The Challenge: Season 5 | Rev3rsor is the Winner!

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Nothing you have posted confirms anyone as town. I'd honestly rather keep around someone who has common sense but is apathetic rather than someone who attempts to metagame and use false logic to jump to conclusions. I think I'll keep my vote where it is.
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Celever said:
So, all of the scum must be people who are able to be online for long enough to come up with a possible kill at the very latest time of 20 to 9 PM my time. This narrows down the scumlist a fair bit.

TheGuy
DevinTheWelf
rev3rsor
Luispipe8
Eron
Athena
Celever
Cobalt Phoenix

rev is dead, so that leaves:

TheGuy
DevinTheWelf
Luispipe8
Eron
Athena
Celever
Cobalt Phoenix

This means that the scum cannot be:
TheGuy, DevinTheWelf

I'm not scum, so that leaves: Athena, Eron, Luispipe8, Cobalt Phoenix.

This is half of the game of 8. There will be a maximum of...uhh... one scum; this gives us town a mislynch, and would be standard setup. Especially with the kill... because there's only one wolf at most...
Click to expand...

Once TheGuy revealed himself as a user of the invisible status, Devin became the only confirmed villager. It is physically impossible for him to be scum, as all scum members must be in agreement of a kill (as is the norm in Werewolf, anyway), and Devin lacked the ability to be a part of this due to activity. This isn't "metagaming and using false logic to jump to conclusions" I just wanted to point it out. If you really don't think what I'm saying here is truthful, then you're delusional ._.

If I die, then TheGuy should take my place as lead. I know that Devin has never played werewolf before, much like Luispipe8 and Eron, so... well, this is going to be fun 9.9. If I die, you'll have half of the players knowing what they're doing, and the other half not. As such, if an experienced player is scum, they can convince the noobies and win right there. Athena, do you really want this?
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

A-are we gonna continue this shit?
Vote Count said:
PG24: Athena, Celever, Eron, Celever, Cobalt Phoenix, Athena (2)
Celever: Luispipe8, Athena (2)
Luispipe8: Celever, Celever (0)
Athena: Celever (1)
Click to expand...
I mean come on, guys. We need to have majority soon!
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

By the way, I have no problem with Policy Lynching Athena. I mean, it's absolutely possible PG24 is once again the culprit. His shock of finding out Bippa (PP) used the same tactic he himself used in Season 2 was definitely unexpected. Thing is, Athena doesn't want to help, as is proven by her by her image above. I dunno, what do y'all think? Also, will Devin PLEASE post for God's sake?
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Unvote: PG24
Vote: Celever

That's the only way we can get a lynch with no problems as no one is posting.
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Vote: Athena

I'm in agreement with Celever and CP's reasoning. Join me Eron of whoever gets online in the next 13 minutes.
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

athena is dead

athena was a wolf

it's now night phase, so send in your night roles if you have 'em.
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Luispipe8 is dead

day phase begin

you have until the 13th to discuss and lynch someone
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

ofc town

if i don't say their role or alignment by mistake, always assume townie with nothing special
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

If you're wolf, please claim. There are probably two of them total, and Athena is gone. If you're her scum partner and you lose, which is pretty likely seeing as we have two mislynches right now, if you claim wolf we will see whether to spare you or not. If you don't, and we lynch you by accident, then it's you're own fault that you got eliminated! /me shrugs
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

The hell kind of logic is that? What wolf in their right mind would claim wolf willy-nilly?! I know your name is Celever, but you're not being too clever right now. (Unless you're just trolling...I can't tell)
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Cobalt Phoenix said:
The hell kind of logic is that? What wolf in their right mind would claim wolf willy-nilly?! I know your name is Celever, but you're not being too clever right now. (Unless you're just trolling...I can't tell)
Click to expand...

This isn't a game of Werewolf. Well, it is, but in the end, this is The Challenge. The losing team gets am elimination vote said team's members, and the wolf will undoubtedly be eliminated. They can try and win, but at this stage I find it somewhat unlikely. As such, if you have connections with players, and are scum, the best thing to do would be to claim. Thanks to Athena's immunity, you are going DOWN if you lose this challenge... Which you won't do by claiming.
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

The only person who isn't dead and didn't vote for Athena is Cobalt Phoenix.. Need I say more?

Vote: Cobalt Phoenix
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top