I do believe Camo is scummy, but I understand the point of view that says he can use lies and manipulations as town. Still I think all he did was identifying my eagerness to question and to get into more details, and turn it to show me as scum in pretty much any scumtell he could come up with. I am willing to admit that I was jumpy- not aggressive, but simply fast reacting to every situation. Again, I have played this way many times as town. The only thing that was out of my usual character was the reaction to bbninjas, but it simply came out wrong- it wasn’t me thinking bbninjas tried to threat me to not talking, but to get him to explain himself and not say vague statements like “We got some info on you”- From my point of view, what I did was to not defend myself, but rather get him to post his thoughts to make a read. In an attempt to make a read on a post that involves you, you get the risk of coming off as defensive, and I totally ignored that and even added more woods to the fire with the way I said it. From a general point of view I can see how others may get that as me being aggressive in an abnormal way, so I am now less surprised by the situation.
Also someone said something that I have not noticed about how Camo’s D1 play style is different than the rest of the game. Now that I think about it I can relate to that idea, which obviously makes Camo less valid for a lynch on D1- because if that’s true: Camo’s D1 play is to lynch someone without considering defense, just to lynch as fast as possible with as much scumtells, true or made up. Very similar to a play style of getting out from the RVS asap, only with D1. Would be interesting to hear it from him in the post game (now it’s kinda problematic because we are playing).
I am waiting for Luispipe8 and PMJ to comment on everything like they promised.
GP is a nice option on the surface. Like last game with Nick and Jplap: players who mindlessly bandwagon very late are usually very scummy to me, especially if they are new. But as last game showed, it can happen with townies. Nick was scum and Jplap was town. So this might need more looking into.
TE is still playing very careful. I would like to see him more involving. He is trying to carefully approach the situation with very surface level questions, that imply also his line of thought, but not explicitly.
NP has improved with giving more input, and so he is neutral for me now.
I’ll reread to gain more thoughts later.