I don't think it needs to be an uncommon to be "fair". With the amount of new product that gets open these days, staples don't all need to be uncommons imo. This could be a $10 until another print comes out. What is the most expensive T/S/S staple (lowest rarity) these days? $2?
You think a holo staple Supporter sounds "fair" when, if you bought one booster box for around $90,
maybe you'll get one--two at most if you get a reverse holo--but you can also completely miss and get none at all? (You only tend to get 6 holos in a booster box, and I bet you there's more than 6 holos in the upcoming set, which lowers your chances of pulling a specific holo.) You think $10 a card is a "fair" alternative for a staple Supporter if you don't pull many--or any--from your booster box or loose packs?
I'm well aware that certain Trainer cards can become very expensive for just being uncommon. But the difference between that and a making this a holo Supporter is the forced rarity. You're far more likely to pull it as an uncommon than you are as a holo. Would you rather pay $40 just for a playset of this? Or would you rather pay $90 and get a playset
on top of all of the other Trainers and ultra rares that you'll get in a booster box or even just from loose packs? The latter sounds more "fair" to me.
Disclaimer: This is my (cynical) view as more of a collector than a player about this hypothetical situation. I'm sure those who are strictly focused on the TCG at the highest level could argue that $40 for the 4 Supporters is a necessary evil if they need them for their deck. It's a different mindset. I just don't agree with it. All I'm saying is that one outcome sounds far more appealing than the other, and it would be greatly appreciated if this was made as an uncommon--not just by me, but for anyone who plays
and has a budget. If there's one thing that gets under my skin about the TCG now, it is TPCi's pull rates and their handling of rarities, especially in the Sun & Moon sets. (Which I suppose is two things, but they kind of go hand in hand.) But I'll stop my rant there before it actually starts.
TPCi
has been fair to us in the past, though, in terms of taking things that were rare in Japan and making them more common elsewhere. Though this might not be the best comparison (both in playability and rarity), but the best example I can think of is Espeon Prime, Umbreon Prime, and Raichu Prime being in Undaunted. In Japan, they were all extremely rare Promo cards (I forget how they were obtained; possibly had to do with tournaments) and they tended to be listed for hundreds of dollars. (Though, I can't speak for whether or not they sold.) But TPCi decided to put them in Undaunted, same pull rate as any other Prime, and they were super cheap because they were so common.
That was very much appreciated.
Useless tirade that no one cares about over.