Finished Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Rejects Win.

[RaichuGirl]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 7 ends with 7 lynch votes.

Teal - Falco
RaichuGirl - Lucario
Bo$$_89 - Donkey Kong
Dark Void - Ganondorf
Porygon-X - Zelda
Sir Taco - ROB
Machamp the Champion - Diddy Kong
TheGuy - Mario
Starboard Driger - Pikachu
dmaster - Captain Falcon
Luckyfire - Sonic

Made a list of people with links to role reveals/proof

Here's the list you made yesterday.

I was going to send part A to chillarmy, but hesitated and decided to hold onto it. So even if the wolves have part b/c, I can keep part A safe.

The only other reason I can see someone targeting Chillarmy is they didn't want him to know/not know whether they had an item. I can't see why anyone would want him to not know that though?

 

[Teal]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

Oh man. I just realized I forgot to pass the curry. Ooooh man... (╯°□°）╯︵ ┻━┻)

 

[dmaster]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

Oh man. I just realized I forgot to pass the curry. Ooooh man... (╯°□°）╯︵ ┻━┻)

Anyway, I may as well respond to this post because I didn't get a chance too last Day.

Where are these posts that prove you are obviously town? You said yourself that you can't really reveal anything about your role without role revealing, so that must mean the only posts that indicate your townie-ness are you, well...acting like a townie. Which is exactly what every wolf ever tries to do.

The difference between a wolf acting like a town and a townie acting like a town is quite different. You have to realize here...I had the Metal Box there for a while and _just_ found it that it was stolen from me like last Day. I had basically complete protection, or thought I did at least. >_> I really had no reason to not blatantly look like a Townie knowing that I could survive a kill. There's a difference between being completely obvious and trying to _hide your intentions_. I'm not hiding them.

You haven't done anything obviously suspicous, but you haven't been obviously town (like you claim to be) either.

Except I have. Not one post implicates me as a wolf in any way, but if you were to take one and twist the words around and say that I'm lying, you're probably just a wolf trying to get a Day lynch for yourself anyhow.

Also, the only ones who haven't revealed or have solid evidence for being who they say they are are me, you, RaichuGirl, and Porygon-X, which makes you a bit more likely to be a wolf than everyone else.

Like I said before...there's really not much more that I can do besides role revealing and at this point, that's really just giving the wolves extra information. We see where that got Chillarmy...Sorry, but I just don't see the point. If you guys want to lynch me (most likely some of the voters would be probably wolves...), feel free because I really don't have much more of a defense after this. It's clear that the Town is inadequate at this point as they either can't read their own roles, misuse their abilities, or screw over each other. It wouldn't be the first time that the Town just submits to the Stolen that is occurring.

dmaster out.

 

[Starboard Driger]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

The difference between a wolf acting like a town and a townie acting like a town is quite different. You have to realize here...I had the Metal Box there for a while and _just_ found it that it was stolen from me like last Day. I had basically complete protection, or thought I did at least. >_> I really had no reason to not blatantly look like a Townie knowing that I could survive a kill. There's a difference between being completely obvious and trying to _hide your intentions_. I'm not hiding them.

So you're saying that because you didn't go full wolf while you had an item that protects you from death one time, you're a townie?

:/

Except I have. Not one post implicates me as a wolf in any way, but if you were to take one and twist the words around and say that I'm lying, you're probably just a wolf trying to get a Day lynch for yourself anyhow.

So you're saying that because you haven't done anything obviously wolfy, you aren't a wolf?

:/

Like I said before...there's really not much more that I can do besides role revealing and at this point, that's really just giving the wolves extra information. We see where that got Chillarmy...Sorry, but I just don't see the point. If you guys want to lynch me (most likely some of the voters would be probably wolves...), feel free because I really don't have much more of a defense after this. It's clear that the Town is inadequate at this point as they either can't read their own roles, misuse their abilities, or screw over each other. It wouldn't be the first time that the Town just submits to the Stolen that is occurring.

dmaster out.

Chillarmy was probably killed by some townie for the same reason he was lynched: he essentially screwed himself over and sounded like he was trying to cover his tracks. Almost everyone else has role revealed and hasn't suffered the same fate as him, so you can't use Chillarmy as a representation of what will happen if you role reveal.

 

[Machamp The Champion]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

The difference between a wolf acting like a town and a townie acting like a town is quite different. You have to realize here...I had the Metal Box there for a while and _just_ found it that it was stolen from me like last Day. I had basically complete protection, or thought I did at least. >_> I really had no reason to not blatantly look like a Townie knowing that I could survive a kill. There's a difference between being completely obvious and trying to _hide your intentions_. I'm not hiding them.

If it was that easy to differentiate a good wolf from a town, then we would've known who the wolves were days ago.

If you're a wolf, you should always act like a town. I've never even been a wolf in one of these games and I know how dumb that is (unless I somehow turn up wolf in this game :O). If you had the Metal Box, and decided to not act like a town, then if we lynch you, you get protected, and we just lynch you the next day. If we don't lynch you that day, it's probably because someone else was a more obvious lynch, and we would later come back to you after all the more obvious lynches were gone, and you wouldn't have your Metal Box anymore. If at any point a wolf drops there townie act, they're going to die.

This seems like a common wolf move, to use dumb logic and make it seem "so obvious" that they're town, when really, it doesn't in any way prove they're town.

Chillarmy was probably killed by some townie...

Why do you think this? It says he was killed by a sword, and the only characters left that have swords are Roy and Ganondorf, and Ganondorf pretty much never uses his sword. I guess it's possible that he was killed by the Beam Sword (if that's even in this game), but the fact that there was no mention of the wolves at all other then that kill makes me think it would be the wolf kill.

 

[Starboard Driger]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

Chillarmy was probably killed by some townie...

Why do you think this? It says he was killed by a sword, and the only characters left that have swords are Roy and Ganondorf, and Ganondorf pretty much never uses his sword. I guess it's possible that he was killed by the Beam Sword (if that's even in this game), but the fact that there was no mention of the wolves at all other then that kill makes me think it would be the wolf kill.

I don't know, I kind of just threw that out there without much thought. I didn't see why the wolves would kill someone who was well on his way to getting killed anyways, but then I read his Final Smash...now I know why.

I haven't seen or heard of the Beam Sword being in this game, so you're probably right about it being Roy.

 

[PMJ]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

Chillarmy was killed by scum.

 

[RaichuGirl]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

If they killed chillarmy because of the final smash, do you think one of the wolves could be holding an item currently, and was afraid of being role-revealled (That beam sword on Roy?).

The list he posted was

This is my most recent data:

Bo$$_89
DNA
Sir Taco
Starboard Driger
Tri3sten

My next night for data is tonight.

Tri3sten and DNA were wolves, leaving boss, Sir Taco and Starboard driger.

Boss is apparently in a mason group with MtC, so we could probably exclude him. Could ST or SD maybe be roy?

 

[Poseidon]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

If they killed chillarmy because of the final smash, do you think one of the wolves could be holding an item currently, and was afraid of being role-revealled (That beam sword on Roy?).

The list he posted was

This is my most recent data:


My next night for data is tonight.

Tri3sten and DNA were wolves, leaving boss, Sir Taco and Starboard driger.

Boss is apparently in a mason group with MtC, so we could probably exclude him. Could ST or SD maybe be roy?

Because Roy totally seems like he would pass a note under a door. You know town could hold an item too. Maybe a wolf didn't want Chillarmy to find out that they were passed an item. This all just seems like WIFOM to me.

 

[Dork Void]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

Uh....Roy is a Fire Emblem character. He has a sword. If Chillarmy was killed by the wolves, and he was killed by a sword, why can't Roy have done it without a beam sword? I suppose that the explanation that the wolves were afraid of Chillarmy getting the final smash seeing as how they wouldn't be able to kill them once that happened does make some sense though, but I'm not following the logic that one of the remaining wolves, specifically Roy, must have a beam sword.

I also don't really follow dmaster's logic at all; it seems like pretty bad reasoning to me and he hasn't done or said anything like that in other games, which I find odd. I'm not sure if he's scum, but he's looking kind of suspicious to me right now.

 

[Luckyfire]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

If they killed chillarmy because of the final smash, do you think one of the wolves could be holding an item currently, and was afraid of being role-revealled (That beam sword on Roy?).

The list he posted was

This is my most recent data:


My next night for data is tonight.

Tri3sten and DNA were wolves, leaving boss, Sir Taco and Starboard driger.

Boss is apparently in a mason group with MtC, so we could probably exclude him. Could ST or SD maybe be roy?

Lololol I misread "ST and SD" as "STD". Anyways, back on topic.

If they killed chillarmy because of the final smash, do you think one of the wolves could be holding an item currently, and was afraid of being role-revealled (That beam sword on Roy?).

The list he posted was

Tri3sten and DNA were wolves, leaving boss, Sir Taco and Starboard driger.

Boss is apparently in a mason group with MtC, so we could probably exclude him. Could ST or SD maybe be roy?

Because Roy totally seems like he would pass a note under a door. You know town could hold an item too. Maybe a wolf didn't want Chillarmy to find out that they were passed an item. This all just seems like WIFOM to me.

Hmm, Sir Taco sent me a note. Could be him, but I'm not sure.

Excuse me if you think I'm repeating things, but that's just the way I play the game. like a stupid boss

 

[Dork Void]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

Because Roy totally seems like he would pass a note under a door. You know town could hold an item too. Maybe a wolf didn't want Chillarmy to find out that they were passed an item. This all just seems like WIFOM to me.

Hmm, Sir Taco sent me a note. Could be him, but I'm not sure.

Excuse me if you think I'm repeating things, but that's just the way I play the game. like a stupid boss

Spoiler

 

[Teal]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

Oh my dog.

 

[Luckyfire]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

...
Did I just quote the person I was suspicious of.

Well, this is just great. I get handed an awesome role and I don't even know how to use it properly.

 

[Teal]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

...
Did I just quote the person I was suspicious of.

?

Well, this is just great. I get handed an awesome role and I don't even know how to use it properly.

How could you use a lynch proof role?

 

[Teal]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

Guys... three days...

 

[Starboard Driger]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

If they killed chillarmy because of the final smash, do you think one of the wolves could be holding an item currently, and was afraid of being role-revealled (That beam sword on Roy?).

The list he posted was

This is my most recent data:


My next night for data is tonight.

Tri3sten and DNA were wolves, leaving boss, Sir Taco and Starboard driger.

Boss is apparently in a mason group with MtC, so we could probably exclude him. Could ST or SD maybe be roy?

We've been through this already...that doesn't make any sense. I had an item at that time, and Chillarmy wasn't lying because Chillarmy is/was town. How does that in any way indicate that I'm a wolf? The same goes for ST.

At this point, I think our best lynch option is dmaster. He's been using faulty logic to justify the fact that he doesn't want to role reveal, and if that isn't wolfy behavior I don't know what is. (DNA did something similar, except he didn't use faulty logic.) Also, we don't really have anyone else, do we? >.>

 

[Dork Void]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

If they killed chillarmy because of the final smash, do you think one of the wolves could be holding an item currently, and was afraid of being role-revealled (That beam sword on Roy?).

The list he posted was

Tri3sten and DNA were wolves, leaving boss, Sir Taco and Starboard driger.

Boss is apparently in a mason group with MtC, so we could probably exclude him. Could ST or SD maybe be roy?

We've been through this already...that doesn't make any sense. I had an item at that time, and Chillarmy wasn't lying because Chillarmy is/was town. How does that in any way indicate that I'm a wolf? The same goes for ST.

I think the logic is since Chillarmy gets the ability to randomly see the roles of people holding items (and becomes deathproof) once he gets his final smash, the wolves would have killed him to prevent him from getting his final smash and getting lucky by seering a wolf. However, this would only be possible if a wolf was holding an item they didn't want to get rid of.

 

[Bo$$_89]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

I guess dmaster might be a good lynch. I can't think of anyone else really that should be lynched(Off the top of my head)

Vote: dmaster

 

[Starboard Driger]

RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 8 ends May 23 at 3 PM CST.

We've been through this already...that doesn't make any sense. I had an item at that time, and Chillarmy wasn't lying because Chillarmy is/was town. How does that in any way indicate that I'm a wolf? The same goes for ST.

I think the logic is since Chillarmy gets the ability to randomly see the roles of people holding items (and becomes deathproof) once he gets his final smash, the wolves would have killed him to prevent him from getting his final smash and getting lucky by seering a wolf. However, this would only be possible if a wolf was holding an item they didn't want to get rid of.

Oh, I see. I misread it as the same argument MtC was using a last Day.

But, as you said, I don't see why Roy--the guy with swords--would need a Beam Sword to kill with a sword. It's possible that he had another item, but they also could've just killed him to be safe. After all, it does last for two nights.

Was it Sir Taco's Final Smash that ended at the start of the day? If so, I suppose he's a lynch option too. (After all, he did threaten to "side" with the wolves.)