From what I gather, this is probably the best course of action. Assume everybody is scum. Then wait until someone proves they are town. Therefore, all scum are eliminated due to their being unable to prove themselves otherwise.
Finished Werewolf XXVII: Revelation
- Thread starter PMJ
- Start date
- Status
From what I gather, this is probably the best course of action. Assume everybody is scum. Then wait until someone proves they are town. Therefore, all scum are eliminated due to their being unable to prove themselves otherwise.
I'm pretty sure that no one thinks the announcer is town because of the sole fact that they're an announcer. It's general knowledge that scum announcers are entirely possible; I even had one in my game. The fact that the announcer is most likely Thomas Martin, as they've claimed, is why people believe them to be town. In some games, flavor has absolutely no meaning and is just there to give the game some extra color, but in games like this, which have a clearly defined plot, flavor should not being ignored. Yes, flavor can't be used for clearing just any old player, but when you have a main character like Thomas Martin or Maxine Owens, who both literally can't be part of the mafia and are very clearly not the indie, there's no two ways about it. Insisting that flavor can't be used to clear roles like those isn't only terrible logic, it's also plain anti-town behavior. After all, the last thing that the scum team wants is more cleared town players. Isn't that right Athena?
Uh... no. If everyone sits back with the same mindset as you, then we'd just sit around assuming everyone is scum and ladida, no progression. So, I'm going to do something. Try on your mindset.
/me puts on mindset
/me looks at options
Ooooooh, hey! You're not a confirmed town === scum. ##unvote: Jeremy ##vote:blaineisthebest
This is hugely ineffective. It would involve randomly lynching people the whole game. It makes you just as good a lynch as anyone else, so there's no reason not to lynch you. You can't prove you're town, can you?
In this game you have to use deduction and reasoning to try and figure out who you think is town and who you think is mafia. This game involves a lot of thinking.
At this point in the game, who do you think is town or scum and why?
You sound like my literature teacher Celever.
At this point I think I know who the announcer is, but I'm not willing to lynch Athena, for now at least. She shouldn't be forgotten though.
Apart from scattered mind (@bbninjas I find his overall behavior suspicious, I don't have a specific slip or anything in my hands) there's the matter of JoshB/Mega Adi. There's a pretty good chance one of them is scum, and there's a bit of info we can get from lynching either. I don't want to press a case on such grounds though, so I'll stick to my vote for now.
Also, it seems some players forgot about the game.
At this point I think I know who the announcer is, but I'm not willing to lynch Athena, for now at least. She shouldn't be forgotten though.
Apart from scattered mind (@bbninjas I find his overall behavior suspicious, I don't have a specific slip or anything in my hands) there's the matter of JoshB/Mega Adi. There's a pretty good chance one of them is scum, and there's a bit of info we can get from lynching either. I don't want to press a case on such grounds though, so I'll stick to my vote for now.
Also, it seems some players forgot about the game.
Do you like your literature teacher? D:
I don't really understand the logic with Mega Adi and Josh. They were subbed out because they got banned, and they got banned because they were alts of each other thus the same person. They could just as easily be town as mafia and their getting subbed out is no indication of anything IMO.
Read their posts. Look at how one of them functions differently. JoshB was scum and Keeper of Night was subbed in for him.
But wait, if Mega Adi defended JoshB doesn't it mean that they are on the same side? Meaning they both scums or town?
He is an excellent lynch. Unfortunately Jeremy is better. There is no reason why we shouldn't be lynching Jeremy right now. Lets go guys. Hop hop.
No it means Josh wasn't under pressure but he wanted to know why I thought he was scum without looking scummy.
If you actually look back over Josh' posts you will see how scummy he was. Search for it.
I see. Well I did some quick searching in the first pages:
OK Wasn't Josh a new player? Am I missing something? I really thought he was new..
I'm always an excellent lynch to you, Camo. Works both ways.
He was. Which is why you are coming around. He was so certain.
Nothing else? Perfect.
What else do you want me to say? It's not as if you presented a case.
- Status