Finished Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Game Over! A winner is PMJ and RogueChomp
- Thread starter Professor Palutena
- Start date
- Status
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
Teal being frozen is most likely a red herring, since sillykyle did it (see Camoclone - Day 2).
My guess is the wolves were roleblocked, or they're inactive. But of course, there's always the chance its a ploy to make us think they're inactive.
-----
So, Grant sent me this during the night, he also sent it to TheGuy:
I then forwarded it to the following people: Teal, sillykyle and SoldiersSpirit, with this message:
Grant sent TheGuy and I this message. I actually trust you guys, so I decided to share it with you first (I'm going to post it when Day starts as well).
This is extremely strange, since Camo said that he could confirm Grant as town... And Grant simply comes out saying that he wants town dead, and wants to team up with the wolves. As soon as Day starts, my vote is on him.
-----
Then, TheGuy sent me this message:
James, this message is only to you. I don't think that you're scum, and I'm not scum either so I think we should work together to find a course of action. I think we have two options, to pretend that we're scum and work with him or to turn him into the town on daybreak. What are you thinking? I'm interested in his special ability.
I replied with:
It could be a plot to try to bring out wolves. He acts as if he will help, and call apps out later. Grant is known for sacrificing himself to help the town. Its a ploy.
-----
Do what you will with this information, but I honestly think he's just bad townie.
Teal being frozen is most likely a red herring, since sillykyle did it (see Camoclone - Day 2).
My guess is the wolves were roleblocked, or they're inactive. But of course, there's always the chance its a ploy to make us think they're inactive.
-----
So, Grant sent me this during the night, he also sent it to TheGuy:
I then forwarded it to the following people: Teal, sillykyle and SoldiersSpirit, with this message:
Grant sent TheGuy and I this message. I actually trust you guys, so I decided to share it with you first (I'm going to post it when Day starts as well).
This is extremely strange, since Camo said that he could confirm Grant as town... And Grant simply comes out saying that he wants town dead, and wants to team up with the wolves. As soon as Day starts, my vote is on him.
-----
Then, TheGuy sent me this message:
James, this message is only to you. I don't think that you're scum, and I'm not scum either so I think we should work together to find a course of action. I think we have two options, to pretend that we're scum and work with him or to turn him into the town on daybreak. What are you thinking? I'm interested in his special ability.
I replied with:
It could be a plot to try to bring out wolves. He acts as if he will help, and call apps out later. Grant is known for sacrificing himself to help the town. Its a ploy.
-----
Do what you will with this information, but I honestly think he's just bad townie.
PMJ
Silhouette Gloom of the Sundown Lands
Forum Head
Articles Head
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
I would suggest that people not do this, as Eagle is only confirmed town today. Tomorrow he could be cult and, if you guys do what he says and gets converted, the cult will then have a list of all the power roles.Eagle4 said:
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
I also obtained a similar message from Grant.
Recipients: Astra, myself, Teal, Four Arms, Red Rain
Teal also sent me something, and only me (and Astra):
As for myself, I used my night action to target Four Arms and SoldiersSpirit.
My Four Arms attempt was redirected to PMJ. My SoldiersSpirit attempt was not redirected.
No one attempted to change either of their alignments.
I also obtained a similar message from Grant.
Recipients: Astra, myself, Teal, Four Arms, Red Rain
I did not respond to it.
Teal also sent me something, and only me (and Astra):
I didn't respond to him either.
As for myself, I used my night action to target Four Arms and SoldiersSpirit.
My Four Arms attempt was redirected to PMJ. My SoldiersSpirit attempt was not redirected.
No one attempted to change either of their alignments.
Or, even worse, the cult might have resurrected him.PMJ said:
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
PMJ, I can be safeguarded or targeted with DNA's ability with ease. The only thing I'm fearing is a mafia kill, as our BG has already died, so I'll need to act fast and in order to do so, I need the roles today.
PMJ, I can be safeguarded or targeted with DNA's ability with ease. The only thing I'm fearing is a mafia kill, as our BG has already died, so I'll need to act fast and in order to do so, I need the roles today.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
I'm pretty sure reporting OC convos here isn't against the rules as it's been done a few times before, so everything I've done so far is legit. The reason I targeted SoldiersSpirit last night was partly because I thought he'd be a good target, and partly as a gesture of good faith.
Assumption 2: That you aren't part of the cult right now.
I'm pretty sure reporting OC convos here isn't against the rules as it's been done a few times before, so everything I've done so far is legit. The reason I targeted SoldiersSpirit last night was partly because I thought he'd be a good target, and partly as a gesture of good faith.
Assumption 1: That I'll target you during the night.Eagle4 said:
Assumption 2: That you aren't part of the cult right now.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
1) I would be the strongest target for the cult if I get everybody's Role PMs
2) I'm not part of the cult right now as Sir Taco has already stated that he has resurrected me, and I have good faith that Sir Taco is not a cult. I was told specifically by Astra that I resume my role and faction.
1) I would be the strongest target for the cult if I get everybody's Role PMs
2) I'm not part of the cult right now as Sir Taco has already stated that he has resurrected me, and I have good faith that Sir Taco is not a cult. I was told specifically by Astra that I resume my role and faction.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
I'd like to say that I believe that Eagle4 was resurrected legitimately and not as a member of the cult or scum, because those items that were being passed around were Kid Icarus related, so that makes sense. I'd very much like to PM you my role Eagle, to prove my innocence, but I'm a bit hesitant to, because as DNA said, you could be converted unless he safeguards you every night. In fact, he might not even be able to safeguard you, if he himself was converted, because he hasn't safeguarded himself every night. He could then claim that his safeguard failed each time. I'm not saying that he's already been converted, but we have to be seriously open to that possibility.
But yeah, Eagle4, you should be seeing a PM from me coming your way soon, unless I have a huge change of heart. (Which won't happen, so don't worry
)
I'd like to say that I believe that Eagle4 was resurrected legitimately and not as a member of the cult or scum, because those items that were being passed around were Kid Icarus related, so that makes sense. I'd very much like to PM you my role Eagle, to prove my innocence, but I'm a bit hesitant to, because as DNA said, you could be converted unless he safeguards you every night. In fact, he might not even be able to safeguard you, if he himself was converted, because he hasn't safeguarded himself every night. He could then claim that his safeguard failed each time. I'm not saying that he's already been converted, but we have to be seriously open to that possibility.
But yeah, Eagle4, you should be seeing a PM from me coming your way soon, unless I have a huge change of heart. (Which won't happen, so don't worry
)RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
My point being that I'd be a bit reluctant to send Eagle4 my role, even at this point. And if I die or am somehow affected, then...well, that effort is all for nothing.
As for my role? You all know what it does; I've said it in the thread a few times.
My point being that I'd be a bit reluctant to send Eagle4 my role, even at this point. And if I die or am somehow affected, then...well, that effort is all for nothing.
As for my role? You all know what it does; I've said it in the thread a few times.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
Man, I feel left out with all the OC going on.
#foreveralone
Also it's probably nothing, but it is interesting that this is the first day without the rooster...
Man, I feel left out with all the OC going on.
#foreveralone
Also it's probably nothing, but it is interesting that this is the first day without the rooster...
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
If I don't get a copy of the PM, I will be suspicious of you breaking this rule.
Note. Directly copy/pasting of role PMs is against the rules. You must paraphrase.Eagle4 said:
If I don't get a copy of the PM, I will be suspicious of you breaking this rule.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
This won't work 'cause people could just give you either a C + P of Camoclone's role or outright farce roles. I could still send you mine; I see practically no repercussions in telling you, and I could definitely tell if you wish. Although, I think it has to be said that the chances of you surviving much longer are slim, because now you are a confirmed town, a prime target for wolves. Moreover, in an OC game like this one, you're now an even better target for the wolves because of you doing what you're doing now. Such as the case with bringing people back to life in WW, I'm afraid.
Eagle4 said:
This won't work 'cause people could just give you either a C + P of Camoclone's role or outright farce roles. I could still send you mine; I see practically no repercussions in telling you, and I could definitely tell if you wish. Although, I think it has to be said that the chances of you surviving much longer are slim, because now you are a confirmed town, a prime target for wolves. Moreover, in an OC game like this one, you're now an even better target for the wolves because of you doing what you're doing now. Such as the case with bringing people back to life in WW, I'm afraid.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
Sir Taco, how does Paulutena's Bow work exactly? Why go resurrecting the Item Trader when we have a Doctor, a Voyeur, and a Jack Of All Trades (yeah, it's an Indie, but it's still useful, as I've said many times) dead already?
I can confirm that Grant sent me that message and that Luckyfire took the hit for me, because I'm her Mason (fourth time being Masons -_______-). I'm pretty sure Grant's town, AKA what he said he was in DNA's PM. I mean, can you honestly tell me that Grant wouldn't do something like fake-claim survivor Indie to lure out scum?
I think it's a good idea for everyone to PM Eagle their roles. I just posted my role (yes, Mason and being protected by LF are my only powers), so obviously I'm not going to do it, but DNA can just "Alarm" him every night, and we'll never lose him. The scum don't want Eagle on the cult team, so they're not going to kill or redirect DNA, so the only way the cult can get Eagle is if they have killing or redirecting powers, which I wouldn't think they'd have, since it's already an overpowered concept anyways. If the scum have a way to get Eagle on their team, they'd probably have to kill DNA first, in which case we might have to just lynch Eagle before he's recruited. The scum also have no idea if people actually PM'd him roles, so they take the risk of killing one of their weapons against the cult.
Today I think our best course of action is to lynch TTwig, unless anyone has any better suggestions. After sillykyle's post yesterday, I think it's incredibly likely they're scum buddies. There's also the fact that, y'know, his posts are just generally scummy.
Sir Taco, how does Paulutena's Bow work exactly? Why go resurrecting the Item Trader when we have a Doctor, a Voyeur, and a Jack Of All Trades (yeah, it's an Indie, but it's still useful, as I've said many times) dead already?
I can confirm that Grant sent me that message and that Luckyfire took the hit for me, because I'm her Mason (fourth time being Masons -_______-). I'm pretty sure Grant's town, AKA what he said he was in DNA's PM. I mean, can you honestly tell me that Grant wouldn't do something like fake-claim survivor Indie to lure out scum?
I think it's a good idea for everyone to PM Eagle their roles. I just posted my role (yes, Mason and being protected by LF are my only powers), so obviously I'm not going to do it, but DNA can just "Alarm" him every night, and we'll never lose him. The scum don't want Eagle on the cult team, so they're not going to kill or redirect DNA, so the only way the cult can get Eagle is if they have killing or redirecting powers, which I wouldn't think they'd have, since it's already an overpowered concept anyways. If the scum have a way to get Eagle on their team, they'd probably have to kill DNA first, in which case we might have to just lynch Eagle before he's recruited. The scum also have no idea if people actually PM'd him roles, so they take the risk of killing one of their weapons against the cult.
Today I think our best course of action is to lynch TTwig, unless anyone has any better suggestions. After sillykyle's post yesterday, I think it's incredibly likely they're scum buddies. There's also the fact that, y'know, his posts are just generally scummy.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
Confirming that grant's message was sent to me, you can see my thoughts about it in the PM I sent to James afterwards. I used to think that he was telling the truth, but the fact that he sent to people he thought were town surprises me, and I'm beginning to agree that he's probably a dumb townie.
Also, the wolves were not roleblocked nor inactive (Or at least I assume the person that tried to kill me is the wolves considering there was no kill last night). They tried to kill me, however I had an item that saved me from death.
Confirming that grant's message was sent to me, you can see my thoughts about it in the PM I sent to James afterwards. I used to think that he was telling the truth, but the fact that he sent to people he thought were town surprises me, and I'm beginning to agree that he's probably a dumb townie.
Also, the wolves were not roleblocked nor inactive (Or at least I assume the person that tried to kill me is the wolves considering there was no kill last night). They tried to kill me, however I had an item that saved me from death.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
I have a better suggestion. You could, you know, not lynch me. That's always an option. I've sent my role to Eagle4, and although he hasn't responded yet, I'm willing to bet that he could vouch for my innocence.
Also, would you mind pointing out the post of sillykyle's that supposedly makes us look like scum buddies? I'd be interested in seeing that.
I have a better suggestion. You could, you know, not lynch me. That's always an option. I've sent my role to Eagle4, and although he hasn't responded yet, I'm willing to bet that he could vouch for my innocence.
Also, would you mind pointing out the post of sillykyle's that supposedly makes us look like scum buddies? I'd be interested in seeing that.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST
sillykyle, your role pm to me, please. I have already had a substantial amount of roles sent to me, making it easier to pick out the scum. You're one of the big suspects sillykyle, so it is very important for you to send your role to me.
Also, I can vouch for TwistedTurtwig's innocence (for now)
sillykyle, your role pm to me, please. I have already had a substantial amount of roles sent to me, making it easier to pick out the scum. You're one of the big suspects sillykyle, so it is very important for you to send your role to me.
Also, I can vouch for TwistedTurtwig's innocence (for now)
- Status