Finished The Challenge: Season 4 - Keeper of Night takes it all!

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Well, that lynch was wasted. I'm not going to die, but I guess we have 2 confovillagers

When I'm not lynched, the way I see it is there are 3 scums: KoN, Rev and Twisted.

KoN has done several scummy things. His plan between Rev and Twisted could easily be set up so that he can not kill anybody tonight, tomorrow we lynch Rev (a townie) and then lose. Because 6 -> 4 is LYLO with 2 mafias/villagers. Except, I guess, for the new mayor role. Hopefully he'll survive (DON'T CLAIM). He also claimed the same role as 3 other people with his cops, and can fly under the radar quite easily with RG cleaning him, however he could also be a Mafia Godfather. Apparently there aren't any millers, so chances are there will be a godfather somewhere.

Rev is another cop who... hasn't done much. He's only on here because he isn't clean, but he's the least fishy right now.

Twisted was the last to claim. People said "if he was scum he would make his role match others" but I really don't think so... actually that is stupid. Yeah, he can steal the flavour, but then we have to choose between 3 coroners and he was the last one to claim LOL. His wincon was slightly off scumtell but he talked about how changed the roles in the slightest way to screw with us.This is interesting enough, as it actually happened (albeit really minor in our role PMs -- mine's missing a comma which James' has lol). However, messing with the wincon is much stranger, as this is actually one of the key ways that we could clean as a town.

My scumlist right now, clearly, is KoN and TwistedTurtwig and it's going to be difficult to sway from this IMO.
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Well, that lynch was wasted. I'm not going to die, but I guess we have 2 confovillagers
Excuse me, but if you think I'm scum and lying about my role, this means we have no (as in, 0) confo villagers.
Because if I'm lying, RG could be my scum partner saying Im clean. And I was the one who cleaned Wander, which means if I'm not clean, Wander isn't either.
We didn't waste a lynch because the smart thing to do would be no lynch. Lynching you is the same thing (supposedly). Therefore, we still win.

KoN has done several scummy things.
lol, are you serious?

His plan between Rev and Twisted could easily be set up so that he can not kill anybody tonight, tomorrow we lynch Rev (a townie) and then lose.
Except for the fact that I'm not scum, so I couldn't make this plan work.
Although I do like it... Maybe for future games? Thanks for the idea!

Except, I guess, for the new mayor role. Hopefully he'll survive (DON'T CLAIM).
He cant, he doesn't even know who he is.

He also claimed the same role as 3 other people with his cops, and can fly under the radar quite easily with RG cleaning him,
I claimed cop first (and role revealed second). You obviously missed that.

Rev is another cop who... hasn't done much. He's only on here because he isn't clean, but he's the least fishy right now.
Yeah... If you flip scum (highly likely at this point) we're taking Rev down next. Sorry, but this is so obviously defending it hurts.

Twisted was the last to claim. People said "if he was scum he would make his role match others" but I really don't think so... actually that is stupid.
Actually, I believe it was only I who said that. What I really meant was he would have stolen the alignment so it would match perfectly.
The fact that he didn't change it and was the one to point it out makes me cautious.

His wincon was slightly off scumtell but he talked about how changed the roles in the slightest way to screw with us.
Everyone else's roles were the same. TT isn't off my list yet.

My scumlist right now, clearly, is KoN and TwistedTurtwig and it's going to be difficult to sway from this IMO.
O...kay?

TL;DR:
all-that-you-think-you-know.jpg
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Keeper of Night said:
Well, that lynch was wasted. I'm not going to die, but I guess we have 2 confovillagers
Excuse me, but if you think I'm scum and lying about my role, this means we have no (as in, 0) confo villagers.
Because if I'm lying, RG could be my scum partner saying Im clean. And I was the one who cleaned Wander, which means if I'm not clean, Wander isn't either.
We didn't waste a lynch because the smart thing to do would be no lynch. Lynching you is the same thing (supposedly). Therefore, we still win.

KoN has done several scummy things.
lol, are you serious?

His plan between Rev and Twisted could easily be set up so that he can not kill anybody tonight, tomorrow we lynch Rev (a townie) and then lose.
Except for the fact that I'm not scum, so I couldn't make this plan work.
Although I do like it... Maybe for future games? Thanks for the idea!

Except, I guess, for the new mayor role. Hopefully he'll survive (DON'T CLAIM).
He cant, he doesn't even know who he is.

He also claimed the same role as 3 other people with his cops, and can fly under the radar quite easily with RG cleaning him,
I claimed cop first (and role revealed second). You obviously missed that.

Rev is another cop who... hasn't done much. He's only on here because he isn't clean, but he's the least fishy right now.
Yeah... If you flip scum (highly likely at this point) we're taking Rev down next. Sorry, but this is so obviously defending it hurts.

Twisted was the last to claim. People said "if he was scum he would make his role match others" but I really don't think so... actually that is stupid.
Actually, I believe it was only I who said that. What I really meant was he would have stolen the alignment so it would match perfectly.
The fact that he didn't change it and was the one to point it out makes me cautious.

His wincon was slightly off scumtell but he talked about how changed the roles in the slightest way to screw with us.
Everyone else's roles were the same. TT isn't off my list yet.

My scumlist right now, clearly, is KoN and TwistedTurtwig and it's going to be difficult to sway from this IMO.
O...kay?

TL;DR:
all-that-you-think-you-know.jpg
Such Quotes
Very Interesting
So Boring
Wow
Much Typing
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

KoN that device was absolutely BS, no offense. You're defense consisted of two things really. "I'm not scum skin can't" and "I still think you will flip mafia" both of these are false, so that's stupid.

Your other defense is that you claimed it first, but prof p also provided you with fakes. He said it a while ago.
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Celever said:
KoN that device was absolutely BS, no offense. You're defense consisted of two things really. "I'm not scum skin can't" and "I still think you will flip mafia" both of these are false, so that's stupid.

Your other defense is that you claimed it first, but prof p also provided you with fakes. He said it a while ago.
lol
You just completely ignored my post, didn't you? I mean, you're so desperate, I'll be genuinely shocked if you don't die today.
...What device?

Here, let me give you the highlights of my post that you obviously didn't read:
Excuse me, but if you think I'm scum and lying about my role, this means we have no (as in, 0) confo villagers.
Because if I'm lying, RG could be my scum partner saying Im clean. And I was the one who cleaned Wander, which means if I'm not clean, Wander isn't either.
We didn't waste a lynch because the smart thing to do would be no lynch. Lynching you is the same thing (supposedly). Therefore, we still win.
There is no downside to voting you.
If you are telling the truth and are town, you'd be voting for yourself.
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Professor Palutena said:
Celever received enough votes to get lynched.

But he didn't die.

Night 1 begins now.

But he didn't die... LOLZ.
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

So Celever's cleared then? Wheeee. One townie confirmed. Unless Astra decided to troll us all by throwing in a wolf with an extra life.
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Celever is clean now.
See Celever? Now we have you as a confirmed townie as well. And the day ended in a no lynch, just as it should have.
No downside.

TwistedTurtwig said:
So Celever's cleared then? Wheeee. One townie confirmed. Unless Astra decided to troll us all by throwing in a wolf with an extra life.

Yeah, he's coroner. That means the scum is (probably) either you or Rev3rsor (or both, but that seems unlikely at this point).
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Yeah, Rev.
Reason being that this will almost certainly give us no death tonight.
Either the real wolf will try to blame Rev by not killing with you on him, or Rev really is the wolf and can't kill.
Either way, between me checking you and RG checking Rev, we should have a good idea about who to lynch tomorrow with no deaths from tonight.

...Unless you're the wolf. Which could mean that you either will try to blame Rev by not killing or kill me for checking you (and in turn look like scum).
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Guys I've said this time and time again -- I look like scum whether I am one or not.

Also keeper, I said early in the game that I would not be opposed to a lynch on me that day lol.

Also device = defense. Ty spellcheck.
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

I wasn't defending myself though, so its alright if my defense was terrible. I was pointing out that you had bad logic lol.
Did you vote for yourself? Or did I miss that as well?
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Keeper of Night said:
I wasn't defending myself though, so its alright if my defense was terrible. I was pointing out that you had bad logic lol.
Did you vote for yourself? Or did I miss that as well?

I was at school, so no.
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Guys I've said this time and time again -- I look like scum whether I am one or not.

Doesn't matter if it's true, that's the worst defence ever. If you were a wolf, you could easily have said that. Same with you being a towns person.
'Guys, I look scummy every game. So don't lynch me. Trust me completely guys. Absolutely no chance I'm a wolf, since I look scummy every game.'

So, we have a confirmed Celever, who won't die tonight. We also have RG, KoN and rev3 as cops.

RG seered KoN as town, KoN seered me as town, and Rev3 didn't seer anyone. Twisted on the other hand is a blocker. Twisted who did you block last night? I don't believe you said that.

Obviously, myself and Celever haven't used any actions, since no dead people yet. If someone dies tonight, they're obviously town. So if RG dies, then we can confirm KoN as town. If KoN dies, we can confirm myself as town. And, with whoever RG or KoN seer tonight, we get another town/wolf out of TT and Rev3rsor.

So, I guess tonight, no matter who dies, we'll have a confirmed town, since if TT or Rev3 die, then both RG and KoN's cop powers will work. While Celever and I cannot die.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top