Chello said:Castelvania is AWFUL. Awful, awful, awful. It got awful reviews, the demo was awful, and the 3D looked like a 5 year old did it. Not worth the money.
Forgive me as I go semi-fanboy:
I can't defend the game much because I haven't played it, but yes, the demo was awful because it was the E3 demo. Nothing had been changed; it doesn't really give a good idea of the game. But if you're immediately put off by the combat, then yeah, you won't enjoy the main game (these are basically the words of Nintendo World Report's reviewer).
3D, no idea, no comment.
Reviews: It got bad reviews from some outlets because they were expecting Symphony of the Night/the GBA/DS games, and they got something different, something more like a sidescrolling Lords of Shadow without too many elements of exploration (also basically his words). Read multiple reviews, get a good idea of the game.
Now, I have no intention of ever buying it, just because it isn't really my thing, but when something's going down in a Metroid: Other M fashion, I feel there should be more than just "awful" strewn all about. A good number of people might be missing out on something they might like.