Finished Mafia XL: Age of Piracy: Game Over!
- Thread starter Jabberwock
- Start date
- Status
I already revealed my role.
No you didn't. I know when you are lying. But that's ok. It no longer matters since you missed your chance to survive. Let's finish this day up and just take Keeper out. Nothing else productive will come of today.
I've decided you don't know what you think you know. But the town always sheeps behind you regardless, so the game has already ended. I'm kinda done playing anyway.
See you all tomorrow.
Did nobody see this? Either Keeper and lord are in a scumteam (why would Keeper pass an item to someone he thinks is scum), or lord is the person with the monkey (who seems to be scum). I don't know the details of scattered's ability, but I would think there's a chance the monkey might show up. Both of those scenarios incriminates lord. Only one incriminates Keeper. Considering they are the scummiest people in the game, lord is the better vote.
P.S. If lord flips as the person with the monkey, we Keeper might be a townie. Otherwise, Keeper's a scumbuddy with her.
This came out of nowhere. First off, how is he in any way confirmed he's not scum, second, what makes him specifically the indie?
Anyone who isn't town is a threat to the town.
This is correct. However he wouldn't give the item to actual scum. He knew someone would figure out who he passed it to.
What does this even mean?
I didn't pass you an item, or at least didn't to my knowledge. By everything I can tell from SM and Drac, it seems like somebody gave me an item and passed it to somebody else without my knowing of it. Or one of them is lying.
How would I know if you're scum or not? Unless you're saying by us being scum buddies I wouldn't pass you the item because yeah that makes sense.
And how could I possibly know somebody would be able to tell who I passed the item to?
@Keeper of Night Can you show us the PM of you being stolen from by the monkey?
The can't be scum thing is disproved by scattered being the kill target again, but at the time seemed right. Keeper is incredibly scummy, which leads me to believe he is not a townie. If he couldn't be a scum but isn't a townie either, he's an indie.
Some indies are fine (like survivor indies). Others are dangerous.
100% WIFOM. Who would expect a item tracker to exist, let alone decide to track Keeper?
Lynch Keeper and then Lord.
In case Keeper is an indie/scum - this is one of our only chances because we know he doesn't have any items to save him from a lynch.
Lord can be lynched tomorrow. Also, I think she slipped. I'll check something and get back to you.
In case Keeper is an indie/scum - this is one of our only chances because we know he doesn't have any items to save him from a lynch.
Lord can be lynched tomorrow. Also, I think she slipped. I'll check something and get back to you.
This is the slip. Lord can't know that this is correct. When someone passes you an item, the host only tells you that you received an item, without specifying from who.
The reasons I think we should lynch Keeper first are:
a. This is one of our only chances. Keeper is immune to lynches if he holds that certain item. With my ability we now know that he doesn't have any items. And also safe claims tends to be close to the real thing. So for example if there is a role that says -Lynchproof by an item scum, then the safe claim would be - Deathproof/lynchproof by an item town.
b. If Lord and Keeper are scumbuddies, there is a chance that the claim is entirely false, and that the item they have is a lynchproof item. There is already a bulletproof item (which I have right now), so it would come to no surprise that the game has this item as well. If so, and Keeper passed it to Lord, then lynching Lord would result in once again, no lynch.
c. We can afford it and we can lynch Lord tomorrow. Not the best reason, but w/e
Except the item that you and Drac say I had and passed isn't a lynchproof item. In fact it should only add vote weight, according to Drac, who apparently passed it to me.
But then if Drac is lying and I'm not, then the item is what I said it was and is confirmed to be a pirate-specific item (why would scum get use out of a pirate medallion?). Which was stolen either way. Which then leads to questions as to why Drac would lie, but I don't think he did.
Meaning Lorde, you should have attained an item that improves vote weight, since that is what Drac sent to me and what SM says was passed from me to you. Except I never had knowledge of it for whatever reason. (I feel like whoever has the monkey had a part of that as well, perhaps the item was replaced?).
KoN your quote on #529 said the item was stolen before you passed to NP. My PM about the item specifically said you received the item. Not swooped by other.
I... Don't quite understand what you mean. I was the one targeted, so I can't see why you would receive any sort of alert.
I was only saying I had received an item as being correct, and since Keeper had sent the Pirate Medallion to someone, should I say what the item was? Because that's not the name of the item I received.
I though you said you were targetted on Night 3, I sent you the item on Night 2
Agreeing with this post. I'm wondering if that's really the condition for Keeper's lynchproof. Maybe, Drac really did pass him that item and Keeper's just lying about it (which explains why I find it so hard to believe his ability). My other question is this: Is it worth it leaving the potential item thief in the game? Personally, I say yes.
##UNVOTE: lord o da rings
##VOTE: Keeper of Night
I don't think knowing the name of the item could help the scum, so I'd say that would be a good idea.
In that case, it's called the Siamese Coin Trinket.
- Status