Ariana literally didn't even have a name for the first 10 years she existed. She was not an important character in the slightest until HGSS came along and had to pretend like the bland executives with six lines of dialogue each were actual characters (still didn't work IMO tbh!).
Giovanni not actually appearing in the story of the Johto games made it less of a leap for them to fill in the backstory that he's Silver's father, but Silver is present during multiple schemes involving Ariana within the storyline and narratively it would be really dumb for nobody in the game to comment that he's fighting against his own mother. Plus, if Ariana was so close to Giovanni in the past, why is Archer the actual leader of Neo TR?
Like sure she COULD be Silver's mother since nothing is ever said about Silver's mother in any direction but there's also no actual implication towards that conclusion in the games, in the show, in the manga, etc whatsoever beyond the two having red hair. By that logic Lorelei could be Silver's mother. Or a werewolf, since that's never deconfirmed either.
Giovanni not actually appearing in the story of the Johto games made it less of a leap for them to fill in the backstory that he's Silver's father, but Silver is present during multiple schemes involving Ariana within the storyline and narratively it would be really dumb for nobody in the game to comment that he's fighting against his own mother. Plus, if Ariana was so close to Giovanni in the past, why is Archer the actual leader of Neo TR?
Like sure she COULD be Silver's mother since nothing is ever said about Silver's mother in any direction but there's also no actual implication towards that conclusion in the games, in the show, in the manga, etc whatsoever beyond the two having red hair. By that logic Lorelei could be Silver's mother. Or a werewolf, since that's never deconfirmed either.
Last edited: