This is pointless, except that it showed that the pressure went to your head. I did see your post, but decided to reply tomorrow. I'm allowed to reply when I see fit, it's that simple.
Yet you still haven't responded to it, remarkably:
Robin said:
Filling in my answers now? This is just rude.
Police: Did you murder this guy?
Murderer: You don't know me you have no idea whether I murdered him or not!
Police: So, yes? If you were a murderer you would just deny it.
Murderer: Wow how rude how could you think that me not denying a clearly incriminating question means that the answer might be true?
Robin said:
It's not a clear yes or no. My character was in direct service of Pompey. That is reason enough for me to doubt that Jabber's role name confirms that he is scum.
I'd like to refer you back to my original refutation of this argument that you still haven't properly acknowledged because it totally destroys your argument but you want to stand by it because your scumbud Jabs would be in the firing line otherwise:
Celever said:
There's a difference between aiding in a military sense and aiding in a political one. Military duties are exactly that: duties; these don't show a particular alignment or affiliation. Political assistance is, on the other hand, a way of enforcing your own ideals. And that's what Jabs' character historically did.
If he was in direct service of Pompey, he was assisting him out of duty. So it's not the same thing as Jabs' character
at all. Unless your character autonomously decided to assist Pompey's political career over your character's entire life, in which case maybe. But you've established that they haven't at this point.
Robin said:
Besides the fact that you won't tell how you got his role name. Especially since you don't claim to be a clear seer.
See above post: it was pretty bloody heavily implied, in the first place.
Robin said:
Also Jabber would be responsible for eliminating half of his team before the start of day 4. Nice going there.
So his plan to get town cred has worked, in short? Nice going there, getting manipulated. Lele was always gonna get lynched so voting for him is not alignment indicative, and in terms of bb vs PMJ, bb was already a publicly acknowledge solid lynch target before PMJ even made a post, and so offing him for town cred is the kind of power play that the scum team had to make.
Robin said:
I'd like to point out role fishing here. Celever might be aiming for me to get the penalty for claiming. Whatever that may be.
Oh God I sincerely hope you're a reaching mafian because if, as town, you genuinely believe this I'm a little concerned. I was asking you ambiguously about your character's historical intentions. There is no way that that would trigger a claiming penalty because, assuming you wouldn't go into a randomly great amount of detail that no one asked you for, we wouldn't be able to figure out who your character is (or even make a 20-strong shortlist).
Robin said:
Again, this is all you're going to bother with?
It's not a case of "bothering". If I were to ask you for an in-depth read about the TEAMAQUA#HEYNICK guy, would you be able to give me an in-depth read? No. Same case for mord and Drac so far: they've barely posted.
Robin said:
The main reason why it doesn't make sense is because PMJ was very close to being lynched himself. If it really was scums intention to lynch their member BBninjas, another member could've easily put another vote on him and even win town credits for it. But as you can see any of the inactives could've swayed the end result. Scum wouldn't let fate decide their supposedly well crafted plan.
Of course they would: it's scum vs scum. It didn't matter whether bb or PMJ was the one who died because they're both the same alignment, and so whoever survives claims the town cred. PMJ being close to being lynched himself was frankly ideal.
Robin said:
Another reason would be that scum vs scum is just an incredibly stupid play this early in the game. They could've easily lycnhed another town before attempting this. Neither PMJ or BBninjas were set lynch candidates before their confrontation. Did they panick after losing just Tapu Lele? I don't think so.
I've said before that this is not the case. bbninjas was a publicly acknowledged strong lynch target literally by the end of Day 1, and support for his lynch increased even more over the course of Day 2 before PMJ came out and made his horrid case on the guy. He wouldn't have survived beyond the end of this day anyway, most likely, looking at how momentum for his case had been building. And so losing Lele as well meant the mafia would have been 2 members down quickly and, considering the inevitability of modkills due to inactives, that's a dangerous position to be in. So actually yes, they needed a power play.
Robin said:
The one that is panicking is Celever
I'm not panicking: I'm phenomenally frustrated. Like, because of this game there's no chance I'm playing another game on this site unless the hosts are friends who convince me to, because at this point this game is composed of inactives, people who aren't really trying / might as well not, PMJ, and Jabs. I only like playing with one of those. It's also meant that I'm not designing the next game like I was originally planning to, because it would bum me out to put work into a game that will inevitably flop due to the players within it; I can't imagine how NP and Vracken are feeling because a lot of work has gone into this game and the quality of this gamethread is shocking.