Finished Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Nerds Win

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

In all seriousness, I don't think Blah is a threat. The only way he could be is if he was a non-neutral that is just acting silly as a coverup. But I think he has just had bad luck and has said the wrong thing at the wrong times, so people jumped on him.

I'm still suspicious of inactives.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

^ Finally, something I said being brought back. Inactives should be at the top of our suspicion list right now, considering most of the active players seem to be neutral.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Wow...the jocks suck...

Interesting how DNA was targeted, but redirected to PMJ. Looks like we have a "throw-under-the-bus" person.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

ISB said:
Wow...the jocks suck...

Interesting how DNA was targeted, but redirected to PMJ. Looks like we have a "throw-under-the-bus" person.
Click to expand...

I suspect that the someone with that "throw under the bus person" was someone who was suspicious of PMJ, so they didn't want to be killed and so they redirected at PMJ. Just an observation, if we think that this guy is an indie, because it certainly wouldn't be a nerd/jock role, since it redirected both of them.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

I think inactives are indeed suspicious. I feel like nerds/jocks aren't paying much attention to the thread at all, and are mostly acting through PM. :/ I mean, I think it's really weird that both factions went for DNA when they could have gone for the priest, who they should know by now is me... Maybe each faction assumed that the other faction would target me and went for DNA instead? Who knows...
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

I think you are right, Meaty. But who should we single out?
I still think the inactives who got replaced are a good bet. Because they must've had an important role to be replaced so quickly.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Let's try to figure out who is the DNA-targetting type.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Not-TDL said:
No, Meaty was a Priest. And don't forget, don't we still have that public-view revealing seer or something?

Oh yeah, change my name in the OP too, Brisk Cakers :3
Click to expand...

The public revealing seer is dead...

Because we lynched him...

Wow, the jocks aren't having very good luck this game. I don't think they've actually killed someone themselves in the whole game. It is odd they both went for DNA though, just like meaty said. And I don't think someone would use that ability (redirecting) on DNA (who wasn't a likely kill until now) if he/she could only use it 2/3 times. I find it more likely that the person chanting the spells is an indie and can use that role every night. Just a hunch.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

superpokemon67 said:
The public revealing seer is dead...

Because we lynched him...

Wow, the jocks aren't having very good luck this game. I don't think they've actually killed someone themselves in the whole game. It is odd they both went for DNA though, just like meaty said. And I don't think someone would use that ability (redirecting) on DNA (who wasn't a likely kill until now) if he/she could only use it 2/3 times. I find it more likely that the person chanting the spells is an indie and can use that role every night. Just a hunch.
Click to expand...

Well, it looks like we are in a pickle... Do we even have any leads at all? If there is another seer out there... Start investigating people dude!! We need clues!

For your convienience:

1. TheGuy (Guy89)
2. Storm Blade (eevee)
3. Lenny KILLED BY NERDS NIGHT 1 (like any game host)
4. oyeah1988
5. Hatman
6. TDL (TheDarkLucario)
7. ISB (slickmario)
8. Chillarmy Lynched Day 2
9. Blah237
10. Gale
11. Meaty
12. Yoshidude10 Lynched Day 1
13. sillykyle
14. Rock Wrecker
15. DNA
16. ESP
17. PMJ
18. PokeChamp
19. superpokemon67
20. Hypnotic Luxray
21. doublenikesocks (Azelf Master)
22. pokenerd
23. Dark Void
24. Tyraniking
25. Teapot (The Power of Three)
26. safariblade
27. Blue Thunder
28. Nengeni
29. Mizublue
30. Darkrai's Nightmare Died along with Chillarmy Day 2
31. swain (batui4)
32. Zorua (Darkvoid57)

Blah237 87
DNA 62
Brisk Cakers 47
Meaty 44
PMJ 36
Dark Void 34
ESP 34
doublenikesocks 31
Mr. Tea 26
superpokemon67 22
oyeah1988 21
Not-TDL 21
Starboard Driger 20
ISB 19
Chillarmy 18
TheGuy 17
safariblade 15
Rock Wrecker 14
dmaster 14
Zorua 12
NinjaSamurai 11
Teapot 10
Storm Blade 10
swain 10
Argetlam 8
TDL 7
Peachy 7
The Yoshi(yoshidude10) 6
PokeChamp 5
HypnoticLuxray 4
sillykyle 3
Gale 3
Nengeni 3
Shining Raikou 2
Lenny 2
Blue Thunder 1
Jade 1
Afro-G 1
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

So through this night we lost PMJ, which is a shame as he was contributing actively to the discussion, and before his untimely death, he took out an indie for us. His presence within the game will surely be missed.

We also found out that DNA is quite likely to be a neutral, seeing as he is neither nerd or jock (unless they're trolling us and killing their own peeps, which I doubt).

As far as that goes, what are our current leads (if any)? Is it time to start targeting inactives and getting them to talk?
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Sorry I haven't been posting much guys. I've actually been looking at the thread quite a bit but I never really have much to say that hasn't already been said. I also never seem to be around in the very short amount of time between the accusation and the lynch. On topic, I suspect that DNA might have a role that moves kills off of him. If so, he's most likely a townie because roles like that aren't usually given to evil roles.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Night 3 End 12/2/2011 7AM GMT+8

Brisk Cakers said:
As the students were about to sleep, someone was chanting a weird spell and spirits were sent out. These spirits both went to DNA and PMJ's room and they both felt a bit weirder as the spirits engulfed them.

Click to expand...


Since it says that the spirits went to DNA and PMJ's rooms I'm pretty sure that that means DNA isn't the one who used his role, since it seems like the person targeted him. Shifting night roles off of DNA onto PMJ might be something to look into though, since we know DNA isn't nerd or jock aligned, so the person who protected him is probably (emphasis on probably) a townie.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Night 3 End 12/2/2011 7AM GMT+8

Dark Void said:
Since it says that the spirits went to DNA and PMJ's rooms I'm pretty sure that that means DNA isn't the one who used his role, since it seems like the person targeted him. Shifting night roles off of DNA onto PMJ might be something to look into though, since we know DNA isn't nerd or jock aligned, so the person who protected him is probably (emphasis on probably) a townie.
Click to expand...

I think "chanting spells" sounds more indie than townie, but that's just my two cents. Maybe there's a school cultist?
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Shifting night roles off of DNA onto PMJ might be something to look into though, since we know DNA isn't nerd or jock aligned, so the person who protected him is probably (emphasis on probably) a townie.
Click to expand...
Either a townie or an indie. However, due to past experience seeing how WW roles work, it's most likely a townie. And since Guy was confirmed to be indie, the % chance of anyone else being an indie is now that much lower.

And apparently someone besides Meaty can protect townies, which is a good thing. (Or at least, that's what I got.) Even so that doesn't mean Meaty isn't a valuable asset.

wow I made more posts in this thread than other people?
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Guys, you should know that whoever revealed PMJ and TheGuy's identities night 1 wast not Chillarmy. His role worked quite differently. I'm pretty sure I know who that mysterious night 1 seer is, and why they've yet to use their ability again. However, I won't say who I think it is or the wolves will easily just go for him... Sure I can always protect, but I'm still playing it safe. But to be honest, if you look at one of my recent posts and review the events of day 2 you should be able to figure out what I'm getting at. If I am indeed correct with this, they should know who they are when they read this. I just wish I could confirm my theory.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Meaty said:
Guys, you should know that whoever revealed PMJ and TheGuy's identities night 1 wast not Chillarmy. His role worked quite differently. I'm pretty sure I know who that mysterious night 1 seer is, and why they've yet to use their ability again. However, I won't say who I think it is or the wolves will easily just go for him... Sure I can always protect, but I'm still playing it safe. But to be honest, if you look at one of my recent posts and review the events of day 2 you should be able to figure out what I'm getting at. If I am indeed correct with this, they should know who they are when they read this. I just wish I could confirm my theory.
Click to expand...

I didn't even have to look at day 2 to know who your getting at. Protecting probably is a good idea, because I won't name names, but you made it obvious with your last couple of posts who it is.

As for potential leads, I don't have any. If you want me to seriously reach I can figure out who's suspicious of who right now, but that probably won't accomplish anything besides some wasted time and arguments.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Guys, you should know that whoever revealed PMJ and TheGuy's identities night 1 wast not Chillarmy. His role worked quite differently.
Click to expand...
Umm, how? Both(or three if counting Guy's) reveals worked the same exact way. Explain.

It seems we still have a seer,(what is this madness) but why on Earth would this person come out and tell everyone his finds? He would die. (On Night 5, is that a record?)


DNA said:
I will tell you up front that I am a neutral, but I don't think I know a way that I can prove that to you guys without getting modkilled.

(but seriously, have any of you actually known me to lie?)
Click to expand...

DNA said:
Point taken, but what's the likelihood that I'm an indie?
Click to expand...

DNA said:
Indeed. But think of it this way; if the nerds and jocks really want me dead, they'll just try and kill me again the next night. Lynching me won't accomplish anything. In fact it'll just help them out.

We need to seriously put our heads together and figure out what leads we do have.
Click to expand...

IDK, it's probably just me being paranoid, but does DNA seem a little less calm and collected in these posts then he usually is? I'm not suggesting lynching him, (that would be stupid) but I want to see if anyone else is getting this vibe.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

I think you are probably paranoid.

I've just gotten used to the fact that I am usually targeted by the wolf factions, and this applies to pretty much any Werewolf game. I've built up a reputation of being a very good Werewolf player, and thus being targeted by the jocks and the nerds doesn't come as a big surprise to me. I knew it was going to happen eventually.

But also lately in real life I've been feeling a bit more calm than I usually have as well (for whatever reason), so that could be part of it.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

HypnoticLuxray said:
Umm, how? Both(or three if counting Guy's) reveals worked the same exact way. Explain.

It seems we still have a seer,(what is this madness) but why on Earth would this person come out and tell everyone his finds? He would die. (On Night 5, is that a record?)





IDK, it's probably just me being paranoid, but does DNA seem a little less calm and collected in these posts then he usually is? I'm not suggesting lynching him, (that would be stupid) but I want to see if anyone else is getting this vibe.
Click to expand...

A little, but lynching him at the moment would be stupid.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

I'm pretty convinced that DNA is a neutral.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top