Finished Mafia XL: Age of Piracy: Game Over!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Isn't this kind of contradictory to say that you both have something that can potentially provide that you are somewhat town yet you two are also the only two I would not mind lynching if we don't lynch the inactive?
Camo and sort-of Blakers have convinced me that I may be wrong on that. Maybe I'm being manipulated by the scum. In all honesty, I can't tell.
 
That doesn't change the fact that the phrase I quoted above was contradictory.

And in addition to add, it is very odd that 2 people that you suspect as scum "convinced" you.
 
TAE, I suspect literally everyone that hasn't had a nightkill attempted on them twice.
I may be getting Celever syndrome right now, since I don't need to care about "Looking Townie". TBH, Captain's Orders will confirm me as town once I reveal it.
 
tbh anyone can be like NP and say oh "I have an ability that will confirm me as town once I reveal it" and use it "tomorrow at the latest" considering today is mylo and a scum that leads the town to lynch someone else will never be lynched tomorrow when the reveal they bluffed because there will not be a tomorrow.
 
tbh anyone can be like NP and say oh "I have an ability that will confirm me as town once I reveal it" and use it "tomorrow at the latest" considering today is mylo and a scum that leads the town to lynch someone else will never be lynched tomorrow when the reveal they bluffed because there will not be a tomorrow.

Stop focusing on soft cleared towns minutes before the end of MYLO. NP gave me the item that makes you immune to the nightkill, and that is how I survived.

Our best options are Blakers Camo or Rainy, as it seems now.
 
Well as I said earlier, rainy is what my gut tells me.

An active forum member that does not make a single post during the entirety of Day 6, which is mylo.

Seriously?
 
tbh anyone can be like NP and say oh "I have an ability that will confirm me as town once I reveal it" and use it "tomorrow at the latest" considering today is mylo and a scum that leads the town to lynch someone else will never be lynched tomorrow when the reveal they bluffed because there will not be a tomorrow.
I can use it today. I just believe it is best to wait until tomorrow.
P.S. @Blakers is viewing the thread. Can you give opinions on what's going on (and then get on the Doc for our game)?
 
We're going to have to decide on one lynch candidate for the day, because we're running out of time. Camo/NP/Me is too risky, Keeper will get us nowhere, scattered is basically confotown, and while TAE may or may not be lying, that still isn't a risk that Town can afford to take right now. That leaves rainy and Celever. While Celever is the safer lynch in my opinion, if rainy flips scum we'll be in a better position the next day. But especially given his inactivity, I think rainy should go.
 
That leaves rainy and Celever. While Celever is the safer lynch in my opinion, if rainy flips scum we'll be in a better position the next day. But especially given his inactivity, I think rainy should go.
What? This reasoning makes no sense. In MYLO, you should always vote the people that you think are scum.
 
That is, more likely to be scum. Don't try to be opportunistic.
Ok, fine. I'm going with Celever then. Given my results from overnight, the fact that Captain of the Ship can redirect a Nightkill, Celever's long inactivity stretch, and his poor reasoning against me, I think he's our best option. Rainy is a solid option, but in my opinion Celever is better. Not to mention he bandwagoned yesterday and is probably trying to earn town cred by jumping on the bandwagon that either me or Camo is scum.
 
We're going to have to decide on one lynch candidate for the day, because we're running out of time. Camo/NP/Me is too risky, Keeper will get us nowhere, scattered is basically confotown, and while TAE may or may not be lying, that still isn't a risk that Town can afford to take right now. That leaves rainy and Celever. While Celever is the safer lynch in my opinion, if rainy flips scum we'll be in a better position the next day. But especially given his inactivity, I think rainy should go.

Can you please give me a way to prove that Im not lying then, cause if I actually got nothing to use, theres nothing I can do to prove I have nothing @.@

I would be more than happy to provide people with whatever they wish... granted its in my role thing to begin with cause I already quoted basically everything serious. ._.
(By basically I mean everything except the post where cyber/cypher or whoever said he wanted to sub out and all those posts that jabber called reinforce a lazy landlubber or whatever).
 
Now that I have read blakers' reasoning, blakers ended up on scummy radar due to his really bad reasoning in both posts.

Again, contradiction in the first post. Logic is kind of flawed, which NP already pointed out I think.

Also how can one possibly claim their own lynch as "risky". Its downright bad for the person that is lynched, and the other players' view should not affect your own view as to which is a good lynch.

Then, after NP points out Blakers flawed logic, he just flipped flopped to Celever basically in an instant.
 
Can you please give me a way to prove that Im not lying then, cause if I actually got nothing to use, theres nothing I can do to prove I have nothing @.@

I would be more than happy to provide people with whatever they wish... granted its in my role thing to begin with cause I already quoted basically everything serious. ._.
(By basically I mean everything except the post where cyber/cypher or whoever said he wanted to sub out and all those posts that jabber called reinforce a lazy landlubber or whatever).
There's no way to prove you guilty or innocent at this point. Thus, you may or may not be lying.

Now that I have read blakers' reasoning, blakers ended up on scummy radar due to his really bad reasoning in both posts.

Again, contradiction in the first post. Logic is kind of flawed, which NP already pointed out I think.

Also how can one possibly claim their own lynch as "risky". Its downright bad for the person that is lynched, and the other players' view should not affect your own view as to which is a good lynch.

Then, after NP points out Blakers flawed logic, he just flipped flopped to Celever basically in an instant.
1. In what ways is my reasoning bad and my logic flawed?
2. Of course it would be risky. Between me, NP, and Camo, we have a 1/3 chance at best of finding scum. Who wants to take those odds in MYLO? Especially when it may be that none of us are scum?
3. You make it sound like me switching to Celever was completely random. It wasn't.
 
We're going to have to decide on one lynch candidate for the day, because we're running out of time. Camo/NP/Me is too risky, Keeper will get us nowhere, scattered is basically confotown, and while TAE may or may not be lying, that still isn't a risk that Town can afford to take right now. That leaves rainy and Celever. While Celever is the safer lynch in my opinion, if rainy flips scum we'll be in a better position the next day. But especially given his inactivity, I think rainy should go.
There's no way to prove you guilty or innocent at this point. Thus, you may or may not be lying.


1. In what ways is my reasoning bad and my logic flawed?
2. Of course it would be risky. Between me, NP, and Camo, we have a 1/3 chance at best of finding scum. Who wants to take those odds in MYLO? Especially when it may be that none of us are scum?
3. You make it sound like me switching to Celever was completely random. It wasn't.


1. In what ways is my reasoning bad and my logic flawed?

> Camo/NP/Me is too risky

What part is risky? 2 of the 3 of are deemed somewhat scummy by the remaining players, and the 3rd just started acting scummy for whatever reason. Granted, NP is actually too risky, but the other 2 options are a legitimate option.

> While Celever is the safer lynch in my opinion, if rainy flips scum we'll be in a better position the next day.

NP Pointed this part out above like I said.

2. Of course it would be risky. Between me, NP, and Camo, we have a 1/3 chance at best of finding scum. Who wants to take those odds in MYLO? Especially when it may be that none of us are scum?

What makes you think it is at best? For all I know, all 3 of you can be scum and it can be a fake chat that is actually just the scum chat. It can also be 2/3 scum, the hosts don't have any restrictions in who to make neighbors, and nobody has any other evidence to prove otherwise. So for all we know the true statistic is 2 or 3 out of 3. However the case, the guaranteed statistic I think is how many ever scum are alive out of how many ever are left. I am frankly unsure lol.

3. You make it sound like me switching to Celever was completely random. It wasn't.

I did not make it sound random. I pointed out the fact that your vote switched basically in 1 minute due to NP's response for whatever reason.
 
I'm down for Blakers. The idea that he has really never used his ability then randomly used it today and struck right doesn't sit well with me. I'm not sure if he's better than Rainy or Celever though. Need to read.
 
So uh the vote ends in 1 hour and 43 minutes.

Celever is fast asleep and prob won't wake up in the next 2 hours...

Ill personally place my vote in an hour or so, its a toss up between Blakers which is on my new found scum radar list, and Rainy the inactive.
 
Blakers is my top choice now. I can't justify lynching an inactive when there's so much evidence here. If Rainyman is scum, the problem lies in the nature of werewolf on the site and we have to do a serious revamp of activity rules.
 
I'm fairly certain Ninja is town so that leaves Blakers. Ninja has been the only thing gluing this town together and it would have been extremely for a scum Ninja to allow the game to dissolve into nothing.
 
I was planning on lynching rainy so I could use my ability on Celever, which is why I said lynching rainy would put Town in the best spot. But we need to ensure that we get scum today.

##VOTE: Celever
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top