Finished Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Game Over! A winner is PMJ and RogueChomp

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

I can't believe you guys actually think that townies would act like this. I claimed everything on day 2, using the term kidnap the entire time, and suddenly when says this:

SoldiersSpirit said:
Kidnap QT lmao...and that sounds town to you guys?
Click to expand...

These people are like OMG HE CAN KIDNAP PEOPLE HE MUST BE A WOLF!!1!!1!!11ONE!!! It makes no sense. It's obviously a bunch of wolves and cultists using it as an excuse to bandwagon. Get your act together townies...
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

Hihi sorry for my absence, had school/mock interviews/volunteering at resource center/masterchef australia which all takes priority. Sadly, I don't really have the time atm as well haha and I'm seeing Chelsea vs Cardiff tomorrow and so I won't be on at deadline :/

So I'm gonna say can we choose TheGuy for the bandwagon? He's evaded most of the top discussion during the game and seems to pop up only to bandwagon with little reason other than "he's scummy". This along with his weak argument to not send me his role (his argument of "I might get targeted by the cult" has been answered many times in the thread before) makes me think he's scum. He can send his role in to me ASAP before this lynch gets turned around but otherwise I want him gone.

##INCRIMINATE THEGUY
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

So Eagle, do you have any other ideas on who's scum? You seemed real confident that you could find the scum after people PM'd you their roles, and you don't seem to have any leads other than TheGuy, who I have reasons to believe is not scum.

Sir Taco has come of as really scummy to me. I really don't like the fact that he revived Eagle (the Item Trader) when there were tons of other great powers that he could've revived. I also have a suspicion than Paulutena's Bow changes the alignment of the revived player to the same one of the player who revived them, and Sir Taco wanted the best player out of the dead ones as opposed to who had the best role. He's also just been acting scummy in general. At this point, I think sillykyle is most likely a wolf, but I think that Sir Taco is more likely to be a wolf. He's also been dodging my question since the day started.

##UNSTEAMROLL: sillykyle
##GAG: Sir Taco

Also, I finally understand what SS meant with the "Kidnap QT Imao" thing. I still think it was horribly worded.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

The guy and sur taco are town.
I'm Convo town to most of you please take my word I know
This from outside comm and analyzytion of posts.yeah I'm a newb w/e
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

^I'm not even gonna justify this post with a response as it makes literally no sense at all.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

grantm1999 said:
The guy and sur taco are town.
I'm Convo town to most of you please take my word I know
This from outside comm and analyzytion of posts.yeah I'm a newb w/e
Click to expand...

... Must not rip hair out at stupidity.

Please, explain your obviously thorough, and logic reasoning for TheGuy and Sir Taco being town. Considering most have differing opinions, please, shed some light on this confusing scenario.

You are no where near 'convo town'. The closest you have gotten is Camoclone saying you are, without reasoning. And even then, your stupidity forces you to send a message to several people saying you are 'Survivor' or 'Town Vig'. One of which was noted towards scum 'TheGuy and I'... And now TheGuy is town?

Oh! Oh. I get it now. Outside communication and 'analyzytion' of posts? It makes so much sense now. THE BEST REASON EVER! Communication and posts. Posts don't have to be linked to, or explained how they are scummy. Who cares? Let's take Grant's word for it AND STOP VOTING THEGUY AND SIR TACO. Instead, let's vote Grant:

##UNBLUEEN: Blui

##STUPIDIFY: GRANTM1999
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

sillykyle said:
Right... But it shouldn't be used as evidence that I'm scum. Because it's not.
Click to expand...

I'm not, I'm just saying it doesn't make you town.

Four Arms said:
Sir Taco has come of as really scummy to me. I really don't like the fact that he revived Eagle (the Item Trader) when there were tons of other great powers that he could've revived.
Click to expand...

Like:
An indie
camoclone, the man who accuses everyone
Sheninja, the other man that accuses everyone


I also have a suspicion than Paulutena's Bow changes the alignment of the revived player to the same one of the player who revived them, and Sir Taco wanted the best player out of the dead ones as opposed to who had the best role.
Click to expand...

You have the first part wrong, but the second part right.

He's also just been acting scummy in general. At this point, I think sillykyle is most likely a wolf, but I think that Sir Taco is more likely to be a wolf. He's also been dodging my question since the day started.
Click to expand...

What question? I'm sure I would be happy to answer a question if I saw it.


So, allow me to sum up your case against me.

-I chose to revive a good player over a PR
-you have a suspicion that an item that I used to give you back a valuable player might have changed his alignment (which you show no proof of)
-I've been acting "generally scummy". Again, you give no examples of why.
-that's it, really.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

Sir Taco said:
Four Arms said:
Sir Taco has come of as really scummy to me. I really don't like the fact that he revived Eagle (the Item Trader) when there were tons of other great powers that he could've revived.
Click to expand...

Like:
An indie
camoclone, the man who accuses everyone
Sheninja, the other man that accuses everyone
Click to expand...
Keeper of Night, the Doctor
Luckyfire, the person who protects me (not really useful)

Sir Taco said:
He's also just been acting scummy in general. At this point, I think sillykyle is most likely a wolf, but I think that Sir Taco is more likely to be a wolf. He's also been dodging my question since the day started.
Click to expand...

What question? I'm sure I would be happy to answer a question if I saw it.
Click to expand...

Four Arms said:
Sir Taco, how does Paulutena's Bow work exactly?
Click to expand...

Four Arms said:
Sir Taco, you still haven't tolled me how Paulutena's Bow works. Please tell me.
Click to expand...


Sir Taco said:
So, allow me to sum up your case against me.

-I chose to revive a good player over a PR
-you have a suspicion that an item that I used to give you back a valuable player might have changed his alignment (which you show no proof of)
-I've been acting "generally scummy". Again, you give no examples of why.
-that's it, really.
Click to expand...


Okay, I didn't explain why your posts are scummy, but I'll do it now. I looked through all your posts again, but I'm too lazy to quote them or give post numbers (just go to Sir Taco's post by clicking his number of posts under his avatar to see them yourself). I might do it tomorrow if I feel like it.

Anyway. Most of your posts have been targeting players who ended up being town. RogueChomp, Eagle, and Teal (not confirmed town, but I'm pretty sure at this point that he's town). You tried to protect SheNinja, but that's just 1. You also refuse to vote for TTwig. All the scummy players seem to lead back to TTwig. Hmmmmmmmmmm.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

To answer your question, I just had to go ##REVIVE: EAGLE4 via PM and BAM! Eagle4 is alive.

RogueChomp wasn't town, but whatever.

I get a big townread off of Teal now FYI. Defending Eagle against me was a big deal.

As for Eagle, let's look at it like this: you are a PR, and someone claims to have stolen rour role from you. You PM the mod and ask about it, and they tell you the PR was never stolen. Would you not make a case against them? And if I really wanted Eagle dead why the potato would I have revived him?
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

Oh, I forgot. Sillykyle, who does Teal think we should lynch?
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

So I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that sillykyle is definitely scum:

http://wiki.sc2mafia.com/index.php?title=Kidnapper

Found this after googling "mafia game kidnapper". That's just one of a few results. The one I linked is notable for saying that the kidnapper is the mafia version of the jailer...except it's probably true only on that site since neither EpicMafia nor MafiaScum use a role called kidnapper. That said, I could not find anything that even hinted at this role being anything but anti-town.

Vote sillykyle.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

Sir Taco said:
To answer your question, I just had to go ##REVIVE: EAGLE4 via PM and BAM! Eagle4 is alive.
Click to expand...

Just letting you know, that counts as a vote.

Sir Taco said:
As for Eagle, let's look at it like this: you are a PR, and someone claims to have stolen rour role from you. You PM the mod and ask about it, and they tell you the PR was never stolen. Would you not make a case against them?
Click to expand...

Okay, fair enough. Although this was most likely a mod error, there's a slight chance that you're lying about this whole thing.

Sir Taco said:
And if I really wanted Eagle dead why the potato would I have revived him?
Click to expand...

Because now you know 100% that he's town...?
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

Everyone's logic towards why others are scum or town or cult or bad or good or horrible or mean or selfish or nice of kind:

Posts. I won't link them, just do it yourself. It makes me look like I don't have a case, as you have to read all the posts to find something I may or may not be addressing, but w/e.

-----

If you have a reason for why someone is town/scum/cult/whatever, say it. Don't just go 'Look at their posts. Oh, and I might post an ISO or case on them.'

People who are supposedly scum:
Sillykyle
Red Rain
TwistedTurtwig
Sir Taco
Teal
TokyoToots
RaichuGirl
Eagle4
TheGuy

People who are supposedly town:
Eagle4
Grantm1999
DNA
Teal
TheGuy
Four Arms.

Don't you just love how scum takes up approximately half the players, only 4 days in? Yeah, the game isn't over, but 9 people are scum.

-----

I'd like the following questions answered:

Grantm1999, how are you confo-town. Camoclone said you were, but hasn't posted a reason. When I asked before, you still posted, not addressing it.

SoldiersSpirit, why were you so sure of Eagle4 being scum, even though he wasn't... And now that he is, you haven't seemed to be too active.

The few who think Teal is town, why? He didn't go after someone who was town. And? He could be scum and not go after him BECAUSE it was a lost cause, and wanted to take advantage of it.

People who think Silly is scum, JUST BECAUSE OF HIS ROLE: We had neighbours in a game where everyone can be neighbours. The most helpful person in the game, wasn't town. A completely new aspect to werewolf is introduced to Pokebeach, the cult.

And because kidnapper isn't a town role in other games, it must not be town now?
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

There is only one thing missing from that analysis james; you.

Sent from my PantechP8010 using Tapatalk
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

##EAT: SIR TACO


If he flips scum we kill Guy then grant.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

Red Rain said:
There is only one thing missing from that analysis james; you.

Sent from my PantechP8010 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Please, explain where I fit into that analysis. The only reasons that have put me near scum have been 'So suspicious, posts. Camoclone. Agreeing with twisted'.

I'm suspicious in every game, my posts are always stupid, Camoclone always thinks I am scum. And I was agreeing with Twisted because I agreed with him.

I obviously am not town to most of you people, but I don't consider myself scum. No one has actually posted any thorough reason as to why I am scum or town, so I didn't include myself.

I could have easily put DNA on the scum list because of the reasons against him Day 1, but I didn't, for the same reason.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 4 ends Saturday, October 19 at 12pm/Noon MST

James, have you not been reading anything thats been going on in this game? I honestly think you have and are grasping at straws to seem town now. No one has really brought you up but ive had a couple people in outside convos say you might br scum. I think you are with that weak post you just made. You're clearly out the loop about a lot of things.

James is scum. Lynch him when I flip...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top