Finished Duck Hunt - Cancelled

Status
Not open for further replies.
The reality is that we won't figure the Dogs out Day 1. This seems like an intelligent group, and I don't think the Dogs would risk giving themselves away Day 1.

##UNQUACK: Ninja Penguin
##QUACK: rainyman123

I believe that he's not a dog. But he has to go if he's going to work against us.
 
There's only one person left who hasn't posted
##UNQUACK: TheDivingSeel
##QUACK: MyLittleKeldeo
 
Does anyone have actual evidence against bb? Right now, he's 2nd place in the votes (if I am counting correctly.)
 
rainyman123 said:
yes your right I totally understand and seeing as how this has been of excess, I'd assume everyone else who logged in within the next hour and read everything mypight assume that either @NinjaPenguin or myself are mafia, as we have had the biggest discussion thus far. You have a small chance of me actually being the dog, and other than me saying that I like the dogs and that they are cool and that I wanna lynch tpsome townspeople, you have no reason to lynch me. Just I have no reason to lynch Mora or bbninjas. This is the first round, we don't know much yet, so this is all guessing. However one of the traits of mafia is to watch it all and make it go your way and make everyone believe you, which as I stated above, would make people think that either you or me are mafia. With all that said, would the Mafia ever do this? (Nothing in the rules I've seen says I can't)
##Unquack: bbninjas
##Quack: rainyman123
Click to expand...
Well, if you really want to lynch yourself I won't stop you.
##UNQUACK: lord o da rings
##QUACK: rainyman123
 
Guys, mafia would never vote hisself. So this would mean I'm obvious town. You could eliminate me and them get 2 more elimainated next night, or you could be a bit smarter and use a small chance to at least kill 1 mafia.
##Unquack: Mora
##Quack: bbninjas
 
rainyman123 said:
Guys, mafia would never vote hisself. So this would mean I'm obvious town. You could eliminate me and them get 2 more elimainated next night, or you could be a bit smarter and use a small chance to at least kill 1 mafia.
##Unquack: Mora
##Quack: bbninjas
Click to expand...
meaning there's absolutely no reason to vote me, except if I'm mafia. It could all be a very elaborate scheme, but in both online and real life, I haven't been Mafia for the past 9 collective games.
 
rainyman123 said:
Guys, mafia would never vote hisself. So this would mean I'm obvious town. You could eliminate me and them get 2 more elimainated next night, or you could be a bit smarter and use a small chance to at least kill 1 mafia.
##Unquack: Mora
##Quack: bbninjas
Click to expand...
There is so much wrong with this reasoning...

Mafia members will sometimes vote for themselves if they're about to get lynched in an attempt to cut discussion early.

You know what fits this right now? What you're trying to do now.

I'm really sorry if I sound rude in this post; I don't mean to be attacking anyone or making others feel bad.
 
PikaMasterJesi said:
There is so much wrong with this reasoning...

Mafia members will sometimes vote for themselves if they're about to get lynched in an attempt to cut discussion early.

You know what fits this right now? What you're trying to do now.

I'm really sorry if I sound rude in this post; I don't mean to be attacking anyone or making others feel bad.
Click to expand...
nup not offended :D but I voted for me self BEFORE people started voting me. (popularity come to me :p)
 
rainyman123 said:
Guys, mafia would never vote hisself. So this would mean I'm obvious town. You could eliminate me and them get 2 more elimainated next night, or you could be a bit smarter and use a small chance to at least kill 1 mafia.
##Unquack: Mora
##Quack: bbninjas
Click to expand...
For reference, this is a textbook example of WIFOM.

##Unquack: TDS because he had a random bw on him which makes no sense.
 
Just over 8 hours remain. I will likely be late with the update so feel free to post until I get back. The day will continue until I post "Game Freeze".

Right now, rainyman and bbninjas will be lynched today.
 
NinjaPenguin said:
It's not scummy to change your RVS target when they respond to your post.
I think the best option right now is to try to lynch some inactives, since they won't help us at all.
Click to expand...
Oh, fair enough. xD ##UNQUACK: NP

[
rainyman123 said:
Hope dogs win!
Click to expand...
(Which is also why I'm voting Mora and bbninjas.) <<Not dogs :D
Click to expand...
rainyman123 said:
With all that said, even though I think NinjaPenguin is the Mafia, I won't vote for him. (As I stated in previous posts)
Click to expand...

Yup, anti-town behaviour. ##QUACK: rainyman123

rainyman123 said:
Guys, mafia would never vote hisself. So this would mean I'm obvious town. You could eliminate me and them get 2 more elimainated next night, or you could be a bit smarter and use a small chance to at least kill 1 mafia.
##Unquack: Mora
##Quack: bbninjas
Click to expand...
You've basically been saying "No, I'm town, because I've done stuff that scum wouldn't ever do," which Celever pointed being a big problem. It's basically a loop: "I'm town because I've done stuff that scum wouldn't ever do, but because I know that scum wouldn't ever do that, I'll do that because I'm scum so I look like town."

Professor Palutena said:
Right now, rainyman and bbninjas will be lynched today.
Click to expand...
Noooo don't lynch me! D:

I think the best votes have already been mentioned: rainyman (obviously) and MLK, because they are inactive (haven't posted anything yet). My votes are on those two~
 
##UNQUACK: double o squirtle
##QUACK: MyLittleKeldeo

If the day ends in majority, do we lynch the two with the highest vote counts? Unless I have miscounted, Rainyman123 is one vote from majority and that would mean losing bbninjas as well. Only unsure since it isn't explicitly stated in the first post, but it does say multiple die each phase so I assume it does work that way.
 
Vracken said:
##UNQUACK: double o squirtle
##QUACK: MyLittleKeldeo

If the day ends in majority, do we lynch the two with the highest vote counts? Unless I have miscounted, Rainyman123 is one vote from majority and that would mean losing bbninjas as well. Only unsure since it isn't explicitly stated in the first post, but it does say multiple die each phase so I assume it does work that way.
Click to expand...
According to the OP, the number of players lynched is equal to the number of dogs alive, and by doing a bit of maths (20/10) that is equal to 2.

Vracken said:
oh, of course you become active as soon as I vote for you >.>
Click to expand...
The problem is that they've popped in just to vote two strong players when Day 1 is nearly over. Which, uh, doesn't make any sense. >.>
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top