@Squirtle Squad
Well, since you yourself admit that the only reason you're seeing me as wolf is that I "gloated" over dead wolves (instead of "being pleasantly surprised about the events" as I had intended when I said that), I don't really know what to say, tbh. It's not like there's an ability or role result that someone has revealed that incriminates me, which is what a person-accused-scum would normally defend himself over. This is how I see the current accusation on me:
I posted something ---> TT claims that it's similar to posts he makes when HE is scum ---> Therefore I am scum by conclusion
And I'm like what??? ?
I'd understand my accusation if TT claims it's similar to posts that -I- make if -I- was scum. That's metagaming, and it's an actual term at Pokebeach's Werewolf dictionary.
But it's not... Unless... IS THIS PROOF UNIVERSALLY APPLICABLE?
That's why I'm repeatedly asking if that post is something that is applied to general player base to use to accuse them as wolf,. Because if it's just specific to particular players, like perhaps, TT, then I don't understand the logic of applying it to me and then accusing me on the same grounds.
Because that implies that every player has the same playstyle and way of thinking and posting.
And that's how and why you'd end up accusing someone with a proof that actually applies to a different person. (In this case, me and TT)
Which is ILLOGICAL.
That's what I think of all this.
... Well, I do have questions and suggestions posed to simsands and TT at my last post that draws on my "Ranger and manga knowledge" as you put it (thanks for the compliment), but I guess they aren't around or haven't seen it yet. I'll just re-post it if it seems like it got lost among the sea of comments.
@simsands If you're looking for a Dragon Pokemon, perhaps it is possible to be Mega Sceptile as Grass/Dragon?
@TwistedTurtwig There isn't really any character that comes to mind to be connected to Ralts besides Wally and Ralts-Gallade. ... Well, there's manga-version Brendan/Ruby who does actually have a Ralts/Kirlia, but Celever's calling him/himself Brendan, so maybe he's the game version and can't be it. Aside from the obvious Tate/Liza, your only character possibility for who could own a Ralts would be an original character Ranger. Analyzing your ability's wording from all angles, how sure are you that it implies there's another Ralts out there? Or could it be that the "stated" Ralts you say is in your ability actually refers to your own Ralts instead? (Is the wording really strange?)
Additional: Also, is it only the Ralts evo line? Or could it be any Psychic Pokemon? We've had Xatu claim, as well as possibly Tate/Liza or Steven't Metagross. You sure it's not them you're supposed to be looking for?
@scattered mind
Hmm, I've already explained myself about the latter, but the first one perhaps has to be something to do with PMJ.
And also the fact that I rarely, if ever, post stuff straightforwardly in WW (unless it's near the end of the game e.g. TheGuy's game and Athena's game). Call it scummily withholding info from town, but that's because I don't want to just immediately blurt out what I deduce and give wolves unnecessary information. I believe there's a proper time to reveal vital information.
Recall that Celever might have been the one pushing PMJ's lynch, but I've been pushing at PMJ as well about his hammering. Posts #427 and #592 if you want to be precise. But then that post of mine you quoted, is post#597, which you would observe is different in tone to the two previous ones. My statement directed at PMJ, is actually about me realizing and accepting his explanation that "hammering is not a scumtell." I very clearly backed off attacking him.
Why? Because I realized he might not be a wolf after all.
How? Because I did analyze and re-read back through the pages of comments and saw this post of PMJ's. Post #475:
Case on simsands: His last vote for Luis reeked of bandwagon. If you wanna look at a "please give me townie points" vote, Celever, that's a far better example than any hammer vote. The update also confirms him as not being Solana, Kate, Kellyn, Keith, or my character, so that drastically reduces the odds of him being aligned with the town - especially since we have two scum teams.
I wasn't sure if the slip was intentional or not, but I felt it significant, because Lunick, as a Ranger protagonist, would be logically town, just like the three Rangers from Shadows of Almia are.
And no, this realization "didn't come after the fact". That post is 475, the post quoted from me is 597, PMJ outright stated and claimed to be Lunick on 652. A logical order. And if I'd been around at the time, I would have switched and defended PMJ by re-quoting that post, as looking at the posts that followed, NO ONE realized that PMJ had all but stated his role name waaaay before he claimed. But he had claimed by the time I got back online. Votes around him disappeared (partly due to simsands) so I didn't feel the need to defend him anymore. Of course, to my utter shock, the votes returned and he got lynched in a quick span near the end of the Day when I wasn't around again.
So... Yeah, I did re-read back and analyze AND scumhunt,
@scattered mind. Scumhunting isn't always about pinpointing who actually is scum. It can also work by confirming who is town and using the process of elimination on the player list, right? It's just that I don't immediately blurt out my findings. I'm more of a subtle hinter on information about myself or ones I deduce. Even now on this post.
