Finished The Challenge: Season 4 - Keeper of Night takes it all!

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Wait a second. If Celever has a role that steals a role from another player, maybe the other scum has it too. Meaning, RG is definitely scum if that's true, since TT has a lone role, which no one has.

Ugh, input, anyone?
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

WanderingWolf said:
Wait a second. If Celever has a role that steals a role from another player, maybe the other scum has it too. Meaning, RG is definitely scum if that's true, since TT has a lone role, which no one has.

Ugh, input, anyone?
Click to expand...
You do realize that since this is an open setup game (all the roles are publicly available), and there is no role that steals a role from another player, your idea is illogical, right?
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

<Celever> of my ability
<Celever> which is
<Celever> to be able to target a person each night and copy their role for the following night
<EgleBravas> so it's luckbased
<EgleBravas> typical
<Celever> no, i hit go
<Celever> ld
<Celever> I targeted James (who is still an ashsole)
<Celever> and got coroner
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

he's lying
(I don't know this for sure, but that's the only logical conclusion)
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

rev3rsor said:
he's lying
(I don't know this for sure, but that's the only logical conclusion)
Click to expand...

We're both male. Who's lying?
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Isn't it funny how celever hasn't appeared to defend himself from the scum charges yet?

I hope you guys never go to law school.
 
Last edited:
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Y-y-you actually beleived that!

tumblr_inline_mxrsjzkCIk1rszwma.gif
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Professor Palutena said:
WanderingWolf said:
Wait a second. If Celever has a role that steals a role from another player, maybe the other scum has it too. Meaning, RG is definitely scum if that's true, since TT has a lone role, which no one has.

Ugh, input, anyone?
Click to expand...
You do realize that since this is an open setup game (all the roles are publicly available), and there is no role that steals a role from another player, your idea is illogical, right?
Click to expand...

Theres also no killing role, yet we have dead people.

You arent exactly playing fair, Palutena. -_-
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

I figured that was a standard aspect of vanilla mafia, which is why I didn't add it to the list.
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Professor Palutena said:
I figured that was a standard aspect of vanilla mafia, which is why I didn't add it to the list.
Click to expand...

Cops are also the standard aspect of mafia. As well as roleblockers. And doctors. And VTs
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

Cops aren't in every game, believe it or not.

Every game has some sort of scum. It may be a mafia household, an independent killer, or both.
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

You role blocked me TT? I didn't get any seer results.
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

WanderingWolf said:
RG.

Well, that lynch was wasted. I'm not going to die, but I guess we have 2 confovillagers

When I'm not lynched, the way I see it is there are 3 scums: KoN, Rev and Twisted.
Click to expand...

Celever knew he wasn't going to be lynched, and therefore, confirmed town. So, he said that everyone but myself and RG are scum. Myself was called town, since he already said a few times he trusts me as town, but this was the first time he mentioned that RG was town.

Putting my vote on RaichuGirl tomorrow.
Click to expand...

Also, your reason to vote me was that Celever pegged me as town, which is rediculus, as at the start of yesterday before it was revealled that he was a wolf, I was the one he wanted to lynch.

Celever said:
I actually coronered twisted. I thought that as we were to coroner RG or KoN last night then twisted would certainly get the knife. Turns out he didn't, and this is quite awkward now.

Wait, why would he not die? James and I were death proof and both RG and KoN were being coronered. So basically, he would have died? Rev or Twisted. Of course, this could all be a huge framing, but since yesterday I thought that twisted was scummy...

Let's lynch RG. Who else would frame twisted so well? James is coroner, I have little doubt about that, but RG is one of the 3 cop claims. He killed KoN to try and make sure twisted or rev would get lynched today. James and I are confo, one of rev and twisted are scum and that leaves RG.
Click to expand...
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

If you were expecting a standard mafia, james, you haven't been playing with P and I long enough.

What's the god damn point if P told you off the start what roles the mafia has? you have to work for it.
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

No rush voting guys. We seriously have to think this threw.
 
RE: Pain and Suffering: Season 4 - Challenge 15 is up!

and just to contribute a bit of pointless discussion, I'd like to add that I've played mafia irl with just VTs and vanilla scum (with the scum kill). It's a great of getting to know others better, and creates a bit of fun in a bit of time.
So doctor/cop/RB/etc. aren't 100% necessary.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top