Finished Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Nerds Win

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

@PMJ What DV said. Meaty is a neutral...but that doesn't mean your theory gives us no leads. As you said, why would the jocks want to kill you? You are no threat to anyone except Meaty who you aren't going to kill now anyways. The only reason the jocks would try and kill you is if the alpha jock was someone who didn't know or read your full role correctly. That person, to have missed such an important piece of information, must have not been playing this game very much. Hence, someone on the inactive list. Or even better yet, the person who replaced Shining Raikou.

Shining Raikou was replaced quickly, leading us to believe he had an important role. That replacement might have not read through the full game yet. In fact, if that replacement had just read the first few pages, PMJ would seem like a perfect kill to that replacement. I think pokenerd, the replacement, has a very good chance of being the Alpha jock.

I'm tempted to vote for him this instant because so many things point to him being the Alpha, but I'll wait to hear what everyone else thinks first.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Okay guys, I'm trying to get caught up so I can play this fully. Would be it possible for someone to give a quick re-cap of the important details of the game, I.E, who has been deemed suspicious right now, what do we know about the opposing faction(s), etc.

I will of course look back in the thread but in case I miss anything a re-cap would be good to have.

Thanks!
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Blah237 said:
Shining Raikou was replaced quickly, leading us to believe he had an important role. That replacement might have not read through the full game yet. In fact, if that replacement had just read the first few pages, PMJ would seem like a perfect kill to that replacement. I think pokenerd, the replacement, has a very good chance of being the Alpha jock.

I'm tempted to vote for him this instant because so many things point to him being the Alpha, but I'll wait to hear what everyone else thinks first.
Click to expand...

Mother of God just stop talking. This is why everyone voted for you so quickly. You make accusations without any proper backup. SR was probably too busy to continue playing the game, or he completely forgot about it.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Guys, you're missing something fairly important.

Brisk Cakers said:
Vote Count

Blah237 - 7 (yes, it is right)
Click to expand...

Why would he say that? I went back and counted, and only 6 people had voted for Blah. That means that either ISB, Hatman, or Teapot's vote counts as double, at least for today.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Night 2 End 11/25/2011 7AM GMT+8

DNA said:
...I am now more awake.
Click to expand...

GEEZ ESP, how did none of us notice that? Either someone has a role that lets them do that and REALLY wants me dead, or someone received a powerup. Like the two people Darkrai's nightmare powered up. But, I'd like to focus on my previous "accusation" against pokenerd.

ISB, how are you not getting this? I am not randomly accusing him. I'm sayin g the evidence I see adds up. Here's my thinking:

Shining Raikou was replaced for inactivity. That probably meant he was just busy or something. While I agree with that, notice he was replaced BEFORE the night. This is reinforced by the fact some other people were replaced AFTER the night. That obviously shows that Shining Raikou had some kind of important night role. What's a more important night role than a werewolf?

Now consider this. The jocks tried to kill PMJ. No informed werewolf in their right mind would try to kill PMJ because he's totally harmless. No INFORMED werewolf. Pokenerd, as having just replaced Shining Raikou, was probably pretty uninformed. Let's look at it from pokenerd's point of view. He probably read through the first few pages of the game. In the first few pages of the game, PMJ seems like a reasonable choice to kill.

I'm not randomly accusing, I'm trying to make sense here. Plases tell me someone sees what I'm seeing.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

ESP said:
Why would he say that? I went back and counted, and only 6 people had voted for Blah. That means that either ISB, Hatman, or Teapot's vote counts as double, at least for today.
Click to expand...

tumblr_lozmrfm2OW1qjz4v5.jpg


That could be either good or bad...
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

I am confused. How could ISB's vote count for double? He was not hit with any power ups.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

ESP said me, Hatman, or Teapot could have our votes count as double.

Although, it could be DNA. He was hit by a power-up overnight. Maybe the power-up effected his vote count without him even being notified. Just a little theory, shouldn't be a problem if it only counts for one day.

TDL got hit with a power-up too, by the way.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Actually, ISB, you are wrong. After DNA and ESP voted for Blah237 RB said he had 2 votes, Swain voted for him and he had 3 votes, then ISB, Hatman, and Teapot voted for Blah237 and he had 7. So, obviously, its either ISB, Hatman, and Teapot. Also, DN powers up their roles. It doesn't make any sense at all that it would be because of him that they would have a double vote power. Read more closely...
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Ummmm.... DV? I was expecting a little help here for my theory on pokenerd. Anyone who sees this, please go back a page and look at my posts.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Blah237 said:
Ummmm.... DV? I was expecting a little help here for my theory on pokenerd. Anyone who sees this, please go back a page and look at my posts.
Click to expand...

Is it just me, or does this seem that Blah and DV are connected in some way? Maybe I'm just reading inbetween the lines too much...
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Dark Void said:
Actually, ISB, you are wrong. After DNA and ESP voted for Blah237 RB said he had 2 votes, Swain voted for him and he had 3 votes, then ISB, Hatman, and Teapot voted for Blah237 and he had 7. So, obviously, its either ISB, Hatman, and Teapot. Also, DN powers up their roles. It doesn't make any sense at all that it would be because of him that they would have a double vote power. Read more closely...
Click to expand...

Whoever had the double vote would know it, so I'd bet it's Hatman or Teapot. It's just something we need to be aware of.

Zorua said:
Is it just me, or does this seem that Blah and DV are connected in some way? Maybe I'm just reading inbetween the lines too much...
Click to expand...

I think you're reading between the lines too much lol.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

You're reading between the lines too much. I was simply saying that because DV was one of the people who didn't vote for me.

But seriously, does anyone have anything else to say on my pokenerd theory? I would vote for him immediately but I want to see if anyone has anything more to contribute.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

I know Blah237 in real life, so its possible that could be the reason he said that. I don't honestly know though. (Don't worry, we haven't been in contact since this started). As for the pokenerd thing, I don't feel that there is much more to say on the topic until more people give their opinions on its viability.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Vote: pokenerd

Fine then. Now it's turned more serious. I didn't want to vote because people have been saying I jump and accuse on a whim, but there's just too many things that point to him being a jock, more likely the Alpha than not.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Mizublue said:
You know, Blah seems like a townie to me. His abysmal spelling, grammar, previous super annoying over the top positiveness, and whack ideas, it seems like it's all part of his role. This could be easily be a ruse (like with Guy and the southern accent), but I'm not too sure about that. He doesn't seem like the type to do something like that.
Click to expand...
... ...
>.<
I totally forgot about this. I remember saying earlier that Blah's role was making him act stupid for whatever reason, making me think he's a townie. Yet now at this point I have (unfortunately) started a bandwagon that will lead to Blah being lynched. Although, I did admit that I wanted him lynched mostly to stop talking.

Unvote: blah237

I'm not going to revote at this time, however. Even if there is a random lynch, I don't want a definite lynch to get someone who I believe to be a townie. (Stupid memory lapses.) I may revote for Blah, but I don't know.

DNA said:
ESP said me, Hatman, or Teapot could have our votes count as double.

Although, it could be DNA. He was hit by a power-up overnight. Maybe the power-up effected his vote count without him even being notified. Just a little theory, shouldn't be a problem if it only counts for one day.

TDL got hit with a power-up too, by the way.
Click to expand...
Whoever the double voter person is, it isn't me. I'll just tell you that up front. This was proven earlier by Risk: when myself and one other person voted (I think it was ESP? I'm too lazy to go look back through the thread), Risk said the total vote count was 2. That means that it could not have been me.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Bandwagon, you say?

bandwagon-2.jpg


That's you in the front there DNA xD I'm just kidding. Thanks for unvoting me.

Also, haven't we figured out by now that most of the active players are neutral? If I was a wolf, I probably would try and draw less attention to myself and I wouldn't have the most posts on this thread. No, really. I'm not exaggerating. Don't believe me? Check this out:

http://www.pokebeach.com/forums/misc.php?action=whoposted&tid=102379
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Okay.

I would like to refute the theory that Shining Raikou, and thus me, was the Jock Head. My reason for this is that at the beginning of night 1, Shining Raikou was listed as an inactive. However, when Night 1 ended, the jocks attempted a kill (TDL). However, Shining Raikou was still listed as an inactive. How could Shining Raikou have been the Jock Head? If he had PMed in a kill, he would have been taken off the inactive list.

Therefore, it is not possible for me to be the Jock Head as I replaced Shining Raikou.

And by the way, my name is Argetlam now :)
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

That's a fine point you have there pokener- I mean Argetlam.

Unvote: pokenerd/Argetlam

I may revote you, I don't know yet. But do you have any idea why the jocks would go for PMJ then?
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

I really don't know... Perhaps they knew of his role that will kill someone who suspects him and didn't want to risk it? Just a shot in the dark...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top