Mostly so I don't completely fail to finish up, here's another part of my ramblings. Thanks to all for humoring me in this. Also, a semi-major edit to an earlier post; replaced one sentence with another that - to me - are saying the same thing, but the latter is clearer. Especially as the latter is now accompanied with a paragraph containing an example of the thing. XP
The title of this thread is "Vmaxes, ADP, and the Terrible Power Creep". I
finally chimed in because these are
not the big problem with the Pokémon TCG. They're
symptoms of it. Am I just playing word games? Maybe, but I'm
finally getting close to explaining myself with the above laid out. I think I have one more
general principle to go, and I finally remembered what I was going to say when I was awake enough and had the time to say it.
Broken cards are a mountain range. What do I mean?
Whatever we think of as "broken" cards, cards that are damaging to game balance and enjoyment to such a severe degree that it calls for special recognition and (hopefully) action to remedy, it is
not a binary deal. Though it may be beyond me to work out in many cases,
any card can be rendered broken with the proper conditions surrounding it. That same card can also be any flavor of balanced, or be unbalanced in the opposite direction e.g. be bad and/or filler. Sometimes this is due to the game's rules and how they have changed, other times it is due to combos or even entire decks, and still other times it is due to the
whims of players. Yes, if enough of us play Card X over Card Y because "Card X is
kewl!" it can distort a metagame where Card X, Card Y, and Card Z all balanced each other out, but only if they're played in roughly equal amounts. If this isn't crazy enough yet, none of these are mutually elusive, either.
Not only can cards be broken in different ways, but they can be different amounts or "sizes" of broken. Closely related to this is a potentially controversial statement:
broken cards may not necessarily be used competitively. So, some cards are just more broken than others; if you don't believe me, we can do a quick thought experiment. We'll use
fake cards in a
fake Format for the sake of those who believe all Ace Spec card are balanced; if you do
not believe all Ace Spec cards are balanced, you already have your answer. The Format is the Expanded Format, but all real Ace Spec cards have been banned. All that exists for Ace Specs are Ace Spec A, Ace Spec B, Ace Spec C, Ace Spec D, Ace Spec E, Ace Spec F, and Ace Spec G.
Ace Spec A through G are all Trainer-Items, the same in every way
except for their effects.
- Ace Spec A's effect says "Add 1 of your Prize cards to your hand. This counts as taking a Prize."
- Ace Spec B's effect says "Add 2 of your Prize cards to your hand. This counts as taking a Prize."
- Ace Spec C's effect says "Add 3 of your Prize cards to your hand. This counts as taking a Prize."
- Ace Spec D's effect says "Add 4 of your Prize cards to your hand. This counts as taking a Prize."
- Ace Spec E's effect says "Add 5 of your Prize cards to your hand. This counts as taking a Prize."
- Ace Spec F's effect says "Add 6 of your Prize cards to your hand. This counts as taking a Prize."
- Ace Spec G's effect says "You win this game."
They're Ace Spec cards, so they are all mutually exclusive; you run one and you
cannot run any of the others. Even with Item-lock being a thing, it seems unlikely anyone would opt to run anything but Ace Spec G, and that few decks would
not run an Ace Spec at all.
Where do the mountains come in? Not only are there different kinds of mountains (I think), but you can have an entire mountain range with mountains of different sizes, but depending on where you stand, your view of the biggest mountain can be blocked by a mere foothill. Even when dealing with full on mountains, you may not realize Mountain #6 is in your way until you clear Mountains #1 - #5. That is how it is with the metagame. Ban one broken card, and another broken card may take its place, or you may have merely made a particular deck/combo
less broken, but the rest is still there plain as day.
Okay, okay. As always, let me know if anyone still cares about this, and I am so sorry for the
massive delay. We really are closing in, and the conclusion will probably be disappointingly simple, maybe even obvious... but I thank you all for putting up with this. I've tried to skip straight to the conclusion before, but I usually then have to explain some or all of the above, with most having written it off
long before I finish.