Finished Werewolf XVII: Universe - Game Over - Antagonists Win!

[Flys Gone 2071]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

I feel like the logic with James is like, "he's suspected every game" "so there's probably a good reason to lynch him this time."

He's only played 1 more game and he's terribly scummy there and here too. You know you can be scum in 2 consecutive games (I was scum on my first 2 games).

I voted for him because he wanted to start a wagon for no reason at all. He could easily be starting a wagon.

@MDL All wolves could potentially get caught if they would push for the same wagon (specially if it is as bad at the one James started). I''m not saying that James is really scummy but that he is the most scummy.

 

[TheGuy]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

I had forgotten about the Lemonnade vote, and agree that that vote really doesn't make much sense. But I don't see that kind of action as scummy. Scum would either avoid the spotlight or make strong claims, rather than through a weakly supported vote. Especially trying to deliberately get a power role lynched on such little evidence.

 

[Keeper of Night]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

I agree with the Astra vote, more so then I do voting James. Although I would still like to keep on eye on that one.

UNVOTE: James86134
VOTE: Astra

My vote until something changes my mind.

 

[PMJ]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

And now it's time for "pmj tries to make up for his one-liner posts now that he has a keyboard at his fingertips"!

If we don't want to lynch anyone, lynch Kecleon to test his abilities. A lynchproof should be lynched every day we have no leads to prove their claim.

This is a highly suspect post because not only did Kecleon-X survive the lynch, he survived a night kill as well. I'm pretty sure he's more than just lynchproof; I see no need to blow the lynch on something that probably isn't going to work anyway. I think Porygon-X used some of my roles from WW16; in particular, the Silent Protagonist ability (can't talk on day 1) and the 300 HP ability (deathproof until day 5). So we should wait until tomorrow, at the very earliest, to consider trying again.

Astra's claim that Kecleon-X is an alien probably stems from the fact that the actual Alien role is an indie, and when Haunted Water died, he had something that dealt with aliens in his role card.

That said, I agree that Astra's posts have been decidedly... empty. I'd like to hear more from him, sooooooo pressure vote go!

VOTE: Astra

 

[WanderingWolf]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

I feel like the logic with James is like, "he's suspected every game" "so there's probably a good reason to lynch him this time."

He's only played 1 more game and he's terribly scummy there and here too. You know you can be scum in 2 consecutive games (I was scum on my first 2 games).

I voted for him because he wanted to start a wagon for no reason at all. He could easily be starting a wagon.

@MDL All wolves could potentially get caught if they would push for the same wagon (specially if it is as bad at the one James started). I''m not saying that James is really scummy but that he is the most scummy.

I've played quite a few more game than just here... #justsaying



And why is everyone saying that I created a 'wagon'. It got no power, I had not planned it to be a wagon, instead, I was just trying to find a lead. I wasn't necessarily going 'KILL LEMONNADE, HES NEW, KILL HIM, HE BANDWAGONS, KILL, KILL, KILL'.

 

[Dork Void]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 3 Ends August 9th, 7PM EST!

VOTE: Kecleon-X

Lynch all indies.

Am I the only one who found this one of Astra's most suspicious posts? Not all indies are harmful to the town and Astra is experienced enough in Werewolf to know that. This strikes me as the epitome of bandwagoning to end the day.

 

[PMJ]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

In my experiences I have seen dangerous indies on pb more often than not. has anyone other than me even used the survivor role?

 

[Dork Void]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

In my experiences I have seen dangerous indies on PokéBeach more often than not. has anyone other than me even used the survivor role?

Porygon-X hasn't hosted anything on Pokebeach before, so that doesn't really tell us much. Just fyi, my game had at least 3 indies who either helped the town or didn't hurt it (but then again, my game had way more indies than usual).

 

[Glace]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

What did I miss at Worlds? From what I can tell, nothing at all >_>

 

[Flys Gone 2071]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

He's only played 1 more game and he's terribly scummy there and here too. You know you can be scum in 2 consecutive games (I was scum on my first 2 games).

I voted for him because he wanted to start a wagon for no reason at all. He could easily be starting a wagon.

@MDL All wolves could potentially get caught if they would push for the same wagon (specially if it is as bad at the one James started). I''m not saying that James is really scummy but that he is the most scummy.

I've played quite a few more game than just here... #justsaying



And why is everyone saying that I created a 'wagon'. It got no power, I had not planned it to be a wagon, instead, I was just trying to find a lead. I wasn't necessarily going 'KILL LEMONNADE, HES NEW, KILL HIM, HE BANDWAGONS, KILL, KILL, KILL'.

Of course I know you have played games outside of of here but if you could at least read the post I would be responding to, you could understand.

You were trying to see if you could start a wagon which wouldn't have a problem in starting because it wouldn't be very "suspicious".

 

[Hegafire]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

After looking over Astra's posts, I realize that she is being overly defensive.
Unvote: James86134
Vote: Astra

 

[rev3rsor]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

I know I seem ignorant but
I'm guessing Astra has a right to defend himself (though normally it wouldn't be so forceful). I'm not saying he's 100% town because I have no idea, but I'm just looking at the other side of the argument (the 'what if?') I don't want to seem like I'm jumping on his side all of a sudden, but I'm just that kind of guy who doesn't like being one-sided.

 

[Keeper of Night]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

I know I seem ignorant but
I'm guessing Astra has a right to defend himself (though normally it wouldn't be so forceful). I'm not saying he's 100% town because I have no idea, but I'm just looking at the other side of the argument (the 'what if?') I don't want to seem like I'm jumping on his side all of a sudden, but I'm just that kind of guy who doesn't like being one-sided.

I say we lynch Astra and if he turn out to be a wolf, we get this guy next.
Though you claim you're not "that kind of guy who doesn't like being one-sided," but you seem a bit too defensive and unwilling to vote against Astra.

 

[Dork Void]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

I say we lynch Astra and if he turn out to be a wolf, we get this guy next.
Though you claim you're not "that kind of guy who doesn't like being one-sided," but you seem a bit too defensive and unwilling to vote against Astra.

Yeah sorry, no. He's playing devil's advocate and that's perfectly fine; discussion is good. You're saying he's too defensive and unwilling to vote-he's made one short post on the subject!

inb4 they turn out to be wolves and you lynch me because of it

 

[Keeper of Night]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

I say we lynch Astra and if he turn out to be a wolf, we get this guy next.
Though you claim you're not "that kind of guy who doesn't like being one-sided," but you seem a bit too defensive and unwilling to vote against Astra.

Yeah sorry, no. He's playing devil's advocate and that's perfectly fine; discussion is good. You're saying he's too defensive and unwilling to vote-he's made one short post on the subject!

inb4 they turn out to be wolves and you lynch me because of it

I only said that if Astra flips wolf, we have reason enough to get James next. After all, aren't most of us pushing the Astra lynch because he was being too defensive in the first place?

 

[Glace]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

Yeah sorry, no. He's playing devil's advocate and that's perfectly fine; discussion is good. You're saying he's too defensive and unwilling to vote-he's made one short post on the subject!

inb4 they turn out to be wolves and you lynch me because of it

I only said that if Astra flips wolf, we have reason enough to get James next. After all, aren't most of us pushing the Astra lynch because he was being too defensive in the first place?

VOTE: Keeper of the Night

For lining up lynches

 

[Glace]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

VOTE: Keeper of Night


though I made it so much cooler.

 

[Keeper of Night]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

I only said that if Astra flips wolf, we have reason enough to get James next. After all, aren't most of us pushing the Astra lynch because he was being too defensive in the first place?

VOTE: Keeper of the Night

For lining up lynches

Excuse me, but by "lining up lynches" I am trying to put together a suspicions list.
As, as far back as I read, you're not exactly everyone's most clean candidate either.

I really hope I'm not the only one seeing a pattern here.

 

[Porygon-X]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

I'm going out tonight, and will not be here to end the day. I'll either have to end it really late tonight or tomorrow morning. This seems like a good thing though - you guys seem undecided.

Oh yeah, vote count:

Machamp the Champion = TheGuy
DNA = Astra
Astra = dounblenikesocks
Keeper of Night = Astra
Flys Gone 2071 = James
PMJ = Astra
Hegafire0 = Astra
Glace = Keeper of Night

Astra - 6
James - 1
TheGuy - 1
doublenikesocks - 1
Keeper of Night - 1

Hegafire0, I counted your vote because it was at the top of a page for me and I saw it. Normally I use ctrl+f for 'VOTE' to compile the votes and if someone votes and the word VOTE isn't in caps I won't see it.

Remember, 11 votes are needed for a lynch.

 

[Hegafire]

RE: Werewolf XVII: Universe - Day 4 Ends August 16th, 7PM EST!

Oh. Thanks for telling me. I thought it was capitalized.