Nope, actually Japanese players get worlds invites through these carnivals. And it actually means that aside from a few exceptions, that carnivals give us a good idea of what's to come.Dark Void said:Riskbreakers said:Way to underestimate the Japanese bro.
According to data from Top Cut, FluffyChomp also won an American Cities, so what's your point, DarkVoid?
That Battle Carnivals mean no more than a single American Cities, which is very, very little.
pokemonjoe said:While there have been Japanese decks that have fallen flat on their face in the U.S., the number of Japanese decks that have actually done well far outweighs that.
Sure, but it means that doing well in a Battle Carnival does not mean its all that good a deck.
The reason why I think Tornadus/Landorus/PHB will do so well is not because it won a battle carnival, that's just another reason why I think it's good. It has a huge amount of early game pressure and PHB solves the damage cap problem. Also, you keep bringing up Garchomp/Altaria, but that's one example. Most of the other decks that won end up doing well in the rest of the world also.Dark Void said:They're a hint of what's to come because the Japanese are playing in the Battle Carnival before anyone else has that format. Therefore, the rest of the world interprets the Battle Carnival's results as the new meta and begins playing the decks seen there; that's how Garchomp Altaria became popular and how anyone ever thought it was good in the first place. However, as the rest of the world begins to actually test the meta for themselves they may find the Japanese completely off, but it will take them some time. Therefore while the Battle Carnival may sometimes be an accurate meta prediction, its also often just a self-fulfilling prophecy.
My point is that because the Japanese meta is a totally different environment from the rest of the world's playing field, the Battle Carnival may or may not accurately represent the rest of the world's meta once it catches up. This is what makes doing well in a Battle Carnival not mean very much as to the viability to the rest of the world. Garchomp Altaria is simply a recent example of this.
Flygon2071 said:Does anyone think that a Flygon + Hypnotic Laser could be a good combo?
Idea: Run mono-Flygon with no energies using Virbank and Hypnotic Laser. That is 40 damage to the active and 10 to the bench in between turns. The only problem is that you could only use Hypnotic Laser 4 times. I think that maybe Sableye but that would ruin having Flygon active.