Finished Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Game Over! A winner is PMJ and RogueChomp

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 8 ends Tuesday, November 18th at 12pm/Noon MST

RG fit the criteria I listed, so it wasn't trusting in you so much as agreeing that she could definitely be cult.\

Also I iso'd RG's posts and got nothing useful out of it.

All right, let's see here. There are ten of us left:


How many cultists are there? Assuming a successful recruitment six out of seven nights, that would mean there would be eight cultists, minus two means there would be six right now. That can't be true, though, because if it were then the cult would still win even if Blui was cult since they'd have five players to tie it right now and win it for them.

So what happened? The friggin mafia happened. The reason the game is still going is because on at least one occasion, the cult tried to recruit mafia - and I'd be willing to bet that it was Porygon-X. It all makes sense now. RG did in fact want both brothers on her team. She recruited Kecleon-X first. Maybe she thought he was the stronger player. He says hey let's recruit my brother, and so she goes to recruit him, but it fails because he's mafia. Neither of them can call him out on it because otherwise they would be instantly outed as cult.

I believe there is at least one more mafioso out there. If you claim to me I will not shoot you if you are who I think you are...

Now then, time to whittle this list down. sillykyle and I are immune to being cult today (not ever, in my case), so he is not currently in the cult. Which leaves

Mapleboy86
Kecleon-X
Red Rain
SoldiersSpirit
Teal
James86134
Chronus MSEA
Blui

The numbers don't add up. We should have been endgamed by now. We're in mylo, which means something if we screw up this lynch. Four cultists left?

kyle: You can be trusted today. I like the Kecleon-X lynch, though.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 8 ends Tuesday, November 18th at 12pm/Noon MST

PMJ said:
What I meant was that it is virtually impossible for anyone to formulate a solid argument as to why someone is cult or not. Anyone I claim is cult will just do the same thing everyone else did: why am I being suspected, how am I scum, I can't be cult because x, okay I'll claim and prove my role here it is, etc etc etc.

I could ISO RG's posts... doubt I'll find anything but I'll take a look.

My theory is obviously not foolproof because Porygon-X was not cult. However, RaichuGirl was cult, so I'm still willing to put some stock in it.
Click to expand...

Thank you for explaining. Now I feel much better, albeit the fact that that statement is true; it is impossible to defend against. And you are right, and I have stated this before, with that exact reasoning, my brother was lynched, and though he wasn't town, he still wasn't cult, the kind of required lynch at this point. But you are correct, it is impossible to defend against because it is of opinion and isn't based on any real, solid evidence.

Although, I am really finding the somewhat passive-aggressive sarcasm of James to be a bit annoying, especially since it is only accomplishing... Nothing. But either way,

PMJ said:
So what happened? The friggin mafia happened. The reason the game is still going is because on at least one occasion, the cult tried to recruit mafia - and I'd be willing to bet that it was Porygon-X. Seeing as he is literally the only Wolf we have ever come across, I find it easy to say that statement. It could be one of any of the Wolf ranks, not just my brother, so keep that in mind, as well. It all makes sense now. RG did in fact want both brothers on her team. She recruited Kecleon-X first. Maybe she thought he was the stronger player. I read as "Because he's the stronger player" and thought you were saying I was a good player. Then I read the rest of it. :( He says hey let's recruit my brother, and so she goes to recruit him, but it fails because he's mafia. Neither of them can call him out on it because otherwise they would be instantly outed as cult. All hypothetical opinions and no base in fact. It's like trying to explain the sound of thunder back in the early ages of man; no one has proof therefore almost everyone is wrong, and you sir, are trying to explain thunder with the logic of Thor.

Now then, time to whittle this list down. sillykyle and I are immune to being cult today (not ever, in my case I am pretty sure you're Alpha now, at this statement because of your immunity. Plus, there is the fact that there has ever only been one instance of a mutilated victim. Not exactly serial killer material, here, especially since the whole psychological gig of serial killers is because they commit their crimes in succession and in graphic ways, having many details about their crimes linked, not just the fact that someone died. I might be looking into the details a bit far, but no more than you are at the moment.), so he is not currently in the cult. Which leaves

Mapleboy86
Kecleon-X
Red Rain
SoldiersSpirit
Teal
James86134
Chronus MSEA
Blui

The numbers don't add up. We should have been endgamed by now. We're in mylo, which means something if we screw up this lynch. Four cultists left?

kyle: You can be trusted today. I like the Kecleon-X lynch, though.
Click to expand...
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 8 ends Tuesday, November 18th at 12pm/Noon MST

PMJ is not the alpha. With the cult this close to winning there's absolutely no way he would intentionally lead a lynch against someone he knew wasn't cult. Personally, I've still got my money on P-X being the only wolf just to screw with us even more.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 8 ends Tuesday, November 18th at 12pm/Noon MST

RG tried recruiting me n0. She isnt just hitting inactives, she wants good players. I've been a fool.

Thoughts on teal or maple for cult?
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 8 ends Tuesday, November 18th at 12pm/Noon MST

Been busy but lol silly, the OMGUS is great and I'm pretty sure you aren't cult and are mafia just putting that out there.

I reqlly don't think if one X is cult than both of them are honestly even though I found kecleon more likely to be cult. Im down with kecleon if need be but id avoid losing the game and think Red Rain is cult...
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 8 ends Tuesday, November 18th at 12pm/Noon MST

>Doesn't vote for me or even mention my name
>Calls me out for OMGUS
#logic
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 8 ends Tuesday, November 18th at 12pm/Noon MST

Red Rain: 3 (SoldiersSpirit, PMJ, Chronus MSEA, Mapleboy86)
PMJ: 0 (James86134)
SoldiersSpirit: 4 (sillykyle, Teal, James86134, Red Rain)
Kecleon-X: 1 (PMJ)

Presently, SoldiersSpirit will be the person lynched today unless: someone unvotes him, or a wagon of five or more people votes for someone else.

If I missed your vote, you missed the ##, and it was not counted.

Day ends in 12 hours.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 8 ends Tuesday, November 18th at 12pm/Noon MST

Uh okay then.

It was a quiet day for the town, although they did manage to decide who to kill today. They elected to kill SoldiersSpirit today. Kirby took him up to the gallows and tied the rope around his neck. Toad then pulled the rope so SoldiersSpirit couldn't touch any object with his feet, and he quickly died.

SoldiersSpirit was:

Dear SoldiersSpirit,

You are Gilgamesh, the Town Vanilla Cult Redirector

You're a legendary swordsman, at least as far as you care. You're a famous samurai who's looking for a sword for each of his eight arms.

Redirector: Once per night, ##REDIRECT: PLAYERA TO PLAYERB, causing that Player A's role effect to be redirected to Player B.

You win if: all threats to the town are eliminated the cult makes up 50% of the town.
Click to expand...

The town was really happy with this lynch, so they went to bed with smiles on their faces.

Night 8 ends on Thursday, November 21 at 12pm MST
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Night 8 ends Thursday, November 21th at 12pm/Noon MST

Just FYI, you guys all suck at doing night actions.

So once again have another shoddy update.

Town woke up. One of them saw Teal's body on their doorstep. Searched for a role PM. Found it.

Dear Teal,

You are Phoenix Wright, the Town Universal Backup Doctor Cult

Object all you want, you've been forced into a battle of the games. As a lawyer, you're a smart individual who can do what seems like anything. Yeah, you got put that ego in that suitcase of yours.

Your abilities are:
Backup: Once a game, you may ##BACKUP: DEAD PLAYER. You will discover that player was an old client of yours. Knowing everything of their every day life, you will inherit that player's role. You will not be allowed to use any effects of that role until the next night.
Doctor: Each night, you may ##PROTECT: PLAYER. You will send out a group of Pikmin to protect the player from death. However, the Pikmin cannot prevent any extra effects from happening to the player including: roleblocking and kidnapping.
Tailor: Each night, you may ##TAILOR: PLAYER and will cause anyone who inspects that player to be given the opposite result of what they should be given, including both cops, trackers and watchers..

You win if: all threats to the town are eliminated Members of the Cult make up at least 50% of the current living town at any moment.
Click to expand...

Town was happy. Saw Blui in a picture frame again, so he can't be voted for today. Town went to work.

Day 9 ends on Tuesday, November 26 at Noon MST

With 8 players alive, it takes 3 votes to deadline lynch and 5 to hammer.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 9 ends Tuesday, November 26th at 12pm/Noon MST

Hell yeah.

##destroy: kecleon-x

James, you're next.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 9 ends Tuesday, November 26th at 12pm/Noon MST

Aww he wasn't the recruiter... :(

That's 3 cult in a row though, now all we need to do is hit the damn recruiter.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 9 ends Tuesday, November 26th at 12pm/Noon MST

The recruiter might already recruit an extra member last night.. So pretty much if we go into a wrong wagon. we are doom
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 9 ends Tuesday, November 26th at 12pm/Noon MST

Kecleon, why didn't you vote yesterday?
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 9 ends Tuesday, November 26th at 12pm/Noon MST

Chronus MSEA said:
The recruiter might already recruit an extra member last night.. So pretty much if we go into a wrong wagon. we are doom
Click to expand...

e0b2cbf7_you-dont-say.jpeg
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 9 ends Tuesday, November 26th at 12pm/Noon MST

sillykyle said:
Chronus MSEA said:
The recruiter might already recruit an extra member last night.. So pretty much if we go into a wrong wagon. we are doom
Click to expand...

e0b2cbf7_you-dont-say.jpeg
Click to expand...

Pretty much I'm trying to fill my daily minimum of posting

but then again.. I'm going with my yesterday's vote. With no arguement what so ever since I want to know other's people trend based on my vote

##Argue : Red Rain
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 9 ends Tuesday, November 26th at 12pm/Noon MST

PMJ said:
Hell yeah.

##destroy: kecleon-x

James, you're next.
Click to expand...

> Thinks I'm town, and says so in a PM
> I comply to almost every wish, because they're helping town
> I Blocked Teal, just like asked last night
> Thinks I'm cult
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 9 ends Tuesday, November 26th at 12pm/Noon MST

^loljk

1. PMJ
4. eagle4 Mapleboy86
8. Kecleon-X
10. Red Rain
13. James86134
23. sillykyle
24. Shocker Dark Void Chronus MSEA
25. Blui

8 Players. 1 cult recruiter, 3 vanilla cult. We need to kill the recruiter. People we know aren't the recruiter are: PMJ (SK), myself (kidnapper), James (roleblocker), Mapleboy (died as town day 2/3 forget which), and Kecleon-X (double voter). These players are not confirmed non-cult (other than myself and PMJ). They are confirmed non-recruiter. This leaves Blui, Chronus and Red Rain. I don't think RR is recruiter because SS tried to get him lynched, so that leaves Blui and Chronus. Of the two, I think RG would have been more inclined to pick Blui than Shocker, and Shocker+his first replacement haven't seemed very interested in the game. Therefore I believe Blui is the recruiter. BUT, because he has been kidnapped, we can't lynch him today. Kecleon was confirmed to have a double vote earlier in the game, so if you don't mind Kecleon, I'd like you to vote for someone to prove you still have the double vote. If you refuse, you will be lynched. If he does still have the double vote, then we'll have to choose between RR, James, Chronus and Mapleboy to lynch. If this is the case then 3 of the 4 will be cult, so it won't be that hard to hit one of them.

tl;dr: Blui is recruiter, Kecleon needs to prove his double vote if he wants to stay unlynched, if he does have it then we'll lynch a different cult member.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top