Finished Mafia XL: Age of Piracy: Game Over!
- Thread starter Jabberwock
- Start date
- Status
Lynching Keeper is becoming a dead end. Lord has ties to Keeper and is very scummy herself.
##VOTE: lord o da rings
##VOTE: lord o da rings
I was admittedly hoping Camo would have been dead by now or something. That's a shame! :U
FTR, I kept up with this game for about the first... 3 pages? Any good folks out there wanna fill a poor sub in? <3
I'm terrible at giving sub summaries, since it always includes my personal opinions. The game is only 29 pages (with lots of short fluff posts and Camo posts), so I'd suggest you read it for yourself.
I'll try and find time to read up but I'm revising for finals right now too. It's still useful to see your summary even if it has personal opinions, especially if multiple people make them; lets the people who have been in the game for longer decipher headspace, and lets me look at A) points of contention and B) points of agreement.
Here's what stands out to me:
Day 1-
RVS goes pretty badly, with people voting without real reasons
We realize we've stalled for too long and have to find a lynch option
morda says something about wanting a port near the East India Company
LC is very inactive, and has scummy posts when pressured
morda claims something that we think looks like an indie
Morda gets lynched, flipping town
Day 2-
Scattered survives the N1 kill
The port for Day 1 causes our items to go to random targets, causing me to accidentally pass the anti-town Wooden Eyeball to LC, which causes me to want to lynch him even more, to get rid of it.
Almost nobody puts up an resistance or alternative ideas, including LC, who ignores every post made against him.
LC gets lynched, flipping town
Night 2-
The port for Day 2 allows us to talk on Night 2.
The conversation is basically inconsequential
Day 3-
We start pushing some fairly bad lynch options, such as RF, Rainy, and jade. Lord is gaining momentum when
Camo subs in, and declares Keeper and lord to be the best lynch options, with Keeper as the best
Keeper and lord both have a large chance of getting lynched, but it is Keeper who is lynched in the end.
Keeper survives the lynch.
Day 4-
We discuss whether or not we should try to lynch Keeper again.
Keeper claims to have survived the Night 3 kill and also claims to have had his item stolen.
Scattered counter-claims.
I push for lord instead of Keeper, but then a combination of scattered, Drac, Lord, and Jade proves Keeper was lying.
Part of the proof is that Keeper strangely passed a good item to lord, who he said he thought was scum.
We lynch Keeper again, but he again survives the lynch.
Day 1-
RVS goes pretty badly, with people voting without real reasons
We realize we've stalled for too long and have to find a lynch option
morda says something about wanting a port near the East India Company
LC is very inactive, and has scummy posts when pressured
morda claims something that we think looks like an indie
Morda gets lynched, flipping town
Day 2-
Scattered survives the N1 kill
The port for Day 1 causes our items to go to random targets, causing me to accidentally pass the anti-town Wooden Eyeball to LC, which causes me to want to lynch him even more, to get rid of it.
Almost nobody puts up an resistance or alternative ideas, including LC, who ignores every post made against him.
LC gets lynched, flipping town
Night 2-
The port for Day 2 allows us to talk on Night 2.
The conversation is basically inconsequential
Day 3-
We start pushing some fairly bad lynch options, such as RF, Rainy, and jade. Lord is gaining momentum when
Camo subs in, and declares Keeper and lord to be the best lynch options, with Keeper as the best
Keeper and lord both have a large chance of getting lynched, but it is Keeper who is lynched in the end.
Keeper survives the lynch.
Day 4-
We discuss whether or not we should try to lynch Keeper again.
Keeper claims to have survived the Night 3 kill and also claims to have had his item stolen.
Scattered counter-claims.
I push for lord instead of Keeper, but then a combination of scattered, Drac, Lord, and Jade proves Keeper was lying.
Part of the proof is that Keeper strangely passed a good item to lord, who he said he thought was scum.
We lynch Keeper again, but he again survives the lynch.
The case on Jade is not bad 
But sure , explain why it is not good.
But sure , explain why it is not good.
Also, you were the one who actually said it was a good case.. NP. And that story of yours on the item that you knew about on LC and yet opened a case against them.. that makes you very scummy in case my theory about Jade-Lord-Keeper scum team is wrong.
Jade was probably the best of those three cases, but everyone is right in that he is playing like a newbie town who plays the newbie card way too much. Maybe that is because he's a member of the scumteam and they've told him to do that? No matter what, lord and Keeper are much more likely scum.
Newbies react when people agree that they're scummy. That's the best chance to get a read on them.
What?
Couldn't be more wrong, but even so, good luck with that.
Wit town needing to lynch scum today, and there being 10 players left, that means there's, what, 4 scum? 40% chance now no matter what we do. (Actually, even better odds than that since we count me out.) So lynch anyone that isn't Camo, SM, or NP and you're pretty much golden.
You’re Abner Pintel, and you’re aligned with The Motley Crew. Referred to by Captain Jack as “the belligerent homunculus,” you’re one half of what is perhaps the least competent pair of pirates to ever sail the seas. But hey, that doesn’t stop you from trying!
Passive Ability: Cursed Gold
You were cursed once, by a chest of Aztec gold. You’ve long since put as much distance as you could between yourself and it, but it seems you can’t escape the curse entirely. As such, if you come into possession of the Pirate Medallion, your vote weight is 2 when voting during the Day Phase for the crew’s choice of port.
Passive Ability: Belligerent Ignorance
All your bluster is good for something, apparently––you haven’t got a clue what’s going on! Since no one can make you listen to them (or honestly just couldn’t be bothered), your Abilities cannot be stolen, copied, disabled, or otherwise affected by other players. (The targets of your Abilities can still be affected.)
Active Ability: That’s the Truth of It
You don’t really know a whole lot, but sometimes a thought will hit you like a seagull’s droppings, though you’re not really sure from where. Each Night Phase, you may PM the hosts the name of a port. You will find out the full effect of that port in a short summary.
Win Condition: All threats to the Motley Crew are eliminated.
Passive Ability: Cursed Gold
You were cursed once, by a chest of Aztec gold. You’ve long since put as much distance as you could between yourself and it, but it seems you can’t escape the curse entirely. As such, if you come into possession of the Pirate Medallion, your vote weight is 2 when voting during the Day Phase for the crew’s choice of port.
Passive Ability: Belligerent Ignorance
All your bluster is good for something, apparently––you haven’t got a clue what’s going on! Since no one can make you listen to them (or honestly just couldn’t be bothered), your Abilities cannot be stolen, copied, disabled, or otherwise affected by other players. (The targets of your Abilities can still be affected.)
Active Ability: That’s the Truth of It
You don’t really know a whole lot, but sometimes a thought will hit you like a seagull’s droppings, though you’re not really sure from where. Each Night Phase, you may PM the hosts the name of a port. You will find out the full effect of that port in a short summary.
Win Condition: All threats to the Motley Crew are eliminated.
Interesting, why do you say this?
Sure. While you're at it, mind giving us another possible scumspect and evidence (tangible, role-based evidence or a large scumslip made by somebody) to support it. Otherwise, your case will still be the best one.
Role:
Announcer/Motion Detector. Nothing really amazing here, but all those notes in "spidery handwriting" have been me.
Scumspect, well, Keeper is scum, we know this. However next in line for me is still Jade, for the reasons I stated before.
I still do not like how he put the town in this position. Had no one done anything a no lynch could have happened, and even with Keeper's ability to not die, this is still strange.
In response to rainy giving a scumread (on Jade of course) an attempt to help out the town, and he claims it's not a smart idea. Um...
- Status