Mitja said:From a technical viewpoint it really is redundant. But Snow Cloak, Snow Warning...and travelling areas where it clearly snows...it makes much less sense to have hail instead of snowfall for all those things.
They can as well just rename it to snowfall, if adding making them into 2 effects is really too much..
That's not really a major issue, and certainly not one worth making an entirely separate weather effect for. They could rename it, but then they'd have to explain the falling Hail.
Mitja said:And Sunny Day does what then?
It surely doesn't move the sun inside the cave either, so why would the opposite move have to control motions of celestial bodies instead of simply causing the effect..
I find it harder to imagine a casual shady Pokemon magically blocking out the sun, than magically darkening its surroundings..
Both are unrealistic (well you could use some sort of smoke now that I think about it, or summon dark clouds), except that Eclipse actually makes it sound legendary and epic, when its supposed to be just the opposite of Sunny Day.
Daylight =/= Sunny Day. You can battle during the daytime and it could still not be sunny, it'd be no weather at all. All Sunny Day does is strengthen sunlight. Likewise, nighttime would not affect the battle either, it'd still be no weather. Eclipse, on the other hand, would be the opposite of Sunny Day, you'd be weakening the sun by obstructing it.