Finished Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Rejects Win.

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

Hi, I don't have proper internet access until Monday so it would be great if you guys can discuss until then without me. The browser of my phone is unpredictable and all I write gets often lost.

Short thoughts: some genius passed me the curry. Fox had pretty much my role but just better AND I had to save him? Azhole. :C Well my FS is better at least.
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

I was passed an item last night. The question is: if Teal and I were both passed an item last night, why did Chillarmy's role only show me as holding an item?
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

Sir Taco said:
I was passed an item last night. The question is: if Teal and I were both passed an item last night, why did Chillarmy's role only show me as holding an item?
Either somebody's lying, or it's a faulty role.
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

On the topic of items, does anyone have dragoon pieces? It would be interesting if they were in the game
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

Chill's info should be from night 5, that's why.
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

Sir Taco said:
I was passed an item last night. The question is: if Teal and I were both passed an item last night, why did Chillarmy's role only show me as holding an item?

Because he used it Night 5. X-Ray Visor can't be used if it was used the night before, so if he used it N5, he couldn't use it for Night 6 (last night, when Teal got his item. That's why he didn't show up on Chillarmy's data), which makes his next night for data N7 (tonight, as Chillarmy said).
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

Maybe he used it earlier then night 5, and just decided not to use it night 6. I'm already voting for him, but you might want to wait to see what he says before you vote for him.
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

That was for sure night 5... Sir Taco didn't you have an item that makes it so that you can't be protected?
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

Chillarmy said:
That was for sure night 5... Sir Taco didn't you have an item that makes it so that you can't be protected?

First: Sir Taco lied about that Item to get the scum to kill him, because his final smash was active, which made him deathproof for 3 nights.
Second: DNA WAS DEAD ON NIGHT 5!

Vote Chillarmy guys. His story is most definitely not adding up.

Also, I'd like to point out that out that out of all the people he claims had Items, 2 are dead, and 1 didn't have an Item. Out of the 2 remaining people, I know Bo$$ isn't a wolf, so I think if Chillarmy is a wolf, Starboard could be the last wolf.
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

I had the item for real, but I passed it to someone N5.
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

Oh, I figured out what happened. If you look at my role closely, it says that on the following day a list of the players with items will be PMed to you. It turns out that i used my ability on Night 4 and got my info day5. This screwed me up into thinking I couldn't use it again until tonight, and that i got my info for Night 5. My bad.

Also, I wanted to withhold this info, but I do have the Metal Box item which allows me to avoid death once, so if you lynch we I live, you waste a precious item, and you waste a lynching day.
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

Chillarmy said:
Oh, I figured out what happened. If you look at my role closely, it says that on the following day a list of the players with items will be PMed to you. It turns out that i used my ability on Night 4 and got my info day5. This screwed me up into thinking I couldn't use it again until tonight, and that i got my info for Night 5. My bad.

Also, I wanted to withhold this info, but I do have the Metal Box item which allows me to avoid death once, so if you lynch we I live, you waste a precious item, and you waste a lynching day.

Likely story. Can anyone confirm that the Metal Box is in this game? And that Chillarmy has it?

I'd also like to say again: Do we just keep voting for people until they don't role reveal/the reveal doesn't look legit?
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

Machamp the Champion said:
Also, I'd like to point out that out that out of all the people he claims had Items, 2 are dead, and 1 didn't have an Item. Out of the 2 remaining people, I know Bo$$ isn't a wolf, so I think if Chillarmy is a wolf, Starboard could be the last wolf.

Dat logic. "Bo$$ isn't a wolf, but Starboard could be because Chillarmy (correctly) claims he had an item."

???
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

Starboard Driger said:
Machamp the Champion said:
Also, I'd like to point out that out that out of all the people he claims had Items, 2 are dead, and 1 didn't have an Item. Out of the 2 remaining people, I know Bo$$ isn't a wolf, so I think if Chillarmy is a wolf, Starboard could be the last wolf.

Dat logic. "Bo$$ isn't a wolf, but Starboard could be because Chillarmy (correctly) claims he had an item."

???

It isn't exactly fool proof, but my "logic" is that he used a Power that let him see that Bo$$ had an item (which he did), and he mistakenly thought Sir Taco had an Item that night, and he would get the wolves to back him up on the other 3 spots (you, Tri3sten, and DNA).

It's definitely not the only option, but it's not like we have any other ideas on who the wolves are.
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

Teal - Falco
RaichuGirl - Lucario
Bo$$_89 - Donkey Kong
Dark Void - Ganondorf
Porygon-X - Zelda
Sir Taco - ROB
Machamp the Champion - Diddy Kong
Chillarmy - Samus
TheGuy - Mario
Starboard Driger - Pikachu
dmaster - Captain Falcon
Luckyfire - Sonic

Role Claims list for reference. I feel like our only 100% confirmed roles are LuckyFire, MtC, and Bo$$.

As for more suspicious role claims, I have a theory. I feel like PMJ would include the original twelve characters from SSB N64, and then we have our confirmed characters. I also feel that given both all three Links were here, Zelda and Ganondorf are likely roles. That leaves Teal (Falco), RaichuGirl (Lucario), and Sir Taco (ROB). Id like other peoples thoughts.
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

I feel like there would be a Luigi, and there's a good shot he's a reject too. Just because of the whole Mario overshadow thing. I don't think rejects always has to do with being in the games and being taken out/ other things like that.
 
RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

@Chillarmy, regular Link isn't in this game (at least, I don't remember him being in here. I checked the Players list and I couldn't find him).
@TheGuy, Luigi already died. He was Jay/Bisharp37.

I don't think that's great logic, Chillarmy. This game is about Brawl, and the characters that weren't in it. So, I don't think those people are any less suspicious then everyone else.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top