really the scum. In which case... I need a new mirror.
Celever said:
Actually, the odds are against us. I think I'll keep said plan to myself, execute it myself, hope not to die in the process, and maybe live to tell the tale.
...Unless I'm really the scum. In which case... I need a new mirror.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
We could always just roleclaim. Since there's a small description of your role, not included in the OP of this challenge, if a wolf gets a role one of the townspeople have, then we'll instantly know they're wolf.
Plus, the wolves don't know our Win Condition.
We could always just roleclaim. Since there's a small description of your role, not included in the OP of this challenge, if a wolf gets a role one of the townspeople have, then we'll instantly know they're wolf.
Plus, the wolves don't know our Win Condition.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
No lynch day one is the best we can play this game. All other options lead to a potential loss before day 2 we even get to day 2 .
No lynch day one is the best we can play this game. All other options lead to a potential loss before day 2 we even get to day 2 .
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
The problem with that is that those roles can be used more than once. We could all be Coroners or VT or whatever for all we know.
The problem with that is that those roles can be used more than once. We could all be Coroners or VT or whatever for all we know.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
Do you guys want to make it so the cop should come out if they see a wolf tonight? Since we WILL NOT have enough nights in this game for the cop to start seeing the other wolf, if there is one?
Do you guys want to make it so the cop should come out if they see a wolf tonight? Since we WILL NOT have enough nights in this game for the cop to start seeing the other wolf, if there is one?
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
Confirmation that RG either needs the doc or should be killed because useless.
RaichuGirl said:
Confirmation that RG either needs the doc or should be killed because useless.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
I think if the cop(s) find a wolf, they should report immediately. Chances are we have another one anyway.
...Maybe.
WanderingWolf said:
I think if the cop(s) find a wolf, they should report immediately. Chances are we have another one anyway.
...Maybe.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
Why would RG need the doc? Coroner's are deathproof until Day 2...
Keeper of Night said:
Why would RG need the doc? Coroner's are deathproof until Day 2...
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!
Because the only a cop would claim coroner, to act deathproof.
WanderingWolf said:
Because the only a cop would claim coroner, to act deathproof.
- Status