scattered mind said:
Leaf_Ranger said:
You're right when you say that they represent RPG's classes, but I think they're way too different from the middle stages (namely Quilladin and Braizen). These last were already different from the initial stages (Chespin got fatter, Fennekin became bipedal and got some black "pants"). In my opinion the final stages look like they have nothing to do with their evolution family and I don't like it .
Many people counter that problem with old Pokemon like Dragonite line. How do you think those evolution lines are different from him or othrrs like Salamance ?
I disliked Dragonite when compared to its family. Like some people, I too was hoping for a graceful and blueish evolution and was disappointed by what came out. Still, I don't think that there's that much comparison between Chespin's lines and that of Dragonite. In this case, only the third stage stood out as weird or unexpected; with the former, all stages were unexpected: Quilladin shares the color scheme but got fatter and his face expression changed, I would say, a lot; if that wasn't enough, Chesnaught only has a few traces of its previous evolutions' colors and its face doesn't resemble Chespin's nor Quilladin and all of a sudden gets wrapped around bandages and gets some shell that take us back almost immediatelly to Torterra. Of all of Kalos starters, I would say that Chespin's line is the one that suffered the most number of changes with each evolution. Fennekin's is next and Froakie is the only that stays more or less the same.
About Salamence, it was a surprise to see Bagon evolve into some kind of cocoon Pokémon but after that it was almost certain that something unexpected could come out of it since, like I've said, it's some kind of coccon. There's indeed some changes with every stage but the color scheme remain almost the same except for Shelgon with that amount of gray. Even so, color scheme aside, Salamence still got something that connected it to its previous evolutions, namely the three stripes on its belly that were formely in Bagon's head and had grown in number and covered Shelgon; Slamence also kept that somewhat defiant look on its face like Bagon.
I Like Pie said:
Leaf_Ranger said:
You're right when you say that they represent RPG's classes, but I think they're way too different from the middle stages (namely Quilladin and Braizen). These last were already different from the initial stages (Chespin got fatter, Fennekin became bipedal and got some black "pants"). In my opinion the final stages look like they have nothing to do with their evolution family and I don't like it .
Delphox reminds me of the original artwork of Lenora and looks like it can get pregnant or that its hidin something mean under that "dress"...after this, I think it would be better if Fennekin remained on four legs. Having apparently lost its stick is also a shock. Being the setting in a France inspired region, I was hoping for a more elegant and refined witch theme.
Chesnaught...oh Chesnaught...Breloom was a good example of a Fighting-type Pokémon without the usual clichés and seeing Chesnaught with a body covered or resembling bandages (to me they remind me more of mummies than fighting wrist/knuckles bandages) is heart-breaking. Its face is ok, seems like some wise dude with the beard and being bald...I admit that it's somewhat good to see the scheme color being different than that of the evolution family because there was little change in that up until now (Meganium changed but not this much) but...It's growing on me but it's still the least favourite of the Grass-starters' final evolution and it will remain at the bottom of my list for a VERY long time. Maybe after seeing it in the anime it will change its position on my list.
I also think that Delphox should have been quadrupled. But then again, people would start complaining that it looks like Ninetales and what not. Game Freak tried out something different, and it didn't really work out too bad.
Chesnaught has an amazing design. I don't get the idea behind the Chespin line myself, but I am guessing Quilladin's body is round to represent enhances defenses, or maybe even a shield, which wouldn't be surprising considering its 'Warrior' theme.
Breloom represents a boxer, as far as I know. Its design is a faster counterpart to the tankish Chesnaught.
Like I've said somewhere before, Fennekin's line was always between two clichés: resembling Ninetales and being another bipedal fire-starter. In my opinion, Gf went wrong and ended up filling the two clichés because of two reasons: number one - the first cliché wasn't even a cliché because of a past "experience" that went great (I think so but you may disagree): Zorua. Zorua was in the same position as Fennkin by being somewhat akin to Vulpix and yet it ended up as something that stood out. Why? Because of its colors. Like Zorua, Fennekin's line could have a different color scheme that would turn it into something very different. Number two - Delphox, Braixen and Fennekin already resemble Ninetales, mostly because of their colors and namely Fennekin, that could be included as some stage in Ninetales' line. Delphox even resembles some sort of Ninetales' Mega-evo.
In the end, by not being bipedal, Fennekin's line would've ended the second cliché and by having some different and broader color scheme it would've stand out from Ninetales, both in locomotion and its current looks that, like aforementioned, as it is now already has some links to Ninetales.
Schezo92 said:
I dunno, I think some of the previous starters have pretty different looks from their second stage as well, I'll give you Quilladin -> Chesnaught might be one of their bigger changes (still not bigger than otter -> Sea lion, GF wat) But most of the starters I feel do actually feel pretty different from each form.
I didn't really look into pokemon reveals in the past but it might be because of how they were revealed this time around that people are feeling this way. I mean, Blastoise gets Cannons out of nowhere and get's pretty hefty. I still don't like Grovyle -> Sceptile, I got used to it. Also for whatever reason Croconaw get's some caveman cloth pattern on it, which disappears on Feraligatr, still don't understand why they added that for one form.
In those examples that you've mentioned, the one that stands out of its line is only one of the stages. Both Croconaw, Wartortle and Grovyle are Pokémon that while resembling both the previous and next evolutions, still have some aspects that make them look like strangers. Croconaw has the caveman pattern, Grovyle's arms' leaves and claws don't match the number we see in Treecko and Sceptile and, not only that, it grows a long hair out of nowhere and Wartortles looks some old wise turtle.
Samurott is also different but this is a third stage Pokémon. I've read before that sometimes the designers don't create the entire evolution line and that might be the case with Grovyle, Wartortle and Croconaw. When it comes to Samurott, I don't think that was the case and, like Masuda (I think) said, they didn't knew how to come up with the third stage for Oshawott and so they created Samurott after a trip to some zoo and seeing a sea lion.